5 ms·
The consequence is that a whole body of work winds up coming with an asterisk until people figure out what they can and can't trust. Papers may be looked at fo
by btilly 10y ago
The consequence is that a whole body of work winds up coming with an asterisk until people figure out what they can and can't trust. Papers may be looked at for inspiration, but won't be quoted for results. Eventually some of it gets proved properly, and the rest is abandoned. After that the older papers become mere historical curiosities.
A reasonably recent example of this is the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_school_of_algebraic_geometry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_school_of_algebraic_ge....
A possible place where this could happen is the classification of finite groups. It has been "proven", but the proof is long, technical, and never was adequately reviewed. Lots of papers these days start off using the classification in interesting ways. However there is an open program to produce an actual reviewed proof. If in the process of doing that, we found that the original result was long, there would be a fairly large project to figure out the consequences.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classification_of_finite_simple_groups https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classification_of_finite_simpl... for more.
- tamana 10y agoBut when the results are useless anyway, it doesn't really matter if they are right or wrong...they just may be speculative of some alternate universe, or may still contain ideas that are applicable elsewhere.
- Natanael_L 10y agoPrime numbers used to be useless when first researched (edit: during the previous two centuries, when their properties was studied). We don't always know in advance what will turn up useful.
- kragen 10y agoYou say, "Prime numbers used to be useless when first researched," but when the Middle-Kingdom Egyptians were doing their initial research on prime numbers, they needed them for the algorithms they used to calculate with fractions. These were used in the Rhind Papyrus to calculate things like the volumes of granaries. You could hardly have picked a worse example.
- btilly 10y agoNo, he picked a famous and perfect example. He just didn't specify it well enough. Over the last 2 centuries, number theorists developed the theory of large prime numbers. The numbers that they were dealing with were so large that they had no conceivable use in describing the physical universe. Famously one prominent number theorist, G. H. Hardy, wrote A Mathematician's Apology, a book describing and justifying his life. In it he famously described his field as being utterly useless with no practical applications. Then cryptography came along, and the mathematics of finding large prime numbers, and factoring hard to factor large numbers, turned out to have practical applications of great importance!
- kragen 10y agoPlease don't blame me for refuting what he did say, instead of what he would have said if he'd known what he was talking about.
- Natanael_L 10y agoI meant exactly what he mentioned. How was I supposed to know you were going to bring up a far older example which I hadn't heard of?
- btilly 10y agoFrom my point of view, both of you demonstrated a lop-sided knowledge of math history. Clearly you know more about the ancient history and origins. I'd be willing to bet that you know that the ancient Greeks knew 2500 years ago what prime numbers were, had proved that there were an infinite number of them, had algorithms like the Euclidean algorithm for finding the greatest common denominator, had proven unique factorization AND had demonstrated that sqrt(2) was not a fraction. We don't actually know how much farther a lot of the knowledge goes. On the other side he had obviously encountered cryptography, and knew that a whole lot of the necessary number theory dates back to Gauss, 200 years ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disquisitiones_Arithmeticae https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disquisitiones_Arithmeticae is the origin of concepts like modular arithmetic, quadratic residues, and so on. But he was not familiar with the ancient history predating that, or else he could not have thought that the study of primes only goes back 200 years! He could have avoided the problem on his side by Googling for what he was going to say before saying things with glaring and obvious errors. Very few of us are so careful. You could have avoided the problem on your side by giving him the benefit of the doubt and assuming that he's probably not a complete idiot, then trying to figure out what he might have meant. You might or might not have figured out "cryptography", but you could have at least made your post in the form of a much more pleasant question. However that is fairly rare to find, and doubly so online. As for me, I'm just lucky enough to know both halves of the history, so could easily sort it out.