2 ms·
I know that the current trend among academics (in the US, less so elsewhere) is to insist that dyslexia has no visual component, and that it is purely phonologi
by gnicholas 10y ago
I know that the current trend among academics (in the US, less so elsewhere) is to insist that dyslexia has no visual component, and that it is purely phonological. This leads people to draw the seemingly-obvious conclusion that special fonts cannot make reading easier for dyslexia, since they are visual.
This is an unfortunate oversimplification. Even if dyslexia is not primarily visual (a question that is not settled in the international research community), reading itself is indisputably visual. So changing visual aspects of reading can have an impact on the overall ease of reading for dyslexic readers, even if it's not directly easing the "dyslexic part" of the reader's struggles.
Approaching this from another angle, researchers have indicated that visual tweaks such as alternative fonts may disproportionately impact readers with dyslexia because of second-order effects. That is, a reader who has dyslexia likely reads less than his or her peers, since it is more difficult/unenjoyable. As a result, the reader is not as practiced at reading in general, and can benefit—sometimes significantly—from visual tweaks that are helpful for readers who are not as highly skilled.
Lastly, in my experience (as founder of a startup whose browser plugin integrates OpenDyslexic and has thousands of users with dyslexia), I have heard from many readers with dyslexia that the OpenDyslexic font is incredibly helpful for them. While it is true that "the plural of anecdote is not data", it is also true that if a large number of people who don't know each other all report the same phenomenon, there's a good chance it's happening. (This is subject to the regular caveats of placebo effects, self-deception, etc.)
I congratulate the author on recognizing that folks have different experiences and that dyslexia fonts are not a panacea—this sort of thinking is strangely lacking in many parts of the dyslexia world. Also, I agree that things tend to get out of hand on social media when people post "this is what it's like to be dyslexic" graphics, which are generally pretty flimsy. Despite this, some of these fonts are, for some people, very very useful.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jamesrom 10y ago> So changing visual aspects of reading can have an impact on the overall ease of reading for dyslexic readers, even if it's not directly easing the "dyslexic part" of the reader's struggles. So... making fonts easier to read for everyone makes them easier to read for dyslexics? Who'd a thought... > it is also true that if a large number of people who don't know each other all report the same phenomenon, there's a good chance it's happening. True, but with no control case, you can only support your first premise: that making a font more readable is helpful for dyslexics. You can say that OpenDyslexic is more readable, but you haven't proven that it's more readable for dyslexics.
- gnicholas 10y agoThe thing is, OpenDyslexic and Dyslexie don't make reading easier for all people. Most non-dyslexic folks find them to be annoying/ugly/distracting.