5 ms·
Sorry if OT, but this article hits a pet peeve of mine: unclear examples. In the initial image for the problem, it shows a mountain that is practically symmetri
by SilasX 10y ago
Sorry if OT, but this article hits a pet peeve of mine: unclear examples. In the initial image for the problem, it shows a mountain that is practically symmetrical and thus doesn't convey any of the intuition for why it would be "hard" for the climbers to stay at the same height for the whole trip.
They should have used an illustration where the sides of the mountain were more obviously different.
An example should be chosen to highlight as much variation as possible so the reader can tell what is and isn't essential to the problem.
- bikamonki 10y agoIt wouldn't be a puzzle if the range was symmetrical so it is safe to assume it isn't.
- elbigbad 10y agoI didn't get the impression that it was symmetrical from the picture, and I was browsing on a phone. I guess it could have been more clearly marked though. Plus, as the other reply noted, the "problem" wouldn't have been a problem if both sides were symmetrical.
- tgb 10y agoI don't think the comment is pointing out the difficulty in telling whether it's meant to be symmetric, it's pointing out that the symmetric case is trivial and so any example should be really different from the symmetric case in order to serve well as an example. It's hard to picture how the climbers might have any difficulty whatsoever when seeing an example that's almost trivial.