3 ms·
This. I can confidently predict that most people will be better off (vs a control group) for having their income topped up for a fixed period by wealthy philant
by notahacker 10y ago
This. I can confidently predict that most people will be better off (vs a control group) for having their income topped up for a fixed period by wealthy philanthropists, in addition to any benefit entitlements they may already be eligible for.
But that's not Basic Income. Basic Income is replacing [most aspects of] the welfare state with a programme that redistributes portions of income from each according to their ability to each irrespective of their need, with all the complications entailed by the variable incidence of the increase in taxes required to balance the books and the likely reduction in state benefits to some needier citizens.
You might get some useful insights, but you can't say much about the viability of a programme from a study which only evaluates the bits that people are unlikely to be upset by.
- tamana 10y agoAlternatively, adding a BI may show that recipients do not need more social services to improve their lot, so we can stop growing them. Similar to how we don't withold all basic medical care when testing efficacy of a new drug.