Good points. In retrospect I think it would be pretty easy to beat a fine. Imagine the following scenario: - I download the song 'Happy Birthday' illegally -

Good points. In retrospect I think it would be pretty easy to beat a fine. Imagine the following scenario: - I download the song 'Happy Birthday' illegally - I get caught and get a fine, which I have the option of appealing in court (lets say the fine is something outrageous like £500) - I option to appeal but before the court date I go to HMV and buy a single of 'Happy Birthday' for £5, and scratch it up a bit so it doesnt look shiny new. - I get to court with my CD and say "I already legally owned a copy of the song, but its all scratched so I downloaded it" Strange thing is, you beat the fine but the record company still gets your £5 for the purchase (and you keep your copy)...so minus the hassle, everyone wins.