3 ms·
I'm stepping back since you're clearly more interested in technicalities than my overall point. So, I'm going to focus on that. Currently, there's two claims ab
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
I'm stepping back since you're clearly more interested in technicalities than my overall point. So, I'm going to focus on that. Currently, there's two claims about patents:
1. They're the source off all kinds of innovation and startups that wouldn't otherwise happen. This means CompSci doesn't happen unless private parties fund it due to patents they expect. Most funding is by taxpayers. So, that's not true. Private parties won't invest in things without patent protection? Not true: they do anyway to remain competitive. Startups won't happen without patent protection? They do anyway with them rarely using patents and some using trade secrets. So, alleged benefits of patents are a lie, esp in software space.
2. They're primarily a tool to maximize profits of companies, small or large, that contribute almost nothing in innovation or features. Every study I've seen shows this. Plus, most suits are coming from groups that produce nothing: acquire patents from someone for cheap, then sue anyone actually building anything. Opposite of what system claims to do. Large companies make up most of the rest of the suits by putting innovators out of business while leaving their own products stagnant. They even sometimes try to take the products off the market as we saw with Virnetx, Apple, and Microsoft.
So, net effect is that patents are hurting innovation. Plus, nobody producing innovative stuff getting acquired did so by reading hundreds of thousands of patents. Surveys show they rarely ever read a single patent. They look at what's out there, maybe read academic work, build something, and sell it. Of all that innovation, patents contributed jack and most don't even get patents since they're expensive to get. Easier for big players the system is designed to benefit. ;)
"How long does it take for you to get a hint? ~15 years of patent reforms, numerous SCOTUS cases, POTUS trying to get involved, etc."
Vast amount of profits produced by legal monopolies gave patent holders more money on lawyers and politicians have given them a good run. Plus, most of the rest aren't uniting to deal with the problem with counter-lobbying. I had a hint of that a while back. That doesn't mean we actual innovators should stop fighting monopolies mostly issued to non-innovating, big companies and small companies that sue instead of sell products.
"Same old tired line. If it drives prices up then generally it will lure investors to invest - and to invest in patents requires investing in innovation - investing in innovation means R&D."
That was so funny I had to respond to it. A patent is a legal monopoly. A monopoly by definition and style will lead to higher prices than competitive segment with many players innovating. If you're right, please tell me about all those cancer and heart drugs that I can get for generic prices. Oh wait, I can't, because they're patented and patent-holders charge whatever the market will bear to maximize profits. Same everywhere else where alternative innovations are hard to come by. Or existed but don't count in a "first-to-file" system that favors patent holders.
- jb613 10y ago> I'm stepping back since you're clearly more interested in technicalities than my overall point. When I disagree with your overall sentiment that patents have no value - then the technicalities ARE important. Regardless, I'll take the fact you feel the need to take the battle to new ground as a win and we'll move on. > 1. They're the source off all kinds of innovation and startups that wouldn't otherwise happen. "all kinds of innovation" - never said anything like that. I said patents incentivize investment into innovation. Big difference. > Most funding is by taxpayers. Well, I disagree with "most". Perhaps some but not most. In my experience, plenty of innovation comes from small entities. If this is not the case then why do larger players continually acquire the small companies? sometimes it's for other reasons but I suggest that at least some of the time it's for their innovations. > "Private parties won't invest in things without patent protection? " ok, clearly you are not reading what I'm writing. If you are referring to my "patents incentivize investment" then how is that equivalent to "won't invest without patent protection"?! > So, alleged benefits of patents are a lie, esp in software space. You are all over the place. Earlier you said patent holders win 100% of the time (which in a free market would mean investors would eventually be drawn in and invest in whatever it took to get these magical things called patents) and now you're saying the benefits are a lie? > "2. They're primarily a tool to maximize profits of companies, small or large, that contribute almost nothing in innovation or features." Of course they contribute nothing - they are merely pieces of paper. You don't create the innovation in the patent application itself! > "Plus, most suits are coming from groups that produce nothing: acquire patents from someone for cheap, then sue anyone actually building anything. " An innovator can no longer approach a larger player with an improvement to one of their products. The larger players have learned their most optimal business strategy is to weed out the majority by ignoring them until an infringement suit is brought. Many small players don't/can't - hence optimal strategy for larger player. Is it fair for the larger players to do this? Morally, probably not. But large corporations have fiduciary duty to maximize profits to their shareholders - so from the shareholders perspective it is. However, from the small player standpoint, they need to do what they have to - and often they realize that selling off their patent assets to another entity is their best option. Call it troll if you like but in reality they are more leveling the playing field by carrying out the IP enforcement that is difficult for the small innovator to do themselves. Either way, a patent is a patent and it matters not who owns it. > "So, net effect is that patents are hurting innovation. " For non-innovators or copycats that might be true, but for innovators that is patently false. > "Surveys show they rarely ever read a single patent." And then they act all surprised when they are slapped with an infringement trial :-) "But officer I did not see the sign". > "That doesn't mean we actual innovators should stop fighting monopolies mostly issued to non-innovating, big companies and small companies that sue instead of sell products." So the innovators aren't getting the patents while the non-innovators are? Please, give it a rest. > "A patent is a legal monopoly. A monopoly by definition and style will lead to higher prices than competitive segment with many players innovating" Monopolies encourage investment - in this case, investment into patents means investment into innovation means investment into R&D. > "Or existed but don't count in a "first-to-file" system that favors patent holders." This was introduced in the last patent reform (AIA). 2 steps forward and 1 back - or 1 forward and 2 back?