3 ms·
The opposite of that, addressing current concerns, is what created the mess of LA to begin with. Here's some examples: In the 1920s, to alleviate traffic on a
by kristopolous 10y ago
The opposite of that, addressing current concerns, is what created the mess of LA to begin with. Here's some examples:
In the 1920s, to alleviate traffic on a specific downtown to miracle mile commute, macarthur park was split in half and wilshire was cut through the middle of the park. The park remains split in 2016 due to this 1920s era problem.
In the 1950s, due to a lack of downtown parking, pershing square was gutted to be a multi-level underground parking structure with a poorly accessible park on top. Now in 2016, when we want a walkable city, many lament that our one central park is really just a multi-level parking lot.
The central problem here is that when city policy crafts a solution with 80 years of consequences to alleviate a 3 year problem, the urban landscape becomes disjointed and short-sighted.
Instead, this concept, which includes things like bike lanes, high density dwellings, and trains, are people trying to come up with 80 year solutions that are forward thinking.
There's been a problem getting all the right funding and public support on board but it's far easier today then what it took to get that first train to long beach open in 1990. The newer high density housing is still not pedestrian accessible, but that is changing in the buildings that are being planned right now and will be complete in a few years.
I think LA is attracting the right people and fostering the right attitude for a workable city that will blossom with sustainability, creativity, and livability in the upcoming generation.
- ikawe 10y ago> In the 1950s, due to a lack of downtown parking, pershing square was gutted to be a multi-level underground parking structure with a poorly accessible park on top. Now in 2016, when we want a walkable city, many lament that our one central park is really just a multi-level parking lot. I think [Grand Park] might be the New Central Park™. But it is, to your point, divided into three sections by streets cutting through the middle of it. =( [Grand Park] https://www.google.com/maps/@34.0535849,-118.2459343,16.35z https://www.google.com/maps/@34.0535849,-118.2459343,16.35z
- kristopolous 10y agoThe upper two levels have been parks and plaza space since 1966 when it was called El Paseo de Los Pobladores de Los Angeles or just Civic Center Mall. Prior to that the lower level had been a parking lot and there was a road that cut through the center, leading to city hall. They cut the lower parking lot into the park in the 2010 project you talk about. So yes, grand park has been gradually growing in size for about 50 years. It certainly now has a more memorable name. It's going in a good direction... Cars make surpassing a certain level of urban density really difficult. As parts of LA are getting there, people are finding out they really can't do it and at the same time allocate enough space for everyone to have their own car. The divorce of the 60s onward happend as a physical necessity. I think LA is growing past such reactionary urban planning. I hope so
- parshimers 10y agoVery true. I also hope all of this finds some sort of equitable way to de-sprawl somewhat. Transit in LA does have such an interesting history of missteps. Can you imagine what things might be like if they never got rid of the red car system?!
- kristopolous 10y agoThe red car was a loss leader for real estate development. It was hastily and cheaply constructed for short term profit, not carefully planned for long term growth and utility. Almost all crossings were at-grade and rail was being converted to bus as early as 1925. Trains were being pulled up after the property was sold and many lines averaged under 13 mph as the density and car traffic increased. The rail lines themselves were cheap material. Many lines were closed when they became too costly to repair. The anarchy of free market competition is a poor substitute for thoughtful urban planning.