6 ms·
I don't think the problem is the fact that Peter Thiel tossed money in the direction of a lawsuit. The issue is that money matters in justice, and that Peter Th
by threatofrain 10y ago
I don't think the problem is the fact that Peter Thiel tossed money in the direction of a lawsuit. The issue is that money matters in justice, and that Peter Thiel coincidentally put his money somewhere did not make this so.
People are focusing shame on Peter Thiel today but that's the wrong place. There will always be rich people.
- vintermann 10y agoNow, I agree with that. But it's not the argument other people are making. People are saying this is an attack on journalism, and complaining that Thiel could have bankrupted Gawker just by attrition. Yeah, he could. But that was not in fact what he did. Gawker didn't lose by attrition, they lost a particular case they damn well deserved to lose. On the other hand, Thiel says Gawker's former victims have been forced to settle for a pittance because of attrition on their end. That sounds entirely plausible. Money matters in court, by default that favours corporations (including media corporations like Gawker, and their $200-million owner Nick Denton) over all but the richest of individuals. That's the status quo, now the media are upset that it didn't work in their favor for once.
- atonse 10y agoYes, Gawker deserved to lose that case. However, the Thiel involvement produced a vindictive and revenge-based strategy to try the case in such a way that Gawker couldn't use their insurance to pay the damages. So I don't think anybody's arguing that Gawker shouldn't have lost that case. But it's clear the motive here wasn't just punishment, it was to put Gawker out of business. And I used to hate Gawker because of all this Valleywag nonsense they did, but they have a lot of good sites today.
- whamlastxmas 10y agoLike the site that sold that bought a stolen iPhone and bragged about it? If Gawker has any good content it's coincidence and not because they actively attempt to make it good.
- whamlastxmas 10y agoremove "that sold" from above, can't edit anymore.
- wl 10y agoPart of the purpose of tort law is to discourage tortfeasors from future misconduct. With a company as big as Gawker, insurance subverts this to some extent.
- martin_bech 10y agoI used to hate OJ Simpson because of the murders, but he was funny in the naked gun movies..
- vintermann 10y agoDo you think it should be possible to insure yourself out of liability for gross invasions of privacy? It's not the insurance company that has wronged him. It's perfectly reasonable for Bollea to seek deterrence rather than settlement money/damages. Anyone would prefer that, unless they were forced to settle for something else for money reasons. Usually the plaintiff would settle/go for damages because they have to prefer money, because going to court is damn expensive. So saying this was unfair and vindictive is presuming that the status quo, where money decides court cases, is just and reasonable. That Bollea should have been forced to go for the money because he's not really rich, he just has a rich backer. But I disagree with that. As long as money matters in court, the more people get access to multimillionaire justice the better.
- ctulek 10y agoIf Thiel didn't have a history with Gawker, I would believe to this nobel cause. However, it is obvious that he is using his power for personal revenge. The short article just tries to show that the new billionaires are not different than old billionaires. They won't hesitate to use their power for personal gain in any area. Well, you may say, of course, they will use their power for their personal gain. Well, yes, that is the point. Silicon Valley billionaires are not different.
- dpark 10y ago> If Thiel didn't have a history with Gawker, I would believe to this nobel cause. Thiel's history with Gawker is irrelevant to whether the cause is noble. If the cause is noble, it's noble regardless of who is funding it and why. If funding cancer research is noble, it is still noble even if you became interested because you had cancer.
- ctulek 10y agoI didn't discuss whether the cause is noble or not. I discussed whether what Peter Thiel is doing noble or not. I don't find his action noble. In other words, that someone supports a noble cause does not make them noble, one should also check their intentions.
- dpark 10y agoYou literally said "noble cause" (well, "nobel cause").
- mukmuk 10y agoI am also somewhat uncomfortable that his sponsorship was kept secret for so long, and that it easily could have stayed secret indefinitely.
- TheCondor 10y agoWhy does that matter?
- Eric_WVGG 10y agobecause then we would be more ignorant of how the world was operating. (Clearly you care or you wouldn't have wound up in this thread.)
- ryanlol 10y agoOne would have to be particularly ignorant for this to come as a surprise though. (Not specifically re: Gawker, but in general)
- TheCondor 10y agoThat's not the ignorance that interests me here. There have been gag rules and confidentiality clauses in settlements forever. Secrecy in lawsuits isn't super unusual. You have any idea how many deals are made before a lawsuit is even filed? it's all secret... The EFF, ACLU, ADL, and other organizations fund legal defense and law suits and even use it as a fund raiser sometimes and we don't comb through the donation rosters and suggest a perversion of justice based on the sources of donations. There are legal defense funds for various things quite regularly. There are victim funds that are put together by communities when certain crimes happen, those funds are presented as just life help for the victims but some of that money goes to lawyers sometimes. It's just not that unusual for people to get help paying for their lawyers. And it has nothing to do with the crime. Since Thiel revealed his involvement, that has been the story which makes me think maybe he was right to conceal it. his name and money had nothing to do with this crime. The fact is some people want other people to fail, they want their companies to fail, it may be rational or it may be irrational or it may be revenge based but society allows that. You can short a stock if you want, if you have enough money you can even affect the price of the stock. Gawker placed itself in a situation where it had substantial financial risk, Thiel simply exploited it. Don't make powerful enemies, don't break laws, this is avoidable stuff. It wasn't a frivolous lawsuit that some billionaire manipulated in to a company killer. Nobody's taken out tmz or drudge or many of the others.... It's also ironic, I'd argue that any deal to pay for lawyers is a private matter. The very existence of that privacy is a concept gawker doesn't seem to comprehend and that's what caused their problem in the first place.
- bko 10y agoOf course money matters in justice, as it matters with everything else. I can't imagine a system in which it doesn't matter. Perhaps if the Bar Association cartel was broken, lawyers would be less expensive, but there needs to be a kind of mechanism to allocate the judicial resources of the state.
- adamlett 10y agoYou really can't imagine? What if for example the losing party in a law suit was automatically forced to pay the legal expenses of the winning party? That is actually how it works many places outside of the US. It's quite effective at discouraging frivolous lawsuits, and it means that a rich person can't bankrupt a someone by waging a legal attrition war.
- qaq 10y agoSo you sue Walmart for 20K on some legitimate grounds but loose to their AAA legal team. Now you are on the hook for 700K of their legal expenses. It's already the case that a large players ability to outspend the small challenger serves as huge deterrent for smaller players to take on the big guys you want to make that deterrent X10 more powerful.
- ghaff 10y agoIt also means a non-rich person can't initiate a lawsuit because they'd be ruined if they lost. There are always uncertainties. Truly frivolous lawsuits tend to be dismissed pretty quickly in any case. But there are many reasonable cases where the outcome is nonetheless uncertain.
- adamlett 10y agoThe way that problem is solved is to grant the judge power to determine what amount is reasonable given the stakes of the case. You obviously don't get to hire 100 lawyers and claim that all of them are necessary for your defense. Really, this is a solved problem elsewhere.
- bko 10y ago
- chongli 10y agoThe issue is that money matters in justice Which reveals the lie behind the term "justice system". It's a judicial system. Its goal is to render judgments. Its relationship to justice exists only in the abstract.
- jdmichal 10y agoI had a thought in jest. But then I started thinking about it, and now I don't know whether it's a good idea or not: We need a single-payer legal system.
- internaut 10y agoIsn't that how Pyscho-Pass got a Sybil System? ;-)
- bakhy 10y ago> There will always be rich people. Peter Thiel is not an automaton. he is a human being. he bears responsibility for his actions. he might not be doing anything illegal, but it is perfectly justified to expect more of people than merely following the letter of the law, and as for the rest, anything goes! it is particularly justified to expect more from such influential people like him. he bears, if not legal, then moral responsibility. and after all, laws did not spring out of Zeus' head or something, we defined them, and situations like this, and discussions that they instigate, can change those laws.
- threatofrain 10y agoI don't like moral expectations, because I feel that it competes with precious narrative-time in public discourse with something far more interesting -- hard mechanisms. I believe in a policy / mechanistic fix of the importance of money in the judicial system, rather than spending time shaming one Peter Thiel. I don't like moral expectations because it works like a black box, which I would be okay with if only the results weren't so lacking and unreliable. When discourse is constrained by limited resources, I prefer to speak of mechanisms because I feel it has a more plausible relationship with moral results. When I'm one on one with you, then of course, we might discuss our moral framework and expectations, standards which may go far higher than brute mechanisms.
- bakhy 10y agoi can understand where you're coming from. i've felt exactly the same about Martin Shkreli. people just went crazy about him, and few asked how to change the system to not allow it. but still, even if the system is wrong, so is Shkreli. no system can be perfect. even in pure math you have Gödel. in the ugly gray world of real life, of human societies, it can only be worse. unpredictable outcomes, grey areas,.. they are unavoidable. so i think we must do both - create systems which try to guarantee good order, and always complement them with a human touch. and that means personal moral responsibility, and a duty to think of more than just satisfying the dead letter of the law. furthermore, a system which would exactly codify morality is probably impossible, or even deadly for society. (just imagine what it means to have laws covering everything that is immoral... it would be the most extremely totalitarian state imaginable.) a lot will always be left to people themselves, to decide and to enforce in this way, through open public discussions, and their ugly brother, public blaming and shaming. it not even clear: should we even make a law against what Mr Thiel is doing? the answer does not seem so easy to me. also, how could this discussion even take place if no one should judge the actions of Mr Thiel? what kind of abstract articles would we then be reading? "somebody somewhere did something, we can't say too much about what, so you don't figure out who it is"? :) BTW, is it not kinda funny to defend a well known libertarian by proposing a stricter system? :)