3 ms·
A lot of the discussion here seems to revolve around UBI as a solution for poverty and homelessness, but I would argue that that's missing the point. As I wrot
by carapace 10y ago
A lot of the discussion here seems to revolve around UBI as a solution for poverty and homelessness, but I would argue that that's missing the point. As I wrote this this morning in re: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11807201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11807201
"""
Keep in mind when discussing UBI, especially in the context of poverty, that it is not a solution to poverty. It is a solution to automation crashing demand by throwing earners permanently out of the economy.
Robots take the jobs so people have no money to spend even as the robots make more stuff, cheaper.
What to do with the people? Throw them in a volcano? "Hunger Games"? Let's just give them money and see what happens, okay?
That's UBI.
UBI isn't for the bum. It's for you (okay, well, your cousin. You read HN, you're probably fine.)
"""
The thing that makes UBI make sense is that the economic order is being overturned by automation.
We simply no longer need to work to live. Bucky Fuller pointed this out decades ago. His estimate put the inflection point in the mid-seventies.
We are punishing ourselves.
---
I want to have UBI so I can devote myself to a program of research. It may not pay off, in fact, it almost certainly won't. But there is a small but non-zero chance that it will pay off handsomely in terms of benefit to society. It's also a very non-linear, meaning that there is absolutely no way I can predict when it might payoff, right up until the moment it does (or I die, whichever comes first.)
There is no one to whom I can honestly say, "Fund me, it's worth it." Maybe I could find an arch-angel investor, but it would be pure patronage (not to say charity.) But with a Universal Basic Income I can devote myself to gardening and research and be no trouble at all to anyone. And I'm not doing anything uniquely important at my job so no one would be harmed if I quit.
- jrochkind1 10y agoWhy do you feel the need to distinguish between "the bum", and "you", a victim of "automation crashing demand by throwing earners permanently out of the economy." Can't some portion of current 'bums', or the homeless, be victims of "automation crashing demand by throwing earners permanently out of the economy" too? I would think they are. Hasn't the process already begun, a long time ago, if perhaps speeding up now? Some of the present poor and homeless definitely seem to have been "permanently thrown out of the economy" to me.
- carapace 10y agoYes, in fact, this is exactly the point I was making. People are talking like the homeless are someone else when the rationale for UBI, in my opinion, is that we are almost all about to be homeless (unless we adjust our systems.)
- jrochkind1 10y agoAgreed, but you seemed to be suggesting that the current homeless or very poor are something different than that, and different from you and I. I think this is an inconsiderate and inaccurate suggestion, by and large.
- carapace 10y agoFriend, I was homeless for about four years. I know that we are all truly equal. I apologize for suggesting anything less. Please forgive me. :-)
- jrochkind1 10y agofair enough. :)