3 ms·
People wonder "where is the money going to come from?" On a national level it could be newly issued fiat currency, which silences the "it's theft!" argument but
by EGreg 10y ago
People wonder "where is the money going to come from?" On a national level it could be newly issued fiat currency, which silences the "it's theft!" argument but then raises the crucial question: what about inflation?
Well, there are two issues here:
1) If the people are freed up to learn or take jobs (I wish minimum wage would be abolished in any jurisdiction that UBI is given out) then more dollars would be chasing more goods and services, so no inflation.
2) However, if there will be more money chasing the SAME number of goods and services, we would have to remove the money from the system by taxing corporations. And this is, in fact, something that raises questions of liberty (of corporations). Corporations can choose where to operate and they often choose tax havens.
What we should really be doing is recognizing the incredible changes that are coming because of AI and its effects on automation in the next 20-30 years. Demand for human labor will fall and experience massive shocks. Wealth creation will increasingly be done by ROBOTS.
This is a GOOD THING as it breaks countries' historic dependency on social security schemes working from having more and more children pay for the elderly. That leads to overpopulation and kicks the can down the road to the children.
Instead, we want to TAX THE MACHINES by somehow measuring the productivity gains from laying people off. Not enough to disincentivize R&D but enough to scale with the UBI and remove money from the system. The machines don't really need to keep ALL the money and the argument that "taxation is theft" starts to sound silly when you are taxing profits of corporations run largely by machines.
The other way, of course, is to redistribute the money to shareholders in the public stock market via dividends. This has been the "socialism" we've had so far in this country.
- greedo 10y ago"newly issued fiat currency" is theft. Forced inflation is theft from people with savings etc etc etc.
- pekk 10y agoBy this logic, anything that increases inflation is theft because anything that reduces savings is theft. This is too broad a notion of theft.
- greedo 10y agoIntentionally devaluing currency is taking money from people's savings. It might not be considered theft by statute, because government, but it's still taking people's money. It's a great way to sidestep opposition to increasing tax rates.
- dragonwriter 10y agoI accept that some people have this broad of a concept of "theft", and I have no problem (so long as it is clear what is meant) with using the word this way, however, once it is broadened this far, I fail to see any necessary connections with the moral implications of more typical definitions of "theft".
- greedo 10y agoNormally I would say that printing more fiat currency isn't theft since it's usually done in a lawful manner. And since theft is by definition unlawful taking, then that wouldn't qualify. But inflating the money supply by 2-3 trillion dollars would be a generational transfer of money like we've never witnessed in the US.
- dredmorbius 10y ago1970s
- EGreg 10y agoI handled the inflation issue in my comment. In scenario #1 there is no theft from anyone even in your sense. And frankly, when you open a store in a mall, it's not theft for the mall to use your rent money as it sees fit. It might build a toy train ride for kids that you disagree with, or spend on a promotion of itself. Same with a state you register your business in. We are talking about abstract entities here, but you are applying a word to equivocate with the visceral feeling one gets in a personal setting.
- greedo 10y agoSimply stating that you've "silenced the" theft argument doesn't make it so. Anymore than the Church branding Galileo a heretic didn't refute heliocentrism.
- EGreg 10y agoOne can say the same about simply stating something is theft, and not making an effort to address the response point by point.
- pyronik 10y agoIs anyone disputing that the purchasing power of one group/person is being increased at the expense of another against their will. This generally meets the accepted definition of stealing.
- antisthenes 10y agoNewly issued fiat currency is an incentive to keep more money in circulation for goods and services. You could just as easily make the argument that in a near-zero inflation economy, people who are ardent savers are also thieves of economic mobility, because they keep the vast majority of money out of circulation, which stifles economic activity (making it not just a zero-sum game, but actually a negative-sum game) I mean, you have complete freedom of speech, so you can call an apple an orange for all I care, but labeling things like inflation as theft (and generally people like you also call taxes theft) just doesn't serve your argument and betrays a complete misunderstanding of basic economics beyond supply/demand. Issuing fiat currency is a monetary policy tool, no more no less. It can be harmful or useful depending on the context it is used. Assigning terms with a moral imperative like "theft" to a tool is alike to assigning the word "murder" to anything that can be used as a weapon.
- greedo 10y agoThere's keeping the monetary supply liquid, and there's pumping $2-3 trillion dollars into it with BI. Taxes won't pay for this scale of program, short of highly confiscatory rates, so the only way to fund this is to devalue currency by printing more money. I didn't say "inflation was theft," I said forced inflation, with the goal of paying for something unsupported by government revenues is theft.
- EGreg 10y agoTo be fair, you consistently call $2-3 Trillion theft, but I wonder why you use a phrase that anarcho-capitalists use for any amount of taxation? For them it is a matter of principle, not amount.
- greedo 10y agoFor the same reason that stealing a loaf of bread is usually a misdemeanor, and stealing a car, a felony. The amount definitively affects the conversation. If the Fed decides that 250 million $1 bills need to be replaced due to damage etc, and they print 251 million, that's not going to have a dramatic affect. If they decided to print 2-3 Trillion (annually, mind you), the effect would be horrendous. As to phrases anarcho-capitalists use, I have no clue.
- orlandob 10y agoSo many intelligent people read this site yet only a handful understand real world monetary policy and economics. Thank you for this comment.