6 ms·
Emacs is a text editor in the same way the space shuttle is a vehicle.
by mseebach 17y ago
Emacs is a text editor in the same way the space shuttle is a vehicle.
- jrockway 17y agoBut unfortunately, very few IDE users are aware of this.
- mixmax 17y agoYes, it's equally hard to operate.
- davidw 17y agoReally? I can see grandma not using it, but anyone on this site ought to be able to figure out the basics in short order. Of course, no one ever truly masters it - I'm always learning cool new things. But that's part of what makes it so great.
- sreque 17y agoCan your emacs editor construct hyperlinked call graphs showing all callers and callees of a given function? Will this call graph generation remain up to date as I edit files? Can Emacs give me a hyper-linked list of all usages of a given symbol and do it properly(lexical scope, etc.), not just doing a simple symbol search? Can I edit my code in emacs, have a background compiler compile the file on the fly, and also provide error feedback, hilighting the problem lines with a tagged failure reason and also providing a hyper-linked list in another window as well? Last I checked, the best I could do would be to kick off a compile manually and navigate the errors as a linked list. How's emacs' refactoring support? Judging by the following stackoverflow post, it's pretty poor: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/673554/how-can-i-refactor-c-source-code-using-emacs http://stackoverflow.com/questions/673554/how-can-i-refactor.... How's Emacs' keyword completion? Last I checked, it was just a hacky dictionary look-up, whereas an IDE can semantically analyze the source to provide intelligent suggestions. Even if you can get Vim or Emacs to do some of the above, it usually isn't as easy to use or as useful as an IDE. For instance, I know you can get call graph support in Vim using cctree.vim, but it relies on cscope, which requires refreshing the database manually, is slow to load, and tends to generate incomplete tag sets. IDE's are, well, better integrated, and so can do many things a lot better than looser environments like Emacs and Vim. Their UI's tend to be a lot more powerful because they are not designed to be run on windowless environments. Personally, for small projects I use Vim and for large projects I use an IDE with a Vim emulation plugin like Netbean's JVI plugin.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- lutorm 17y agoEmacs can do whatever you want. If it doesn't, it can be added. In fact, Emacs is an IDE... It's just not a mouse-based IDE. Mouse clicking makes my hands hurt much faster than using the keyboard. I also find it annoying to switch from mouse<->keyboard, so I don't want a UI that relies on constant mousing.
- RyanDScott 17y ago"Emacs can do whatever you want. If it doesn't, it can be added...." Um no. But if so, then someone better start busting a lisp to get emacs to make cute little bubbles. I'd love to see that.
- lutorm 17y agoThey'd just be text-based little bubbles...
- doty 17y ago"Emacs can do whatever you want." Saying "Emacs can do whatever you want" is like saying "your computer can do anything you want." Sure it can, so long as you're willing to write the code to make it go. But my time is finite; I cannot be bothered to re-build environments that have already been implemented elsewhere.
- sjs 17y agoIn the 30+ years Emacs has been around people have written a huge amount of Emacs Lisp that does pretty much everything you can think of. Almost every feature from other editors and IDEs has been implemented in Emacs. I like Lisp but rarely write very much Emacs Lisp, and when I do it's usually an extension of some code someone else started. There aren't a lot of new ideas and when an Emacs user sees one he implements it for Emacs.
- epochwolf 17y agoIt's also based on technology that's ancient compared to everything else around it. (Not that ancient is a bad thing, go unix!) Unrelated but interesting out of 130 space flights 2 resulted in the destruction of the vehicle.
- jrockway 17y agoYeah, dynamic customization and extension is quite antiquated. Modern IDEs should only be customizable by writing 5000 different classes, recompiling, and restarting the IDE. Tools should only be built by dedicated tool-builders, not by your average programmer! Nice troll though, I will give you that.