19 ms·
Thiel shows why tech billionaires are the new robber barons
- jgalt212 10y agoWhat I don't get is if Peter truly feels he was doing a public good by shutting down Gawker, why must he do so in secret? Would the mission be impaired if the sponsor were revealed or is Peter an underhanded snake?
- Kristine1975 10y agoMaybe he doesn't want to be in the spotlight. "Do good without bragging about it."
- 4bpp 10y agoI doubt the decision in the Gawker case was made in complete isolation from the public opinion, and public favour these days is significantly based upon who can depict themselves as the underdog/victim and therefore claim the moral high ground. Presumably, being financially supported by Thiel would not exactly have earned Hogan underdog points.
- geomark 10y agoFrom the article: "Many are growing disillusioned because they bought what Silicon Valley sold them: an idealistic and almost utopian vision in which the technological advances of the Information Age would change the world -- or at least the Western world -- for the universal good." Maybe it's just me, but I only occoasionally even heard of that idea, much less bought into it. Am I that far out of the echo chamber?
- rimunroe 10y agoI've heard that idea a LOT, especially from people 10-15 years ago. I think most people abandon that thinking pretty quickly, but it persists with a smaller but still significant number.
- theoh 10y agoIt was very much the stance of Wired magazine in the 90s, I think, and may still be. One major critique of that position is the "Californian Ideology" theory. Isn't the quoted passage essentially what Mark Zuckerberg claims to believe? What about Google's "don't be evil"?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- AlexB138 10y agoIt used to be a very common idea, but has fallen out of vogue in favor of more raw capitalist sentiment. There very much used to be an idea of changing the world for the better, but it died along with a lot of America's positive outlook in the post-9/11 era.
- Kurtz79 10y agoWhile not necessarily in these terms, it is something is not uncommon to see in the comments here in HN (as in "truck drivers should learn how to program" and stuff like that). While I feel there is a noticeable and unwarranted resentment growing in the media against SV (and I find kind of stupid binning so many people under the same umbrella), it is also true that many people in the environment do seem to suffer from naïveté and ivory tower syndrome, IMHO.
- CPLX 10y agoIf this strikes you as somewhat accurate and funny, then at some point you've heard the idea: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXuFrtmOYKg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXuFrtmOYKg
- DeusExMachina 10y agoFor the record, Scott Adams also believes in the philanthropic nature of Thiel's actions: http://blog.dilbert.com/post/145205211401/billionaire-branding-mistakes http://blog.dilbert.com/post/145205211401/billionaire-brandi...
- byuu 10y ago"I can't believe Scott Adams holds such a crazy opinion!" -- said nobody ever. I see no reason to take sides on this debacle. Both Nick Denton and Peter Thiel are guilty of absolutely awful behavior. Denton for outing people and publishing private videos; Thiel for Paypal (and its horrible practices) and using his wealth to bankroll personal vendettas. Both are happy to exploit others for their own personal gain. They deserve each other.
- NhanH 10y agoWhat exactly is the difference between "bankroll personal vendettas" and "fight against what you believe is bad"? The latter has to be broke and the former isn't?
- bakhy 10y agoif Mr Thiel wants to raise journalistic integrity standards when it comes to outing people, then the right things to do would be something like opening a public discussion, advocating some change in the law, etc. or perhaps, if he must use litigation, then focusing on suing all media that out people recklessly in this way. that would be a way more admirable approach. but this is not what Mr Thiel is doing. he is instead attacking just Gawker, for >10 years now, supporting any suit against them, and to top it all of, he is doing it secretively. the lesson the media are going to take away from this is not "we must behave morally", but rather, "we must be careful not to get any rich guy pissed at us". which is where these arguments about how Mr Thiel is hurting the freedom of the press are coming from.
- byuu 10y agoFunding a secret lawsuit against a company to try and destroy them for outing you as being gay is not good behavior. This has dangerous precedent for freedom of speech in journalism. If what Gawker did was illegal in outing him, he should have sued for that. If it were just morally objectionable, he should have called them on it and let the public decide how to respond. What this lawsuit says is, "say something about a rich person that they don't like (even if it's perfectly legal or maybe even in the public's best interest to know), and they'll fund covert lawsuits against you to destroy your entire business." That's not a world I want to live in, regardless of what I think of Gawker (they're the internet equivalent of The National Enquirer in my eyes.) We're taught this as children, "two wrongs don't make a right."
- supergirl 10y agoI wonder what's the connection, if any, between the author of the article and Gawker. If he's the same guy I found on Linkedin, he seems to be working for some kind of PR company for hire; also confirmed by the article footnote. I hope nobody takes this article only for what it is but also questions why it is.
- devishard 10y agoGood catch!
- michael_nielsen 10y agoFollowing that rabbit hole, the author seems to be this person: http://www.startegix.com/about.html http://www.startegix.com/about.html The first five things in the list of things his company does are: "Public Relations, Media Relations, Press Material Creation, Marketing Communications, Brand Positioning". It appears that Reuters is running unmarked advertising for Gawker or some other client with similar interests. Lovely.
- further_tech 10y agoEven if so, I'd rather move beyond the Ad hominem.
- dimino 10y agoIt's not an ad hominem, because the article isn't making an argument, and someone questioning his motives isn't saying he's wrong because of his motives.
- further_tech 10y agoThe article is making an argument (Thiel shows why tech billionaires are the new robber barons) and, regardless of the author's motives or background, I analyze his arguments. Claiming "isn't saying he's wrong because of his motives" is just reinforcing what I'm trying to say.
- plehoux 10y agoThis is totally BS. Litigation finance has been around for years, and has been done by all kind of people and organizations for all kind of purposes. Thiel is rich, he does things, there is no causality with 'tech' here. > Maybe it’s time for Silicon Valley to tone things down. To admit that, no, the Valley can’t solve all human problems -- not even close -- and never will. WTF.
- sdca 10y agoMaybe Thiel paid Hulk Hogan's lawyers through PayPal. (sarcasm level: infinity)
- saint_fiasco 10y agoIsn't Omidyar on Gawker's side, though?
- nxzero 10y agoTech people to tend to generically think about the world in a way; this is not an absolute, but just a pattern. Techies for example care more about access to information than the general public; to be fair, being in SV does not make you a techie.
- mukmuk 10y agoCan you point me to some examples where an individual financed litigation against a media outlet or journalist? I don't doubt they exist, but I can't think of any specifically.
- camperman 10y agoWhen quite a few individuals took News International to court between 2009 and 2011 for illegally eavesdropping on their mobile phones in the UK, a number of them had their legal costs underwritten by Max Mosely. This is just the same thing: a wealthy individual making sure that legal costs do not preclude action against Gawker.
- 10y ago
- droithomme 10y agoDistributing a private sex video was unethical and not an act of journalistic integrity. I view the Hulk Hogan case as justified and supporting it as a beneficial act.
- bko 10y ago> Litigation finance is typically a business venture. It doesn’t become charity because a wealthy person uses it as a template for a personal crusade and then insists he’s doing everyone else a favor. Why? Many cases brought by individuals or groups on moral grounds have led the way to better governance. A lot of good work has been done by groups such as the Electronic Frontier Foundation. Why should individuals or groups not be allowed to litigate moral changes? Who is supposed to do this? What's lost in all of this is what the lawsuit was actually about. Gawker wasn't speaking truth to power and criticizing individuals. Gawker posted an illegally obtained sex-tape. These articles attacking Thiel framed as billionaire versus journalists doesn't even mention this fact. The question should be why you need a billionaire to fund a lawsuit to get some sort of justice.
- Kristine1975 10y ago>These articles attacking Thiel framed as billionaire versus journalists doesn't even mention this fact. This one does though: >As for Gawker, it disseminated a sex tape of a retired pro wrestler. Let’s not pretend that the website did it as part of a great journalistic mission. Gawker did it to lure eyes to its website while smugly saying the First Amendment sheltered it. The author's beef isn't with Thiel using his money to help sue Gawker, but with him considering this to be philanthropic: >The problem isn’t the way Thiel used his money. It’s his pretensions about it.
- bko 10y agoAre more leaked sex tapes used for commercial purposes in the public interest?
- Xylakant 10y agoNobody pretended so - which is the whole point. Thiel could have given his money to a foundation that openly sponsors lawsuits for media victioms. That would haven been for the public good. Instead he chose to sponsor the lawsuit (and other lawsuits) against gawker in secret because he feels wronged by them with the intent of punishing them. And that's not in the public interest because it can be considered a form of vigilantism.
- tonetheman 10y agoMan interesting how all this happens, a few weeks ago when the verdict came out and no one knew of Thiel there was no large outcry. Now to find out that the lawsuit was funded directly by someone who was hurt by the high shittery from gawker. It is not a surprise. Tech billionaires are people, gawker pushed him and he is pushing back. Not sure there is much more to this.
- DickingAround 10y agoSaying all the tech titans are just like Thiel is a pretty obvious fallacy.
- EddieSpeaks 10y agoGawker is utter shite and it's a dangerous tabloid. I have no idea why anyone with a sane mind would be on their side in this issue. this is just a revenge story, let it go!
- venomsnake 10y agoBecause I am free speech absolutist which means defending speech that I don't like. There were other ways to nail gawker - copyright infringement comes to mind.
- frankc 10y agoGawker was allowed to say whatever they wanted about the sex tape. No one has ever questioned that. They were not allowed to publish it. That is what they were sued over. I'm pretty absolutionist about free speech myself, which is why it's pretty disappointing that a lot of people are missing this key point.
- whatok 10y agoExactly. The story and "news" surrounding this incident still exists without publication of the stolen video. Coverage without the video does not deliver as many clicks so they rolled the dice with that one and have so far lost.
- fixermark 10y agoI don't understand how a free speech absolutist supports a copyright-based retribution approach. "Absolutist" may not mean what you think it means.
- st3v3r 10y agoSo you believe that publishing private citizen's sex tapes falls under free speech? That outing others as gay falls under free speech?
- venomsnake 10y ago
- andy_ppp 10y agoIn other news a rich person used the law to their advantage.
- AlgorithmicTime 10y agoYeah... no.
- tomelders 10y agoWhat a hack piece. It would have a modicum of legitimacy if it wasn't criticising the status quo of modern media that Reuters has deemed unworthy of coverage for the past forty years. Why the sudden self righteous moral indignation? I smell a rat. I get the sense that "they" simply don't like Thiel his powers for good, when everyone knows you should only use the powers that come with been knee-tremblingly rich for evil. And It would be a good thing if Gawker ceased to be. It's a blight.
- mk89 10y agoWhat do people expect? They are humans with a lot of money and power.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoWait a minute. Gawker is no righteous hero here. Let's see if I understand correctly. Gawker outs Thiel (which is nobody's business, yet Gawker decided to make it people's business). Gawker at some point later posts an illegal SEX tape (again, nobody's business). Now, we're supposed to feel sorry for Gawker because Thiel wants to help out another person who was WRONGED by Gawker? Wow. Just wow.
- devishard 10y agoI don't feel bad for Gawker at all. I do, however, feel concerned that a rich person like Thiel can buy litigation. That's a highly dangerous capability. He's using that power for good in this case, but I doubt he always will.
- coredog64 10y agoHe does have to buy the right litigation though. Thiel can't just sue the NYT out of existence because he gets it into his head to do so. He'd need to find a meritorious suit.
- kazagistar 10y agoIt's surprisingly easy to find some way that the law was broken... it's quite complex.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoIf your concern is that the legal system is too expensive, complex and dangerous then you are right. But there is nothing specially worrying about industrialists in this picture. The lawsuit suit that sideswipes you is far more likely to come from some crusading NGOs or from government agents trying to look tough.
- kazagistar 10y agoThere is something particularly worrying about the industrialists: they have the most resources.
- devishard 10y agoThe fundamental issue here is that rich people can buy the law. It's not as simple as bribery, but it's nearly as effective. The only defense we have against that is when voters and jurors are educated and deeply suspicious of laws and litigation that are bought. Of course what Gawker did was reprehensible, but I don't need a million-dollar lawyer to tell me that. And when suddenly there is a million-dollar lawyer telling me that, I have to guess there's some other endgame here. My guess is that Thiel is building a template for future litigation. And while it happens to be good for justice in this case, I doubt it will always be so. That is definitely a bad thing.
- Teeboo 10y ago...if your premise is true then it is a damning indictment of Gawker. Not Thiel. This issue has been covered in detail. Hogan did not have the financial resources to combat the Gawker legal machine, funded from the company coffers. It took Thiel and his larger coffers to come along and upset their apple cart. So, if a rich person did buy the legal precedent, it was only until a richer person came along and restored sanity and parity to the system.
- devishard 10y agoIn this case, yes, that's how I see it. But I don't trust Thiel just because he did the right thing this time. The underlying problem is that anyone, Thiel or Gawker, can buy the law.
- whatok 10y agoLet's say the girl in this video [0] decided to sue Gawker. I'm going to just assume that she doesn't have the means to stand up to their army of lawyers. Is Gawker the rich person buying the law in this hypothetical? [0] http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3488027/Gawker-editor-AJ-Daulerio-refused-college-girl-s-pleas-possible-rape-video.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3488027/Gawker-edito...
- st3v3r 10y agoHe didn't buy the law, though. Gawker completely and totally did the things they were accused of. Would the world be better off if Hogan did not have the resources to fight back against what they did?
- danso 10y agoFWIW, David Simon, one of the biggest living romantics about the American press, has been ripping Gawker and defending Thiel for the past week. Probably the most prominent of journalists who I've yet seen defend Thiel: https://twitter.com/aodespair/status/736536875498770432 https://twitter.com/aodespair/status/736536875498770432
- arprocter 10y agoSee Generation Kill and s5 of the Wire to feel more of his press opinions Thanks - I didn't know he was on twitter
- bedhead 10y agoIt's evident that this was not only an isolated incident but one that seems to have more than a decent amount of justification. How so many people have managed to extrapolate this into tech robber barons taking over the galaxy is hyperbole at best. I think there is a part of this that admittedly has an ick-factor to it in general and people aren't sure how to articulate that. (Full disclosure, I utterly despise Gawker, have for years and have made prior vitriolic comments - quite proudly - about how awful Gawker and its associates are) As for the financing specifically, is it really materially different than lawyers taking cases on contingency? They are in effect self-financing cases on behalf of their clients...same basic thing is going on here, the plaintiff has a "backer" to float the case for them.
- fromthemorning 10y ago> "I no longer believe that freedom and democracy are compatible." [1] I think his intentions for funding the Gawker lawsuit, and now endorsing Trump are clear. [1] http://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/education-libertarian http://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/education...
- Teeboo 10y agoThis is why I find myself firmly on Team Thiel. Gawker are using the historical precedent of freedom of the press in order to exploit the private lives of people, illegally, for profit. It is this corrupted pursuit of salacious gossip which led to the hacking of thousands and thousands of voicemails in the United Kingdom by News International. Not just celebrities but political figures and most chillingly, victims of crime. Parents whose children had been abducted and/or murdered had their private lives hacked by an international news agency to churn out sordid headlines. So yeh, I am Team Thiel until the press learn to wield their authority with respect and deference.
- AlexandrB 10y ago> So yeh, I am Team Thiel until the press learn to wield their authority with respect and deference. A good/free press does not and should not exhibit respect and deference to those in power. For a counter-example, see the Russian press, which does show a lot of respect and deference to the Russian ruling class.
- Teeboo 10y agoWho said deference to those in power? I would hope a free press has the respect not to invade the privacy of private citizens. Do you honestly think the videotape of the sexual exploits of a private citizen is somehow worthy of protection under freedom of the press? Not to mention the tape was illegally procured and Gawker continued to act in flagrant violation of the court ordered redactions. You hear deference and you immediately go to despot or dictator. The truth is, the press is far more damaging to private citizens than it has ever been to the establishment. You show me one piece of great investigative journalism and I will show you 10 celebrity reporters lying in the gutters getting upskirt shots of a teen celebrity. Team Thiel until they learn not to hack voicemails and generally become decent members of society.
- lotso 10y agoHow can you be Team Thiel and have these opinions when Thiel financially supported the person who made the acorn videos? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_O%27Keefe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_O%27Keefe
- tmaly 10y agoI have a feeling that these recent attacks on Thiel have more to do with who he is backing politically rather than this lawsuit.
- sparkzilla 10y agoLet's just stop the name calling. Theil is not a "robber-baron". He created his wealth by providing services in the free market for others' benefit. He neither robbed, nor did he gain his money through inheritance. He did not use government funds to finance the Gawker case. He used his own money on a cause he believed in. If you don't like it, give your money in Gawker's defence, or work to a better solution: limiting the amount of damages a jury can award in such cases.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoWhat? People view Silicon Valley as idealistic and almost utopian? Give me a break. Stupid article. When I look at all the evil that the Economic Royalty have done to the world since the beginning of the Enlightenment, the funding of a law suit seems like nothing in comparison.
- protomyth 10y agoSo, news companies (owned by rich people) which have been able to print untrue or private things with impunity are mad because someone richer than them decided to retaliate. Rich people mad at richer people for threatening their power. This is basically why I find most money in politics stories to be laughable since these publishers sure spend a lot of money on ink. Reuters is just mad they might actually step on the wrong person and be held accountable.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- CookieMon 10y agoFascinating to watch Gawker's quarter-billion dollar public manipulation machine kick into gear. Linked-In just emailed me to ensure I was aware of another one of these articles. Thiel better hope he can manage a death blow, or that people become bored of the manufactured controversy - there's nothing Gawker doesn't stoop to, it's going to be vicious.
- arprocter 10y agoThe media backlash feels more like a disingenuous and thinly veiled attack on Thiel's political views. Ask yourself - would there be all this hand-wringing if Soros had funded the case?
- bakhy 10y agoperhaps this is off-topic, but what personally bugs me most, as a gay man, is that Mr Thiel can hold such a huge grudge for so long about being outed. is it so humiliating for you that other people know you're gay, Mr Thiel? i must add a disclaimer, of course: i am strongly against outing people like that (barring some exceptions, like anti-gay politicians). it is wrong, and Gawker should be punished for it. but i would expect that Mr Thiel feels at least some relief that the secret is out. and that this would enable some degree of letting go, and that the whole thing would die down. but, no. instead, 10 years of litigation... alternatively, Mr Thiel could just be prone to extreme grudges, and just generally can't let anything go (?)
- nickpinkston 10y agoFYI - this was written by a PR person, not a journalist, and is designed to make Thiel look bad. Perhaps from someone hired by Gawker? The author, Keith Emmer, is "the founder and managing partner of this strategic communications consultancy helping our clients... manage reputations... through editorial media" https://www.linkedin.com/in/keithemmer https://www.linkedin.com/in/keithemmer
- NoMoreNicksLeft 10y agoIf Gawker were something other than tabloid trash, maybe it'd get more support from us non-robber-barons. Do you think Gawker would spare you, if they thought humiliating you would be popular? Could you do anything about it? Well, apparently they were stupid enough to humiliate someone who could do something about it. And I'm fine with the results we're seeing.
- emblem21 10y agoGawker Media is a Cayman Island corporation founded by a foreign national. It does not engage in journalism. It is a blog designed to shift the Overton Window for Jon Stewart's fanbase into normalizing extreme political agendas. Are there any cases that show foreign companies that exist 100% as a tax shelter, founded by a foreign national, have first amendment rights?
- lotso 10y ago>It is a blog designed to shift the Overton Window for Jon Stewart's fanbase into normalizing extreme political agendas. Like Jezebel being pro-feminism. What an extreme political agenda!
- emblem21 10y agoOnly privileged white people think Jezebel represents feminism. Let me know when they give full-time coverage of the challenges of poverty that routinely face WoC instead of hyperventilating about how sexist a handful of pixels are. Or are feminists only those who have minable consumer behavior? Looks like the Overton window shifting worked on you.
- lotso 10y agoDefinitely agree that Jezebel and many other publications in general don't give provide enough perspective of feminism and LGBT issues from PoC (for what its worth, I'm a PoC), but I disagree with the fact that Gawker does not provide some legitimate journalism. Does Gawker have an issue here? Yes. Does Gawker produce a bunch of drivel around issues that are probably trivial in the grand scheme of things? Yes, but I think you could apply the same critique to almost every major liberal news publication. The difference for me is that Gawker has reach and is willing to take on very powerful people (for better or for worse), unlike other publications.
- emblem21 10y agoI'll meet you halfway and agree on the importance on taking on the powerful. But I can't lionize Gawker for doing that. I can only criticize them for lowering the bar on what taking on the powerful means. Revealing a VC is gay isn't taking on the powerful. Revealing the low-commitment racism of a wrestling has-been isn't taking on the powerful. This is pandering to low information and low attention audiences to secure a buck with TMZ-style gossip... and then dressing it up like you're doing God's work because, somehow, everyone involved believes they are on the right side of history™. If you want to see an example of journalists taking on power, ask yourself this: When is the last time a central bank called out Gawker? If you want to see an example of data-driven journalism (ignore the election year antics) that actually takes on the powerful, give Zerohedge a try. At least they make the effort to back up their occasionally ridiculous speculation with hard data.
- _Codemonkeyism 10y ago(Not taking sides or condemning/supporting Thiel) Publications destroy people all the time - at least tabloids here in Germany. Most of those people have no money and can't sue. Journalism is fine when the 800pound Gorilla is on their side. Now once a person aims to destroy the magazine, journalists with pitchforks claim the end is near (aka censorship). At least this is how it looks from the sideline.
- twinkletwinkle 10y agoEver heard the phrase "Play stupid games, win stupid prizes"? Hard to feel sympathy for tabloid writers feeling unfairly targeted.
- srj 10y agoMoney alone doesn't win a lawsuit. The reporter who wrote this probably doesn't agree with the court's decision, but that decision wasn't written by Thiel or Silicon Valley. Also, people have crowd-funded legal fees previously. That isn't new. That Thiel chose to fund a lawsuit against a publication that outed him as gay doesn't seem very surprising or devious. They still had to convince the court they had a claim in this case.
- hinkley 10y agoOh are we figuring this out now? Is this a thing? I thought we knew this back when Bill became the richest man.
- vinceguidry 10y ago> That may actually help rebuild some of the lost trust between it and the public. Oh please. This is the sort of thing journalists say that has no bearing on anything real, they just say it to make themselves the center of conversation. Lost trust my ass. Nobody trusts big American business, or big business everywhere. Commerce has always had a large element of adversarial conflict to it, the tug of war between the public will, exercised through politics and legislation, and markets is what produces social progress, not any kind of altruism. This is really just the press industry rallying behind their own. They think they should just be able to say whatever the hell they want about whoever they want with no consequences whatsoever. They're the ones that want a legal advantage. You know why nobody sues the tabloids? They all have humongous legal teams, going up against them is like shooting peas at a brick wall. But they've created a business model around saying vicious, wrong things about people who did nothing to deserve such treatment. So forgive me if I'm a tad bit skeptical.
- geuis 10y agoHow is it that weeks have gone by and the css on Reuters mobile site is still broken?
- tumbas 10y agothis story sounds like some free mason communist is seeding it's communist seed again so I clicked for that ends up as misleading title that looks like generalising things
- grellas 10y agoExtremely wealthy people are just like any other group of people in that they come in all shapes and sizes. Here, one very wealthy individual used his money to fund someone else's lawsuit. He did so secretly. He did so against an organization that had harmed him and against which he presumably wanted payback but that also had done a gratuitously damaging and sleazy act as part of a pattern of sleazy acts upon which it had built its erstwhile presumably profitable venture, hence presumably deserving payback. So what does this say about Silicon Valley? Well, nothing at all, really. Both before and after this incident, Silicon Valley was, is and remains a place where multiple tech entrepreneurs and those who back them financially have built amazing ventures (and fortunes) that have reshaped all of world commerce even while many others failed. The thing that is new and different is the tech and the ways of using it to disrupt old-style business models. What is not different is the people. As with people everywhere, some are great, others sleazy, still others ravenously greedy, still others amazingly kind and gracious - in short, people who come in all shapes and sizes. I guess they are on average more educated and accomplished than average folks but the personal traits that define them, both good and bad, are pretty much the same as with people everywhere. I don't know Mr. Thiel and don't know any more about him than what the headlines say. He may be fully justified in taking this action (it is a perfectly legal thing to do) or he may be displaying traits deserving our opprobrium. What I am sure of is that his actions here, good or bad, have little or nothing to do with what other prominent tech entrepreneurs do or how they think or how they run their companies. So the logic of this piece - Mr. Thiel did x as a private act in his life, therefore all Silicon Valley tech billionaires stand indicted, therefore the public will now see them as no different than robber barons - seems to rest on multiple non sequiturs that really need to be more carefully thought through. I guess we are conditioned to accept this sort of sloppy reasoning when it comes to discussing the very rich but this seems like a way-over-the-top overreaction to an individual episode that is what it is but that reflects very little on the broader environment surrounding it (or, if it does, not in ways that can be generalized in the crazy ways the author does here).
- internaut 10y agoHe is not using sloppy reasoning, he is only saying what members of the media have been thinking for a long time now. The media see us as competition. More here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11824117 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11824117
- spinlock 10y agoOr, you could spin this as ethical investing. Presumably, Thiel backed Hogan with an expectation of being compensated if Gawker lost the suit and had to pay damages. So, from an investment perspective, this was a good deal that paid off. It also punished a bad actor that invaded a celebrities private life. Smells like a win-win to me.
- juped 10y agoThere's a deep tragedy in Thiel financing the lawsuit. The tragedy is that you apparently need a billionaire's backing to get any sort of justice against something like Gawker.
- kazinator 10y agoThe situation with Thiel and Hogan shows that lawyers are are ever the robber barons. Who grabs all that money from Thiels' funding of the lawsuit? Follow the money, and that's where the barons are. And in this state she 'gallops night by night Through lovers' brains, and then they dream of love; O'er courtiers' knees, that dream on cursies straight; O'er lawyers' fingers, who straight dream on fees; [...] ^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ -- Mercutio's "Queen Mab" speech, Romeo and Juliet, Act I, Scene IV.
- vixen99 10y agoHow about one who really is dangerous - George Soros. “I admit that I have always harbored an exaggerated view of my self-importance—to put it bluntly, I fancied myself as some kind of god” or “I carried some rather potent messianic fantasies with me from childhood, which I felt I had to control, otherwise I might end up in the loony bin.” http://humanevents.com/2011/04/02/top-10-reasons-george-soros-is-dangerous/ http://humanevents.com/2011/04/02/top-10-reasons-george-soro...
- mahyarm 10y agoThe media industry sees this as a threat to their industry/tribe and does a circle the bandwagons reaction using their convenient tool at hand. Writing articles in widely published publications. On top of it, these people are probably friends-of-friends publishing these articles. That is why it gets more attention than many other instances of similar behavior in similar situations.
- pyoung 10y agoWhat Gawker did was disgusting, but what irks me about Thiel's actions is the fact that most of his wealth was created by investing in businesses that have significantly reduced consumer privacy (i.e. Facebook, Palantir, etc..). How many people have been accidentally outed due to Facebook's poor privacy practices? Gawker is a by-product of the current ecosystem that Silicon Valley has created. The rise of click bait journalism was a by product of incentives created by social media companies like Facebook. And Thiel sits in the center of this universe. If he really wants to be 'philanthropic' he should focus his efforts at the root causes of these issues. But he won't, because that is where his net worth comes from.
- lowbloodsugar 10y agoThe conclusion of the article (I think) we are (still) discussing here, however, appears to be "Thiel is a robber baron and we the poor public should be wary of these new rich", when in fact the conclusion should be "Our system of justice is broken because rich people can get different outcomes than poor people." Clearly, the author of the article does not want the poor people to come to the conclusion that the justice system is broken, presumably, because then the rich and powerful establishment, would not be able to use it themselves. Instead, they want to put upstart newcomers like Thiel in their place. Are there any other areas where the establishment may need public backing to take down the "robber barons of silicon valley"? Anyone having the nerve to fight back on issues of privacy, national security, encryption, copyright, basic human rights in general? No?
- frogpelt 10y agoBillionaires being in control and being somewhat held in check by regulations and laws is infinitely better than regulators and lawmakers being in control (read: having all the power and money) and being held in check by no one. See North Korea.
- benbou09 10y agoThiel get sniped by The Economist here: http://www.economist.com/news/business/21699954-tech-billionaire-has-morphed-libertarian-corporate-nietzschean-evolution http://www.economist.com/news/business/21699954-tech-billion...