8 ms·
It amazes me that the music industry has the audacity to complain that the DMCA makes things too hard. If anything, the DMCA makes it too easy to take down con
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
It amazes me that the music industry has the audacity to complain that the DMCA makes things too hard. If anything, the DMCA makes it too easy to take down content. And YouTube then makes it even easier than the DMCA, and harder to restore content after faulty takedowns.
This time around, I hope the computing industry and the user-generated content industry are big enough to just say "no, go away and don't ask again".
- Natsu 10y agoThey want what they have long wanted: to push responsibility for enforcement onto someone else. The problem is that no one else can tell what is and is not authorized. Copyright relies on permission and the copyright owner (and only the copyright owner) has any idea to whom they have and have not given permission. Granted, as the Viacom lawsuit against YouTube once proved, even they can get that horribly wrong, but anyone else has even less knowledge to act upon, which should not be encouraging. I'm sure they see that the DMCA spammers are rather ineffective at doing anything but taking their money, which no doubt upsets them, but the level of censorship and preapproval for speech that would be necessary to actually enforce copyright is, in fact, quite draconian. Given how easy it is to quite literally steal someone's video (that is, by both taking it and depriving them the use thereof) with ContentID and how many times something like that has actually happened, I can only fear what might come to pass were they given their wish.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> The problem is that no one else can tell what is and is not authorized. Copyright relies on permission and the copyright owner (and only the copyright owner) has any idea to whom they have and have not given permission. It goes even further than that: there are completely legitimate uses for which the copyright owner hasn't given permission, and their permission is neither requested nor required. YouTube's "Content ID" doesn't take fair use into account at all.
- Natsu 10y agoVery true. They default to believing all use is illegitimate, though
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> Given how easy it is to quite literally steal someone's video (that is, by both taking it and depriving them the use thereof) with ContentID You just made me realize that in the discussion of piracy, the only people who actually steal something is those doing wrongful DMCA takedowns.
- nemothekid 10y agoThe major labels try to frame the discussion around piracy, which confuses everyone else because YouTube bends over backwards when it comes to copyright law. If you dig deeper, its not about piracy - its about control. What do the majors get from Spotify/Apple music that they don't get from YouTube? If the majors don't like their deal with Spotify (whether its 80% of the revenue, or no free listeners), the majors can walk, and if any of their music appears on Spotify, the majors can sue them out of existence. With YouTube it's different - 1.) YouTube is the largest streaming site so users will always look for music there 2.) Anyone can upload music to YouTube 3.) YouTube isn't financially responsible when someone uploads infringing material. These 3 factors mean, if the majors decide they want 80% of YouTube's revenue rather than 50% and YouTube walks, there is a chance (more like a given) that someone will upload Taylor Swift's new album on there pitch shifted by 13% (to evade content id), and will go on to generate millions of views. And since YouTube is protected by the DMCA, the majors can't sue them out of existence. That's why the majors hate the DMCA, as it applies to YouTube. There effectively isn't a "scorch-earth" policy for music on YouTube, and the majors can't leverage their army of lawyers to force YouTube to submit to them if "scorch-earth" fails. Now I doubt "we need to kill the DMCA so we can sue YouTube for billions" is very PR-friendly, but "muh piracy" always is.
- desde_mona 10y agoPaying someone to be an artist is like paying someone to be an alcoholic, and the more I hear Artists collectively complain about the lifestyle I'm failing to enable, while I sit lashed to a desk all day, the more I want to destroy their every dream and aspiration.
- ehnto 10y agoYou seem to be lambasting what you see as entitled behavior, while making it very clear that you are simply bitter that they live a life you either don't agree with or perhaps, are envious of. Either way it isn't up to you to decide who will pay for what, and your assumption that every artist is a drunken freeloader is clearly false. Most working artists also have to hold down a job and will get very little in return for their efforts. They aren't providing nothing, and very clearly people want what they are providing. It takes time, effort and opportunity costs to produce music and to expect that it be given to you for nothing because you think it's frivolous is ridiculous. Do you pay for DVDs? Pay to see movies? What about the artwork on your clothing, or the design of your car? You pay for all of those things directly or indirectly and they could all be considered frivolous in one way or another, yet someone worked hard to make it happen and people are willing to pay for that.
- whiddershins 10y agoIn the sense that DMCA complaints are presumed valid, you are correct. In the sense that the company has plenty of time before they are required to respond to a complaint, it is the opposite, obviously no number of DMCA complaints would, by themselves, stop a popular song from being available on YouTube. Only contentID can do that, and YouTube deploys ContentID at their discretion while being protected by the DMCA from lawsuits. So when all is said and done DMCA is a real pain for regular people, while not providing the protection which was intended.