10 ms·
Music World Bands Together Against YouTube, Seeking Change to Law
- peterkshultz 10y agoI opened the article expecting the music industry to have caught wind of youtube-dl. I was wrong.
- Artistry121 10y agoIt is strange. It seems like all of the artist mentioned have Official Youtube Pages where they post their own videos and music - if they don't want to be on youtube why not take those videos off the site?
- dylz 10y agoWhat makes you think it's them wanting it vs their labels wanting it?
- NEDM64 10y agoIf they don't do, people will upload the full albums and people will listen to those copies. So better put there their songs. Also, YouTube is a monopoly. It's the Microsoft Windows of online media distribution. Developers cannot afford to not release their software for Windows, now imagine if Microsoft decided to build an AppStore like iOS where they decided unilaterally the price of software and their cut, and it were dirty cheap! Damned if you didn't develop for Windows, damned if you did.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> If they don't do, people will upload the full albums and people will listen to those copies. So better put there their songs. And the world's smallest violin will play a royalty-free sad song for them. YouTube already has a huge pile of mechanisms above and beyond the DMCA to automatically identify and take down content. If you don't want your music anywhere on YouTube, you can use those tools, which YouTube doesn't have to provide at all, but which they provide because they want to make business deals with major labels. Personally, I'd love to see YouTube just drop all access to those tools for anyone not on their platform, and labels can go back to filing individual DMCA requests by registered letter.
- Goronmon 10y agoAlso, YouTube is a monopoly. Haha, good one.
- fpgeek 10y agoLet's run with the Windows analogy for the moment. Microsoft did make an iOS-like Windows Store with a standardized cut, though they did let developers have control over pricing. And they bundled it with Windows 8, gave Windows Store apps access to new APIs and generally pushed it as hard as they could. It hasn't gone anywhere (at least not so far). So let's say YouTube has Windows-like market power. Just like Microsoft, they still don't get everything they want. The other side of the table (artists or developers) has market power too - they own the rights to their music or apps. There's nothing stopping them from putting their official presence somewhere else (Facebook, Amazon, Vimeo, ...) and issuing takedowns for everything that shows up on YouTube. That they don't do this is a pretty strong indication that the deal they're getting isn't actually that bad (especially since YouTube's competitors would happily given artists all sorts of incentives to switch to help build their user base).
- eikenberry 10y ago".. now imagine if Microsoft decided to build an AppStore like iOS .." Yeah like they would do that.. http://apps.microsoft.com/ http://apps.microsoft.com/
- dragonwriter 10y agoIn what market is a YouTube a monopoly in the antitrust sense, exercising pricing power?
- ryanobjc 10y agoThe comparison of vinyl vs YouTube I suspect is deliberately misleading. Since vinyl has manufacturing costs, if their $471m figure was revenue, it was the incorrect value to use. The gross margins are typically 50% or in that area +- 10%. Whereas the YouTube revenue has a gross margin of 100%. So very apples and oranges.
- golergka 10y agoHosting is free now?
- seanp2k2 10y agoCertainly orders of magnitude less than producing vinyl and selling it in brick-and-mortar stores. The size of YouTube videos is in the singles-to-tens-of-MB. http://www.cdncalc.com http://www.cdncalc.com suggests delivery costs for commercial for-profit General-purpose CDNs are on the order of 5 cents per GB. YouTube has absolutely massive scale and their own CDN POPs deployed, so I wouldn't be surprised if their costs are a small fraction of this price. However, even at a generous 10MB per video and retail CDN bandwidth cost of 5 cents per GB, delivery of one play of one song is about would cost one twentieth of one cent. I'm sure they're making much more than this for the ad which plays before the video. YouTube also has employees and infrastructure and other costs, but they don't disclose their financials, so it's hard to know exactly how much they spend on hosting: http://www.businessinsider.com/google-cfo-doesnt-disclose-youtube-financial-results-2015-7 http://www.businessinsider.com/google-cfo-doesnt-disclose-yo... All that said, digital distribution tends to be drastically cheaper than physical distribution to the point where it's essential free, and a negative cost once ad revenue is factored in. For a vinyl analogy, imagine Starbucks was paying 1000x the cost of distributing a record if someone went to Starbucks after seeing the ad which was slipped inside the record cover. Another consideration: YouTube makes so much on ads that they're giving some of that money back to content producers because they know that the service they provide is so readily available for free elsewhere that producers need additional incentives to use YouTube specifically. I'm fairly confident that their ad share payouts exceed their bandwidth costs.
- magicalist 10y ago
- chatmasta 10y agoThe self-proclaimed* music world, aka mainstream leftovers and special interest mouthpieces. What about all the artists who would be nowhere without YouTube? Like Justin Bieber, for example.
- Natsu 10y agoTheir videos will probably get taken down by someone else claiming to own them, if history is any guide.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoIt amazes me that the music industry has the audacity to complain that the DMCA makes things too hard. If anything, the DMCA makes it too easy to take down content. And YouTube then makes it even easier than the DMCA, and harder to restore content after faulty takedowns. This time around, I hope the computing industry and the user-generated content industry are big enough to just say "no, go away and don't ask again".
- Natsu 10y agoThey want what they have long wanted: to push responsibility for enforcement onto someone else. The problem is that no one else can tell what is and is not authorized. Copyright relies on permission and the copyright owner (and only the copyright owner) has any idea to whom they have and have not given permission. Granted, as the Viacom lawsuit against YouTube once proved, even they can get that horribly wrong, but anyone else has even less knowledge to act upon, which should not be encouraging. I'm sure they see that the DMCA spammers are rather ineffective at doing anything but taking their money, which no doubt upsets them, but the level of censorship and preapproval for speech that would be necessary to actually enforce copyright is, in fact, quite draconian. Given how easy it is to quite literally steal someone's video (that is, by both taking it and depriving them the use thereof) with ContentID and how many times something like that has actually happened, I can only fear what might come to pass were they given their wish.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> The problem is that no one else can tell what is and is not authorized. Copyright relies on permission and the copyright owner (and only the copyright owner) has any idea to whom they have and have not given permission. It goes even further than that: there are completely legitimate uses for which the copyright owner hasn't given permission, and their permission is neither requested nor required. YouTube's "Content ID" doesn't take fair use into account at all.
- Natsu 10y agoVery true. They default to believing all use is illegitimate, though
- simplexion 10y agoBy "music world" do they mean record labels and musicians signed to record labels?
- pessimizer 10y agoI thought it was a store like Guitar Center. It's just the massive media conglomerates that own us all speaking under a few of their brands. They're fighting the tech companies that make all their money from getting between every communication and collecting rents, and blaming everything that goes wrong on one of the endpoints. "Mommy, the capitalists are fighting again!" "Don't worry baby, we'll just send our check to whoever wins..." Vivendi was started as a municipal water company by Napoleon's nephew, also Napoleon.
- vonklaus 10y agowhat if they banded together and competed. i don't want to trvialize it but youtube is annoying as fuck. * pointless comment system * inability/difficult to just get audio, especially mobile * horrible search experience * weird channel/user ui * many features/services that come and go. youtube red, other premium services, i actually saw a new one today * mobile app i am not saying baseline piracy should be allowed, but as other saas and consumer services become much cheaper, it becomes easier to buy than steal. finding and curating an entire music library is simple and 9.99 on apple and spotify. netflix and prime provide video media more consistently and with less of a hassle than torrenting it due to integration, speed and lack of adware. just roll out the fucking content and let people buy it. if you sue google and take it down, and it can't be immeadiately torrented, that artists music immeadiately won't exist to 60% (prob greater) of the people listening. also, DMCA makes no fucking sense. i cant find the link but random 3rd parties just issue takedowns and get and keep advert revenue. i am against google and youtube being essentially sole purveyors of search and media, but I feel for the people running these services. how do you verify and moderate millions of request? this might even be per hour at this point. last thing this needs is to be changed. either scrap it or keep it, i'd be too scared to see what would happen if this got amnended even with good intentions
- tgb 10y agoThe comment system apparently appeals to a lot of people, just not you or I. It's probably better for the artists to have that than not. If you pay for Youtube Red / Google Play Music, you can get audio only easily on mobile. That's actually why I started subscribing, though now I use it mostly on my laptop. It's essentially 100% covered my music needs since I started. The search actually seems pretty good to me. I generally find what I want very quickly even with typos, etc. Do you have specific thoughts about it? UI can definitely be a little wonky for say, browsing a channel I frequently can't find what I want without searching. And the damn auto-playing video on the channel page! I end up having to stop it playing four or five times in short succession the way I use the page. Anyway, opinions differ.
- pluma 10y agoYouTube Red is not available everywhere (or even US-only at the moment, I think?) and Google Play Music is a completely unrelated (though excellent) service. Also, YouTubers complain more about the comment system than the people commenting do. There's a reason many videos these days have comments disabled. There was also a lot of negativity when the comment system was changed as part of the Google+ rollout. The commenting system is really only useful for the channels when considered in aggregates -- there's barely any point in trying to hold individual conversations -- it's worse than Twitter. Maybe NLP and sentiment analysis could be used to build moderation/analytics tools to improve that use case. The UI is nice but wonky. As a web developer myself I frequently look at YouTube as an example for what kind of sloppy UX you can get away with in a billion dollar flagship product. It's also gone through several even worse iterations (e.g. the dreaded keep-video-playing-when-you-navigate-away "feature" that was supposed to emulate the behaviour of the mobile app). As an example for a current mis-feature of YouTube (i.e. something intentional they had to actually go out of their way to develop): volume and speed are saved (less or more reliably) and persisted globally and indefinitely if you change them. Listened to a couple of talks on 1.5x or 2x yesterday? Now all the music videos you're watching are sped up too. Had to turn the volume way up on that video podcast? Better turn it back down before the next video's incredibly loud conference jingle comes up. These features as they are only make sense if you use YouTube for precisely one thing and one thing only. The second you approach it with different use cases the features become annoying and distracting.
- bluesign 10y agoYouTube is not so honest I guess tbh, instead on forcing artists for contentID sign up, they can as well at first DCMA request calculate contentID, and block all current and future violations automatically, and artists don't have to send DCMA for every violation