4 ms·
If you've read what Scott wrote, you'll see that it bears little resemblance to what Rodgers says. Scott is explicitly talking about small-scale social organizi
by barrkel 17y ago
If you've read what Scott wrote, you'll see that it bears little resemblance to what Rodgers says. Scott is explicitly talking about small-scale social organizing and the like, where there isn't a profit business to be made - the intuition being that the government would come out ahead via taxes.
It's explicitly not about trying to create innovation or build profitable enterprises via top-down funding and political patronage, which is what Rodgers was arguing wouldn't work, and Paul has also said wouldn't work.
Paul also says it right here: http://www.paulgraham.com/inequality.html http://www.paulgraham.com/inequality.html - governments don't like risk, so they try and manage it away via bureaucracy, which in turn attracts companies that are optimized to gain government grants, rather than customers or profitable businesses.
- btilly 17y agoScott is specifically suggesting that government be the funding source. If government is the funding source, that translates either into government contracts or grants, both of which result in the problems that Rodgers talked about. This does not mean that government should never fund anything. But it does mean that we should be suspicious of claims that government is better at generating viable or semi-viable businesses on command than the free market.