5 ms·
Also: "A universal basic income has many undesirable features, starting with its nonnegligible disincentive to work." I can think of two responses to this: (1
by otterley 10y ago
Also: "A universal basic income has many undesirable features, starting with its nonnegligible disincentive to work."
I can think of two responses to this:
(1) Perhaps work that doesn't pay more than a UBI can provide is not work worth doing --
(2) Except for charity work, which is extremely valuable, and which would be greatly incentivized because having a UBI would free up people's time to work on it.
- prostoalex 10y ago> Perhaps work that doesn't pay more than a UBI can provide is not work worth doing This is a frequent argument invoked in favor of a higher minimum wage, and the answer is maybe. But then you find out that some fairly useful work, such as running a convenience store or a corner bodega in a low-income neighborhood involves significantly lower margins than operating a Whole Foods or organic juicery in a ritzy residential neighborhood, and people start decrying "food deserts" http://baltimore.cbslocal.com/2015/02/03/food-deserts-continue-to-plague-poor-neighborhoods/ http://baltimore.cbslocal.com/2015/02/03/food-deserts-contin...
- otterley 10y agoGrocery stores in general, even large supermarket chains, have incredibly low margins (5%, typically). They survive on volume. So it's not about margin as much as it is about income. At any rate, a UBI could possibly make these low-income operations sustainable by providing a helpful boost to the owner's income.
- unprepare 10y agoits almost as if hiring a low income neighborhood worker for an extremely low wage isnt particularly beneficial to the neighborhood.....
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Perhaps work that doesn't pay more than a UBI can provide is not work worth doing Work doesn't have to pay more than a UBI provides to be worth doing in a system with a UBI -- the idea that it does is a failure to recognize the central difference between UBI and means-tested benefit programs. Because UBI doesn't get reduced for additional income (beyond the effect of regular income taxation), there is little to no disincentive for additional work; additionally, most UBI proponents favor UBI eventually eliminating minimum wage (though in an early-stage, not-yet-adequate-for-independent-support UBI, the UBI might merely reduce the minimum wage by some amount), so that UBI reduces the structural barriers for low-money-value work that remains mutually beneficial getting done.
- ahartman00 10y ago(1) Perhaps work that doesn't pay more than a UBI can provide is not work worth doing I largely agree with you here, coal mining being a notable exception. As much as I want to be only on renewables, coal makes up 33% [1] of our current production. They talk about how gas prices are a drag on the economy, I dont want to find out what happens when 33% of power becomes much more expensive!! And fwiw, I do not share the optimism/pessimism that all jobs will be obsolete in 5 years. I dont agree with people who are saying, "just automate it!" Easier said than done(which is a good thing). 1. https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=427&t=3 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=427&t=3
- unprepare 10y agooh no! the most pollutant form of energy will become more expensive! whatever shall we do!? /s this is only a bad thing to people heavily invested in coal. There are other sources of energy which are nearly competitive on price already, with a labor hike Solar would become drastically more competitive (IMO more in line with costs of externalities)