8 ms·
The Triboro: Transit plan for the NYC Boroughs
- bydo 10y agoWhy call it the Triboro? Even leaving behind the negative associations (one assumes advocates of rail would not want to call to mind thoughts of Robert Moses), there are, err, four boroughs it proposes to connect.
- untog 10y agoThe Staten Island connection is shown as a possible future extension, not part of this plan.
- elliottcarlson 10y agoAs a Staten Island resident, this sucks as usual. I lived here for 10 years, moved to Manhattan and recently moved back because I just can't get the same amount of space for the price in the other boroughs. The work on the Verrazano and SI Expressway has slowed down traffic to worse delays than before, and this island really needs some better transportation options. Currently, I take the express bus every day to my office in the Flatiron district - this takes me on average an hour and 10 minutes door to door, but can easily hit 2 hours due to something happening on either the Verrazano or the FDR. Alternatively, I live close enough to the (there is only one) train on Staten Island that can take me to the Ferry - from there I would get off with everyone else and fight with the crowds taking the various subways up town. This commute is about an hour and 20 minutes, and is broken up in 3 parts that are mildly frustrating during each leg of the commute. Obviously a direct subway connection to the island would be amazing, either to Brooklyn or Manhattan directly, but that plan was scrapped in the 20's and isn't likely to come back any time soon. Some transportation proposals include commuter connections to the NJ light rail via Bayonne; and there is a 20 year project ahead to improve and widen the Verrazano - I don't know how much of that time will cause more delays than there already are. As the North Shore gets gentrified with the new luxury residential buildings like URL (Urban Ready Life - sigh - though it looks like it has now been renamed URBY...), the Wheel (the future world's tallest ferris wheel), Empire Outlets, etc - the area will become a hot new destination for those looking to escape the ever rising prices of the coveted Brooklyn and New Jersey areas like Williamsburg, Crown Heights, Jersey City, etc. Hopefully they have a lot more in store for transportation options when it comes to the island when these projects open to the public over the course of 2017. Sorry for the rant...
- IIAOPSW 10y agoIt isn't a coincidence that commuting time and price of a sq-ft of space are negatively correlated. I guarantee you if someone built a 5 min connection from downtown to Staten Island, the real-estate on SI would very quickly be developed to the exact same state as all the other places that are 5 min from downtown. The thing you want (affordable, spacious, fast transit) simply can't exist.
- dgant 10y agoThey can if the supply greatly increases. That's among the reasons why a project longer the Triboro brings so much opportunity. Decentralizing New York real estate would drastically improve affordability.
- IIAOPSW 10y agoThen more people will see that New York provides better bang for the buck (economic opportunities per rent dollar), which will cause population to increase by migration, which will increase demand, which will eventually get us back to where we started. I'm not saying this proposal is bad. I quite like it. But let's not get the causation backwards. Urban poor aren't poor because of bad access to transit. Urban poor have bad access to transit because they are poor. Building transit ultimately changes the real estate value along the line, temporarily makes everyone's rent cheaper, and permanently increases the population of the city.
- Spooky23 10y agoThis is why I moved upstate. Construction doubled my commute last week -- 15 minutes. When I need to get to Manhattan, it takes me about 30 minutes more than it takes you to do so on a bad day, in the relative luxury of an Amtrak car.
- Kinnard 10y agoThis was so well written that it makes me want to hop on a plane to New York and give it a ride.
- Spooky23 10y agoGood luck convincing CSX to share rails. It took Amtrak decades to get a deal in place for the Hudson River line.
- chris_va 10y agoI'll believe it when I see it. The original IRT network was built in 2 years (!). They've been working on the 2nd avenue line since 1972 and it still isn't open.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hueving 10y agoModern public transit projects in the US are an embarrassment. It takes 20 years now to do something that used to be 1 year. :(
- techsupporter 10y agoI suspect it has a lot to do with building in urbanized areas and using construction and siting methods that care about things like public input and how the environment is affected. (Note: I do not deny that the process can be twisted to suit a particular goal of a small minority--see also Sound Transit's East Link planning through Bellevue, WA.) Instead of the days of the "city fathers" coming in and declaring that a thing will be built in a place and that which exists can either get out of the way or get flattened--and the thing being built in a way that benefits those who greased the right palms with the public coming in a distant second or third--we study, plan, and consider a lot more. As a secondary bit, we also don't have the financial capacity, either by accident or intent of the legislature and voters. Many projects are built with bonding authority backed by voter-approved taxes. The legislature of an area restricts what authority and taxes can be used and in what quantities. Dallas Area Rapid Transit's light rail system was built with a 1% sales tax in member cities...and it still doesn't extend to every city that was a charter member. Sound Transit's light rail and express bus system was built with a combination of taxes, mostly on vehicle registrations and sales, that are under periodic assault from statewide initiatives. Many countries have a "land bank" where the national or provincial/state government "front" the money for the local bonds. (Like Canada and British Columbia did in Vancouver.) Most U.S. states do not. We "did this" to ourselves. It's not the construction, it's the mechanics of getting there.
- 10y ago
- b34r 10y agoWhy not just extend the G? It already is Queens<->Brooklyn.
- acjohnson55 10y agoThat would require a whole bunch of grade-separated right-of-way & track that doesn't currently exist. The brilliance of the Triboro is that it's all already pretty much there. Note also that there's a long history of truncating the G train [1]. I personally would love to see the Franklin Ave Shuttle extended to make a loop out of Brooklyn portion of the current G train route along Church Ave, connecting north-central Brooklyn to Williamsburg, Greenpoint, and Long Island City. That's probably a pipe dream. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_(New_York_City_Subway_service) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_(New_York_City_Subway_servic...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jessriedel 10y agoThis proposal and the G serve very different areas. The motivation is more than just "connect the three boroughs".
- waimbes 10y agoIn addition to what other people have said, the G is VERY slow.
- ktamura 10y ago>Providing a reliable connection between the Bronx, Queens and Brooklyn by rail will provide more direct trips within and between these boroughs than either the subway or bus networks can do today. Buses make up 43% of transit ridership in these three boroughs, but buses operate at an average speed of 8 mph as they fight the city’s heavy traffic. It's amazing to see New York City suffer almost half a century after Robert Moses's decline. One of the worst consequences of Moses's 600 (or was it 700?) miles of highway is how residential areas outside of Manhattan developed: Because he built the city around highways and hence commuting by car, residential areas outside of Manhattan developed into thinly spread suburbs, making it near impossible to create an efficient network of trains. To New York City's credit, they've made a laudable comeback with subways: After all, it's the city you can live without owning cars in the United States. Yet, our generation continues to pay the price of Moses's ego and lack of foresight. RM is a humbling reminder that getting wrong stuff done so effectively has grave and lasting consequences.
- CPLX 10y agoThe story of Robert Moses is a fascinating one and hugely relevant to the shape of NYC, but I'm not sure he really had much to do with the specific issue under discussion. With some relatively small exceptions the city was highly developed and dense before Moses and the car came along, and while he did ram highways through it, he didn't have the effect of making it less dense. This proposal discusses connecting well populated inner city areas laterally, where are these thinly spread suburbs you mention? The issue described here is that the rail transit system is highly Manhattan centric, which well predates Moses.
- rst 10y agoThere were inter-borough light rail lines, specifically streetcars between Brooklyn and Queens, which died of malign neglect in the Moses era (though I don't know how much he personally had to do with that).
- tashoecraft 10y agoWhile the issue started and was establish before Moses, it was his control over nearly all the transportation budget that prevented any new growth. If he had been friendly to mass transit, nyc would have far more subways options.
- StanislavPetrov 10y agoEveryone has a plan until they get punched in the mouth. -Mike Tyson As a New Yorker, I'll be stunned if anything comes of this "plan" except hundreds of billions of dollars wasted and endless hours of sitting in traffic while I pass construction areas filled with equipment and completely devoid of workers or activity.
- forgotmysn 10y agosomeone posted this in response to another comment a while back. thought it was relevant http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/11/why-dont-we-know-where-all-the-trains-are/415152/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/11/why-do...
- Eric_WVGG 10y agoAn amusing thing about this proposal is that it comes only a few weeks after De Blasio’s plan to put a light rail along the Brooklyn/Queens waterfront. Though it would personally benefit me greatly, I must confess that it would mostly be a convenience for yuppies who can afford to live along the water. This Triboro would benefit people who need better transportation.
- Nav_Panel 10y ago> An amusing thing about this proposal is that it comes only a few weeks after De Blasio’s plan to put a light rail along the Brooklyn/Queens waterfront. The Triboro RX proposal has been around for a much longer time than De Blasio's light rail thing. Here's an article about it from 2013: http://www.citylab.com/commute/2013/07/transit-project-new-york-mayoral-candidates-should-be-talking-about/6271/ http://www.citylab.com/commute/2013/07/transit-project-new-y...
- chx 10y agoIn a dream world this would go underground at Jackson Heights and connect LGA to the subway system.
- aj7 10y agoWITHIN BOROUGH, just try to get from LGA to the Ronkonkoma LIRR line. Not an unreasonable request. The line shows sort of helps. But at the least, it should have a station at LGA.
- bryanwb 10y agoDoes it seem odd to anyone else that this plan seems to pretend northern NJ doesn't exist? It would make much more sense to me to make the "triboro" a full-circle rather than a half-circle. If you look at underground map of London you don't see any half-circles.
- CPLX 10y agoThis is a much deeper issue that transcends just rapid transit, and is based on the competing politics and priorities of the two different states. For smaller scale but completely astonishing example of just how dysfunctional that whole issue is, take a look at this: http://newyorkyimby.com/2014/09/the-port-authoritys-missed-connection-the-path-lex-line-that-never-was.html http://newyorkyimby.com/2014/09/the-port-authoritys-missed-c... We did manage to get the world's most expensive and amazing $2bn open atrium shopping mall on that site. And for just a few bucks more we could have had a direct rail connection potentially stretching all the way from Grand Central to Newark Airport. Oh well.
- aninhumer 10y agoThis and the rest of the subway system. It kind of hilarious looking at that map and seeing a dense web of subway lines with none of them going to New Jersey. I'm guessing this is because the administrative boundary means there's no incentive for New York governance to do anything to benefit New Jersey?
- cauterized 10y agoAnd vice-versa. See also: ARC.
- akgerber 10y agoThere are subway lines going to New Jersey— they are just operated by the Port Authority as the PATH.
- pimlottc 10y agoThe top image is the new splash screen. Why not lead with a map of the proposed line above the fold, instead of a pretty but non-informative title page that leads into a page full of text?
- opticalflow 10y agoThis proposal sounds great, but seems to wave its hands furiously about right-of-way and eminent domain. I used to live in Astoria on Ditmars Blvd, and the proposed line would most certainly be going on/over thousands of private residences. I presume their placement is to try and connect this to the end stop of the N subway line, but It's not like Astoria is a junkyard or railyard, it's a dense residential neighborhood with single family and multi-family housing.
- kneisley 10y agoThe plan here is to use the existing above-ground rail line that runs parallel to Ditmars from the park, then along the BQE and into Brooklyn. It is the line that literally has a bridge over the Astoria-Ditmars stop with all the Greek murals.
- ChrisArgyle 10y agoAs a Bronx resident this sounds very exciting. As a jaded consumer of modern media this sounds suspiciously one-sided. What are the downsides? It doesn't seem to generate revenue or lower costs for the city. Why would a politician back this plan?