5 ms·
I'm intrigued by Heroku (and EY Cloud), but the thing that really freaks me out is how they charge for every little extra thing. I love the idea of a turnkey s
by dasil003 17y ago
I'm intrigued by Heroku (and EY Cloud), but the thing that really freaks me out is how they charge for every little extra thing. I love the idea of a turnkey solution for Rails deployment and cloud scalability, but for me personally I don't think I would do a startup on it because the value proposition is squeezed from both sides.
On the low-end I can get a VPS for $10-$20 month and get a Rails app up and running for a significant number of users with just that modest outlay. I can install SSL and any software I want and have a predictable amount of resources to play with. Yes, there is some sysadmining overhead, but setting up Nginx w/ passenger is like an hour of work once you've been through it a couple times, and similarly a lot of the add-ons that Heroku charges a monthly fee for are just a small one-time time investment. When I'm trying to bootstrap something really small the last thing I want is ramping up a significant recurring cash costs just to run some open source software that is really not hard enough to setup or maintain to justify recurring costs.
On the high-end when I'm using a lot of server resources, I'm paying a growing premium for a given amount of resources. Now don't get me wrong, it's nice to be able to magically adjust for traffic spikes, but if I have a consistently high amount of traffic, once again I'm paying a high recurring cost for actual resources that are a fraction of the cost, especially if I need any add-ons which are not inherently resource-intensive—maybe I'm actually just paying for SaaS of essentially open-source components. Actually I have this problem with EC2 and S3 in general to some extent, though much less so than with Heroku because the markup is lower and I've still got a large degree of control.
The benefit of Heroku is that they maintain an up-to-date and well-tuned Rails stack w/ add-ons on top of EC2. There is definitely value there. But in all cases there is this downside of overhead and flexibility. The clincher for me is that ultimately Heroku may end up not supporting something I need that would be trivial open-source stuff on any UNIX VPS. At that point I will need to migrate off of Heroku and all those supposed sysadmin costs hit me full in the face all at once rather than being amortized over the life of the project. Maybe I'm just turning into a cranky old man (at 31!), but VPS or dedicated servers still seem like a better value considering all risk factors. If I had VC money and was trying to ramp something up really fast I might reconsider.
- hopeless 17y agoEven though I had a VPS configured and running for almost a year (i.e., all the upfront sysadmin setup done) I was stressing about what I hadn't done, or more precisely what I didn't know I needed to do. Forgetting to update the OS, check if the machine had been compromised, check the load/mem/disk space etc. Just a hundred little worries floating around inside my head. So I moved to Heroku to focus purely on the app. It's wrong to say they change for "every little thing"... most addons are free. But yes, hourly cron, background workers, unlimited bundles etc are charged for. I'll always recommend to anyone that they check out Heroku because I think it's a real time saver if your app fits within their constraints. During development you'll usually save money and then the costs will scale (hopefully) with your income after launch
- jhancock 17y agoFor me, not owning my own server as a serial entrepreneur is like a graphics design consultant not owning a mac. Or a mechanic without four extra cars in his backyard. I'm sure Heoku is a great deal if you don't have the sysadmin skills. My skills are just good enough and I manage my own box. I bought it 5 years ago..4 cores, 8 GBs, 73GB RAID-1...for $5000. I pay $105/month to host it. This is at least the equivalent in horsepower of what you get from Heroku for $500+ a month (that's being generous). So in a few years, I'm ahead of the curve: $11,300 vs $30,000. Add in the fact that I paid down $5000 in advance as a capital investment and I'm still ahead. You could do this today for under $3000 capital investment and have an even more capable box. Sure there's risk I'll have a hardware failure (I did have 3 years 24 hours on site warranty, but that's still potential downtime and headaches). But there is also risk that over the course of that time you will want to run things on your server you did not anticipate when you started. It certainly was the case for me. e.g. I started my app in rails then switched to merb. Now I run a second site on the same server with mongodb and solr. Bottom line, if you have moderate linux skills and know your going to be in "some business" that requires you have a server, buy your own. If not, Heorku seems a fine choice for some.
- hachiya 17y agoThanks for this comparison. Can you recommend the company that you colocate/lease-to-own with?