6 ms·
Marry Him: The case for settling for Mr. Good Enough
- teach 17y agoThis is an interesting article; thanks for posting it. However, I enjoyed The Last Psychiatrist's deconstruction of it more: http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2010/02/dont_settle_for_the_man_you_wa.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2010/02/dont_settle_for_the_m...
- ardit33 17y agoIt might sound awful, but this is one of the reasons I avoid dating 28+ girls (I am 29 myself). 1. Too much pressure. (even if it is not explicit, given her standing, it is implicit) 2. I don't know if she likes me for me, or just because her clock is ticking. On the flip side, girls it have really really easy on their early 20s. That might create an "suply is infinite" kind of thinking in girls, and maybe perhaps even a degree of narcisism sets in (I am demanded, I deserver x, and y, and of course z qualities on a bf/ideal partner). Some girls just fail to realise that past 26 (maybe 28 for asian girls), looks tend to fade. (fertility peak is 22). So, absent a family presure, it is easy to get comfortable thinking this attention they get is normal, and will last for a long time. Hence, they hit their late 20s/early 30s with extremely high expectations, yet their perceived value has diminished with time (at least looks wise). Many girls realize this, and end up being in "settling mode", which honestly, if you are a guy sucks. She will not love you for what you really are. To be honest if I had a daughter, my advice would be find a good one between 25-28. That's where your should be wise enough to know what you want, but still have time to change your mind if you feel it is not the right thing.
- iamwil 17y agoHow about the case for older women? http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/2010/02/16/the-case-for-an-older-woman/ http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/2010/02/16/the-case-for-an...
- randallsquared 17y agoThat only works if you want to have kids immediately, or want to never have kids. If, like me, you're a guy who wants to have kids in 5-10 years, late-30s women are just out of the running, no matter what great qualities they may have otherwise. Due to biology, the marriageable age range for women doesn't really change as a guy gets older, unless he's done having kids or doesn't want them.
- benpbenp 17y agoYour comment reminded me of Ben Franklin's case for older women. http://www.swarthmore.edu/SocSci/bdorsey1/41docs/51-fra.html http://www.swarthmore.edu/SocSci/bdorsey1/41docs/51-fra.html
- vitobcn 17y agoI don't think your comment sounds awful, but in my opinion you are giving too much importance to age and looks. I am 28 myself and when dating I am not trying to evaluate whether she already passed her prime time or if she still has a couple of good years cause she is Asian. Unless you are a teenager or in the early twenties, we are all going downhill. Shouldn't we try to find a partner who we like and share interests with, regardless of age (obviously, there are some boundaries). It seems you don't want a girl to 'settle' with you, but there's a ton of reasons to do so independently of her age. Maybe she wants you only for your money, or your looks...
- kpanghmc 17y agoI think the OP's main point was that when you date a woman in her 30s, there's a lot of pressure to get married and have babies ASAP. Because while it's certainly possible for a woman to become pregnant in their 30s, the chances pretty much go into a freefall during that decade. So even though as a man, you stand a higher chance with women in that age range, you'll always have this lingering doubt of whether she's with you because she wants you or if she's with you because she's running out of time. You're right though that there are plenty of other reasons a woman could be interested in you, but I think you might be underestimating just how loud that biological clock is ticking in a woman's brain when she hits 30.
- indiejade 17y agoPerspective changes as you get older. Besides, women live longer than men, and reach their prime later. There are a lot of reasons it makes sense for a female to date a male who is slightly younger than him. So. . . I daresay that the comment does sound pretty awful. Awful is probably the wrong word. Delusional, megalomaniac, may be better words. Anybody who doesn't have a bell curve around the ages of people they're willing to date (yes, with his/her own age in the middle) is probably missing a few logic gates. Given the gendercide and such, it's pretty certain that the world will never have shortage of creepy old men.
- philk 17y agoSo. . . I daresay that the comment does sound pretty awful. Awful is probably the wrong word. Delusional, megalomaniac, may be better words. Anybody who doesn't have a bell curve around the ages of people they're willing to date (yes, with his/her own age in the middle) is probably missing a few logic gates. I think that's a bit judgemental. It's okay for people to have preferences regarding who they date. If one of these preferences is for younger women, well, that's up to them. There are girls out there with preferences for richer men or taller men and we don't go around accusing them of "missing a few logic gates". As an example, suppose you're an older guy (~45 yo) looking to get married and have kids. Your preferences are obviously going to tend towards younger women because you'll have a better chance of conceiving and healthier kids. This doesn't imply that you're crazy, or creepy. It simply implies that you have particular life plans and have a preference for getting together with someone who is compatible with these.
- kingkawn 17y agoThe desire to systematize every aspect of life is why you're still just dating.
- slig 17y agoThis made me think in a way I never thought before. Thanks.
- philk 17y agoI'm really not sure why you're using "just dating" pejoratively. The GP might feel no desire to settle down or might enjoy repeating the initial rush through serial monogamy. Alternatively, he may be open to the prospect of marriage but not be sufficiently dedicated to it to be marrying someone who feels that they're just settling for him.
- jcnnghm 17y agoThe grandparent isn't exactly old, and he is right.
- pvg 17y agoBy the same logic, no woman should ever come near you since she can't know if you like her for her or because you are driven by the genetic imperative to spread your semen around.
- tome 17y agoNo, the GP's point is very specifically that the biological imperative is time constrained for a woman whilst it isn't for a man.
- pvg 17y agoHow is that relevant? I won't date a woman older than X because her clock is ticking and it might mean she doesn't like me for my sparkling personality. It is identically silly to 'I won't date any man because he might only be trying to get into my pants'. If you don't like dating women your age or older, more power to you. But rationalizing it away by some sort of ersatz pop-logic and sweeping generalization (is every 30-year-old woman a fading flower hell-bent on reproduction?) is disingenuous.
- switch 17y agoyou're lucky if you only find 28+ girls who are dying to get married. Almost every girl I meet above 23 is looking to get hitched. Around 25 they learn to pretend they don't want it but they keep pushing things in that direction.
- Tichy 17y agoCouldn't there be a third way: make demands less strict in society? I remember reading that women in Iceland are among the happiest on the planet, because they are not under so much strain to sustain a relationship forever. It is not frowned upon to break up. Women just move back with families and date again. Since > 50% of marriages seem to break anyway (if I remember correctly), maybe it would be better to approach things in a more relaxed way to begin with. Maybe then men also wouldn't be so afraid to settle - for a while.
- nfnaaron 17y agoSomeone in the marriage breakup industry told me that 75% of all second marriages fail. I think we should have five and ten year civil contracts, with options to renew. What you do religiously is your own business.
- tokenadult 17y agoSomeone in the marriage breakup industry told me that 75% of all second marriages fail. That's the kind of statement to rigorously fact-check before believing it. Most estimates of divorce rates (in terms of percentages of all marriages that will end in divorce) are overestimates. http://www.divorcereform.org/nyt05.html http://www.divorcereform.org/nyt05.html
- wisty 17y agoSome Muslim groups permit those marriages. I forget which.
- kpanghmc 17y agoThat wouldn't work so great for men / women who elect to become househusbands / housewives upon marriage. While the other partner spends those 10 years building their career, they toil away at home cleaning, preparing meals, and raising the kids, only to be left high and dry when their partner declines to renew. Now what are they to do? They have little job experience to build upon. Unless your solution comes with alimony / child support, I don't see how it would work. And if it did, what's so different about it than getting a divorce?
- andreyf 17y agoLori Gottlieb, in The Atlantic, writes "Marry Him!", and describes a problem so pervasive and urgent it's hard to imagine Obama hasn't cleared his desk: what's an "independent," "feminist," "heterosexual" 40-something "woman" with a sperm-donor child to do when she can't find a man to marry her? I found this analysis of the author much more interesting than the original article: http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2010/02/dont_settle_for_the_man_you_wa.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2010/02/dont_settle_for_the_m...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- rglullis 17y agoThis is just an analysis of the author, in no point it addresses the issue that she mentions. The "psych" just calls her ideas "dangerous" in the end, and sticks to an ad-hominem. I'd like to read someone who can actually find a counter-argument to her thesis and convince me that the best thing women can do is to hold on to their ideal all the way to the end.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Xichekolas 17y agoI'm not sure that counterargument could really be made. Anyone holding out for an ideal person is going to be looking forever. Everyone has faults. The relationship depends on whether you can still be happy despite those faults. That said, I think Lori is totally misguided. She feels she hasn't found a guy because her standards were too high, and that now she needs to lower them and "settle". Maybe she hasn't found a guy because she was too busy measuring guys by some predefined standards, and missed out on having fun. At the end of the day, standards and faults don't really matter if you enjoy being with the other person.
- rglullis 17y agoI completely agree with you. Thing is, I also think that Lori is not the exception, but may be very well part of the larger group. In that light, the article is something much more important and interesting.
- pvg 17y agoThe Cosmo-ification of HN continues apace. Next week, esr's sex tips FAQ. I know someone will very earnestly explain to me how this is on topic but really, it isn't.
- zackattack 17y agoErlang innards are hard. Let's go shopping.
- incomethax 17y agoSpoken like a true Barbie Computer Engineer
- codexon 17y agoI personally don't find these types of articles interesting either, but the HN guidelines say this: On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. So if this story has upvotes, I presume some "good hackers" here have found it interesting.
- derefr 17y agoYou presume wrongly. Communities begin with a "primary demographic"—people who are there for what it says on the tin. Over time, though, these communities start to lure in "secondary demographics" that are interested in both the community topic and other topics, but then those people in turn lure in "tertiary demographics," who aren't interested in the stated purpose of the community at all, only about the hybrid on-/off-topic stuff the secondary demographic posts. The tertiary demographic then posts stories like this one, which the secondary demographic upvotes, and the primary tolerates because they value the participation of the secondary demographic. Before you know it, the tertiary utterly dominates the community, and there is no more topic to be "on topic" about (especially in communities where "on topic" is small and static, but the community allows growth despite this.)
- jseliger 17y ago
- elptacek 17y agoThis article is long and makes me want to throw something at Lori Gottlieb. Not that I'm advocating violence or would commit it... it's just written in that sort of smug, grating style that makes me browse away after the first 10 paragraphs. All she has done is rebranded the concept of "compromise" (important in all sorts of relationships) as "settling." Nothing new or fascinating, there. The deconstruction is hilarious. Thanks for posting it. I read all of it. The civil contract idea is intriguing and creepy at the same time. Part of me thinks, "...or just don't get married in the first place?" That the government is involved with what is, effectively, a religious sacrament, boggles me a little. But that's a whole 'nother discussion. After 11.5 years (and yes, that .5 is important), I'm starting to feel like a veteran on marriage. Like Gottlieb, my perspective on what 'Mr Right' is has changed significantly. To wit, if I had advice to give to young women, it wouldn't be to "settle," but to find someone young, intelligent and not too hard to look at and train him.* By way of example, tptacek is currently in the kitchen making a chicken caesar salad. * What this really means: grow together. It's difficult, but better than turning 40 and "settling."
- thegoleffect 17y agoYeah, when I read the article it sounded like this passive mindset. Why leave it to chance when you can train someone hehe! That, to me, is the right attitude.
- btilly 17y agoWhat's the saying? Men marry women expecting that they won't change and they do. Women marry men expecting that they will change and they don't. Yes, some men are trainable. But you had better verify that he's sufficiently trainable for your needs before marrying him.
- elptacek 17y agoThis sounds like a great self-help book. Think it'd get me on Oprah?
- btilly 17y ago
- donaq 17y agoThis article could be mapped readily into "Get a real job: The case for settling for a steady paycheck."
- rajat 17y agoDon't you think the lesson could be applied to startups? Do you try to work with the co-founders you have, or do you search incessantly for the perfect one (ie. Bill Gates, or Wozniak)? Do you wait for the perfect, home-run idea, or do you pick one you have and make it work? I've heard so many people in real jobs moan about how they would do a startup if only they had the right idea. Or that they didn't think they and their potential partners could learn enough about business to make it. They're waiting for the perfect opportunity and circumstances, as if such things fall out of the sky magically, instead of being built and molded by hard work.
- Agile_Cyborg 17y agoIn the long run marriage should be a last resort. The vector from mama's vagina to the pine box may not be straight but it IS very short. Heaven is a fantasy so do your best to live peacefully and passionately. Marriage contains a bit of wonder surrounded by pitfalls aplenty. It is best engaged in by the simplistic and rigid.
- maxharris 17y agoWomen are people too - they are not just bags of meat that must have babies to be happy. Don't ever settle, because doing that is always a certain path to endless misery and longing for what you could have had. Yes, life is short, but that's all the more reason to stick to your ideals, and make sure that you choose your ideals carefully (so that you're successful!) Just think about how settling would ruin your honesty. Imagine what it would be like if you were to see your spouse and think, "I thought I could do better than you, but I gave up trying to find someone decent. You're okay, I guess." Settling requires you to take these thoughts and "set them aside" - evade them - constantly. Doing this does not result in love, or a happy life for anyone (including the children of divorced parents).
- cliveholloway 17y agoHere's a rational approach that may be appreciated here :) Make a concious decision to try and settle down with one of the first 6 girls you date. Here's the rules: 1) don't settle for the first one you date. 2) the next one you date that is better than the first one you dated is the one you settle for. Why? Do the math. Let's label them 123456. If you date 1 first, you have 1 in 5 chance of ending up with any of the others (1 in 30 for each) If you date 2 first, you end up with 1 (1 in 6) If you date 3 first, you can end up with 1 or 2 (1 in 12 each) If you date 4 first, you can end up with 1, 2 or 3 (1 in 18 each) If you date 5 first, you end up with 1, 2, 3 or 4 (1 in 24 each) If you date 6 first, you end up with 1,2 .. 5 (1 in 30 each). Add that up, and the odds of you settling for each woman are: 1 - 38.1%, 2 - 24.7%, 3 - 16.4%, 4 - 10.1%, 5 - 6.7%, 6 - 3.3% So, 79.2% of the time you "settle" for someone above average. And, for the other 20.8%? You can always split up before it's too late :)
- fizx 17y agoYou should look at http://www.parabola.unsw.edu.au/vol45_no2/node2.html http://www.parabola.unsw.edu.au/vol45_no2/node2.html which derives that the best strategy is to use the first 1/e of your potential dating life to set a baseline, and then choose the best partner that exceeds it.
- BearOfNH 17y agoand then choose the best partner that exceeds it Meaning, choose the next candidate who is better than the previous ones.
- huherto 17y agoVery interesting. The example for a young man that wants to get married between 20-39 is to date until 27 and then marry the best partner that exceeds it. In the case of a woman is different. Assuming her prime is between 20-33; her strategy should be to date until 24 and then marry the best man that exceeds it. right? edit: grammar
- mklg1266 17y agoI hate being a 20-something women. Everybody on the planet, from doctors to HN, feels the need to comment on the apparently glaring biological clock ticking over my head, and make assumptions about A) my happiness and B) my nefarious ulterior dating motives. I will posit that there exist women who don't base their self-worth and happiness entirely on the approval and acceptance of a man. I will further posit that there are women who aren't married by 30 because they haven't met someone they want to marry yet and are totally OK with that. Later first marriages are more likely to last anyway. (And do men really want to be settled for? Like "sure I'll marry you; you're not totally horrible"?)
- owinebarger 17y agoI thought the obsession with the clock and nefarious ulterior dating motives didn't start until 30-something. Now that you mention it, though, when did marriage and children become either nefarious or ulterior reasons for dating?
- arojahn 17y agoI'm a female entrepreneur aged 32, happily unmarried. Yes, there are women out there 'who aren't married by 30 because they haven't met someone they want to marry yet and are totally OK with that.' - I'm one of them. But this kind of article is the reason why it's sometimes hard - because no-one will ever believe you if you claim that you are not set on getting married and you're not keen on having kids. I've even heard the theory that I founded two startups because I didn't find the right guy to marry and have kids with.
- alnayyir 17y ago>heard the theory that I founded two startups because I didn't find the right guy to marry and have kids with. I generally flinch in the presence of feminist rhetoric (not saying that you were engaging in rhetoric, demonstrating my leaning), but that is crass and offensive. Why can't people just do what works for them? Yeeeesh.
- Tichy 17y ago"aren't married by 30 because they haven't met someone they want to marry yet" It seems to become more difficult with age, though. Easy for you to be annoyed, if you are still in your twenties. What if you are 40? A lot of things will look different by then, I think so much is safe to assume.
- rajat 17y agoFrom the vantage point of a 20-year marriage: it's always about compromising, about settling. My wife and I had, I suppose, one of those romantic, instant connections. She's from Sweden, my parents are from India and I grew up in the Bronx. We ran into each other at IBM Research, and we moved in together on our second date. Instant chemistry, very romantic. But during the 20 years of marriage, the way we met didn't matter. Marriage is something else than about that initial burst of lust, or gushing romance or whatever. When you get woken up at 4 in the morning by your soulmate because the dog needs to go outside to pee and she certainly isn't about to leave the warm bed, believe me, romantic love is not what makes you jump out of bed. I think we have unrealistic expectations about romance. Living together is freaking hard; giving up one's independence and having to be ready to compromise about every damned last thing in life (except maybe what you do in the potty) is hard. And once you compromise, if you're smart and want to stay happy, you have to be enthusiastic about the compromise, or you get bitter. Be happy, even when you didn't get what you want. Still, despite all the compromises, all the things we had to work out, here I am 20 years later, and the love I had for her on that first day we met seems like a pale imitation to what I feel today. You have to work at it, and you end up with something a lot more. I don't know about settling, but instant love connection or not, making the marriage work is the hard part, and the real love in life comes from that work.
- altano 17y agoCongrats on the many years together. It sounds like you (and presumably your wife) have a great attitude. Reminds me of the dialogue from Good Will Hunting where Robbin Williams explains what he misses most about his wife (she died of cancer). > and the love I had for her on that first day we met seems like a pale imitation to what I feel today It's only people who realize that compromise, distance, and honesty are some of the ingredients required to bring two people together (happily) for life.
- jf 17y agoThanks for sharing this. I'm about to hit my one year anniversary and it's advice like yours that I'm keeping in mind for the long run.
- impeachgod 17y ago
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- owinebarger 17y agoFirst, "settling" is a highly offensive term. Anyone using that term is living in a fantasy world. I read the author as using it facetiously, though, since that is pretty much the point of the article. Second, she soundly observes that marriage is basically a business partnership, except she considers it nonprofit (I do not). Assuming you aren't somehow committed to the single life, you should evaluate marriage opportunity based on your appetite for risk and a frank assessment of the opportunity at hand. Just as you shouldn't base decisions on sunk costs, you should ignore illusory opportunity costs. Physical capital decays, if you want a return on it you'll have to take a risk before it loses all of its production capacity. Of course, the older you get without taking a plunge, the easier it becomes to see the illusory nature of the opportunity cost you might have been using. This all assumes you have a marriage opportunity that you can see having a profitable return (profit measured in happiness here). I would go so far as to say that it's impossible to judge marriage as an institution to be inherently profitable for you personally; it will always depend on the particulars. You might think marriage sounds like the place you want to be, but if you don't find a good partner for yourself in particular, marriage isn't for you. As long as you don't have kids and both spouses have careers, getting out of the marriage is relatively easy. On the other hand, you only get one life, don't waste it avoiding risks whose most catastrophic downsides are not that bad. I have assumed you aren't marrying a black widow or having kids with an affinity for patricide/matricide. But worrying about the latter is like worrying about being hit by lightning while not batting an eyelash over driving a car regularly. Avoiding the former is a matter of due diligence.
- tome 17y agoI found this fascinating link about Lori Gottlieb: http://jezebel.com/5467630/email-interview-with-lori-gottliebs-ex-tim http://jezebel.com/5467630/email-interview-with-lori-gottlie...
- etherael 17y agoWestern social marriage patterns confuse the hell out of me. It appears to me that the vast majority of men are literally looking to marry a supermodel, beyond that very little beside if she'll laugh at his jokes and be nice appears to matter. Women on the other hand appear to have all manner of weird neuroses about what constitutes "Mr Right.", so vast is the span of options it is not possible to really outline them all, they even conflict in many cases "Works hard, financially secure, can take the kids to soccer practice and let me focus on my career". At any rate, I don't understand why from a man's perspective marrying a woman from abroad isn't the obvious option. They tend not to have the lifestyle that contributes to what is fundamentally the definition of "average human appearance" being skewed wildly with weight or the long term effects of cosmetics on skin quality etc etc etc. For what it's worth for me personally, I think all you humans are crazy and I'm perfectly happy to not be codependent, but whatever blows your hair back.