5 ms·
Can someone give the devil's advocate view? As others are saying, the judge's ruling is ridiculous. I can understand if there were material misrepresentations
by SilasX 10y ago
Can someone give the devil's advocate view? As others are saying, the judge's ruling is ridiculous. I can understand if there were material misrepresentations that affected the offer price, but to rule that you should offer more than the market was valuing it? Even though no one was actually willing to pay that price? And on the grounds that "investors are too stupid to correctly value it"?
Isn't the whole point of a buyout that you think other investor's are incorrectly valuing a venture based on the available information? If any buyout is going to be subject to this later, with-more-hindsight review that forces buyers to "top up" to the "correct" value, what's the point?
Sometimes I wonder how business manages to work at all in the presence of this "jackpot justice".
- jacquesm 10y agoIt depends on whether or not it was a 'drag along'. That can make a big difference in how the price is interpreted after the fact. It means you don't exactly get a say in the price at which you sell. Of course it also matters if you were on the record as disagreeing with selling your shares at that price.
- pilom 10y agoThe issue is that some shareholders were forced to sell at $13/share even if they didn't want to. There were a minority of shareholders who were holding onto the shares on the assumption that the new long term vision would work out great and expecting their shares to be worth something >$13/share. Those people were forced to sell at $13 because the majority of shareholders agreed to take $13/share and let the company go private. Maybe someone bought at $14 a share years ago and simply was a buy and hold investor living off the dividends and convinced that it was under priced but totally ok with that because they expected to own the company forever. That person would be pissed at the $13/share offer.
- alistairSH 10y agoPissed? Sure. But, anger isn't generally grounds for a successful lawsuit.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoNo, but a law that gives you grounds for a lawsuit is grounds for a lawsuit. Shareholders who were forced to sell are entitled by law to have the sale reviewed by a judge.
- jonknee 10y agoWell that is how it works when owning a minority stake of a public company. Or how it should work at least, this lawsuit is absurd.
- jawilson2 10y agoIsn't that part of the risk when you invest in equities? If you don't want to be forced to sell (or deal with bankruptcies, etc.) you can always buy bonds or ETFs or other less risky ventures.
- rayiner 10y agoShareholders take that risk against the backdrop knowledge that in situations like this they can seek appraisal from the court. Not that I think such appraisals make all that much sense with publicly-traded equities, but nonetheless these shareholders bought the stock assuming the appraisal right would be available.
- tomp 10y agoCourts of course should always be last resort, after all, there could be fraud (e.g. if the CEO was deliberately hiding some information that would have increased the market price). But the problem with this ruling is, that it's ridiculous - the court's argument is basically that the "fair value" is above what PE paid because PE wanted to make a profit! It basically contradicts the whole idea of the market (buying something if you think it's worth more than the current price)!
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoIn a market, typically things are sold voluntarily. These are people who were forced to sell.
- scotty79 10y agoExactly, you are abandoning market and its prices once you say "those stocks are just pieces of paper now, we'll give you few bucks for each so you won't sue us"
- rayiner 10y agoThe appraisal right makes sense for smaller companies, even in the absence of fraud. There, you can have a majority shareholder come in and force a minority to sell based on a lowball valuation. There are no competing PE offers or public exchange prices to use as a reference in that scenario, so the appraisal right at least ensures an independent look at the purported valuation.
- Vraxx 10y agoThis all makes sense as to why they might not have wanted to sell, but doesn't this ruling invalidate the entire reason to vote? Constituents don't get any sort of compensation if their preferred political candidate doesn't win the election, or if a bill passes that they voted against. Why would this be different in the case of a vote for a buyout?
- robotresearcher 10y agoHere's the idea: I own 51% of the shares, so have a strict majority of all votes. I call a shareholder meeting and propose to take the company private by selling all the shares to me, for any price I choose. The vote passes by majority. To prevent the 49% being completely screwed with regularity, the law provides for those who voted against such a takeover to have the sale reviewed by a judge. The 51% owner takes this into account when proposing a price. In the case of a political election, the losing minority does not have their property instantly and compulsorily purchased at an arbitrary price set by the winner.
- SilasX 10y agoThanks, that makes a lot more sense now. I remember using the reverse of that strategy in Railroad Tycoon 2: if my company had a lot of cash, I'd buy up as many shares of a smaller company as I could, and then make a wildly-over-the-top bid for it to divert my company's money into my pocket! Interestingly, I think it capped the amount you could offer at something like 2x the current market price, their own version of imposing an "arm's length" restriction...
- tsmffh 10y ago>In the case of a political election, the losing minority does not have their property instantly and compulsorily purchased at an arbitrary price set by the winner. Perhaps not instantly, but it that's exactly what happens.
- SilasX 10y agoAlso, forgot to add: >In the case of a political election, the losing minority does not have their property instantly and compulsorily purchased at an arbitrary price set by the winner. Actually, in many poorly-run democracies, they do something very close! I'm reminded of the Dilbert comic: "If you vote for me, I'll take money from the people who didn't, and give it to you!"
- SilasX 10y agoHow can that be "the" issue? That's fundamentally how business equity -- the entire stock market -- works. Certain decisions are put up to a vote of shareholders, one-share-one-vote, and the result binds all shareholders. It's no more unusual than "forcing" naysayer shareholders to accept the dilution that comes with e.g. a secondary offering. (Certainly, there are reasons to dispute the prudence of the decision, but that would be orthogonal to your argument, which seems to be about the mere fact of overruling minority dissenters.)
- scotty79 10y agoHow can anybody be made to to sell a thing that he doesn't want to sell? I understand government can do it for greater purpose, like building infrastructure but a company? How can a company say "you know what, these stocks that were issued to represent ownership won't be a thing since next month, we can give you 13 bucks for each so you won't feel like a total looser"? Suddenly I'm all for judge deciding how much people that were basically sold piece of paper with some meaningless letters should get.
- facepalm 10y agoIs there anything wrong with that? Surely that is an known risk when deciding to become a minority shareholder? What is next? Maybe I can buy Apple stock because I expect them to launch a self driving car next year, and if they then don't focus on self driving cars I can sue because it is not what I expected?
- danvoell 10y agoSince we are asking questions, hope you don't mind me piggybacking, how does someone decide the amount they are willing to pay in such a transaction? I understand that you pay a premium for controlling interest and for the sheer volume of the stock you are purchasing, but how does one pick the premium amount?
- bboreham 10y agoYou look at similar past deals which have gone ahead or fallen through. You sound out some large shareholders, see what they might accept. You run your own modelling - what you think it's worth, what it will cost to finance the deal. That gives you a cap on what to offer. Then you use your judgement and make a bid. After you make your bid, you will get more feedback and can raise the price if necessary.
- specialp 10y agoWell the Devil's advocate view is that Mr. Dell orchestrated the sale to himself without giving the market the knowledge he possessed at the time of the sale. I do not know the details of the case, but Mr. Dell as the CEO of Dell is not a normal buyer, he is someone that has a legal obligation to the shareholders to deliver them maximum value. The lawyers here would have to prove that Mr. Dell was working in his own interest here, and not in the shareholders' interests.
- rubidium 10y agoThat's not really the challenge being placed in this case: " The best reply, especially in a conflicted management buyout where the buyer is also the CEO, is often along the lines of "because management deliberately undermined the sales process to prevent other bidders from seeing the company's true value, so they could take it for themselves on the cheap." But that's not really what happened here; the court found that, while there were some inherent conflicts of interest, Dell's independent directors basically did a bang-up job of running the sales process, and even Michael Dell himself -- despite being both the CEO and the prospective buyer of the company -- behaved like a prince. Actually, reading the opinion, you almost get the sense that Michael Dell didn't do this leveraged buyout for the money. It was just an intellectual engagement, a point of principle. He thought the stock was undervalued, and he wanted to argue his case, and the way you argue that is by buying all the stock."
- joshdickson 10y agoYou're getting a few things mixed up. > '...but to rule that you should offer more than the market was valuing it?' Acquisitions in general are almost always for a premium based on the current market value of the company. Just look at Salesforce/Demandware this morning, with the stock up >50% over where it closed yesterday. As the article states, the current shareholders of the company obviously believe that the company is worth more than the current price - if they didn't, they would have sold their shares. The argument is regarding how much more it was worth, but the practice of it being worth more than it was at the time trading publicly when it comes to a buyout, take-private or acquisition is not in and of itself unusual. > Even though no one was actually willing to pay that price? 'Nobody' is sort of subjective here. No, nobody that was involved in the take-out process was willing to pay that price. But the lawsuit was brought by shareholders, who very well could have believed that the stock was worth $50, yet had positions as large as they could manage. The judge actually ruled that his price was correct because nobody (in the sales process) would be willing to pay that amount as private equity would need a significant return on its capital (25% in this case). > Isn't the whole point of a buyout that you think other investor's are incorrectly valuing a venture based on the available information? If any buyout is going to be subject to this later, with-more-hindsight review that forces buyers to "top up" to the "correct" value, what's the point? The Dell case is unusual because Michael Dell did not make the case for any sort of managerial or strategic shift post-buyout (hell, why would he push for a managerial change as the CEO). Normally in the acquisition/buyout/merger/etc process, there's something materiel that the acquirer wants to change to make the company more valuable. Maybe they want to purchase the company and get rid of all the managers. Maybe they want to purchase the company and achieve cost "synergies" between two or more companies where significant savings could boost sales. Maybe they want to let both companies sell each others products. In this case, Michael Dell didn't want to do anything different from what the current plan for the company had been -- he just wanted to do it in private. So while this decision is wild, it's not one that sets precedents for most acquisitions.
- sideshowb 10y agoBefore the buyout, how much does it really matter what the share price was? Did it affect the physical operation of the company? In other words, sure the price might have been "wrong" but why was it necessary to rush and correct it? Won't the market do that in the long run?