4 ms·
>> The big difference this time is that AI makes money. This is not in support of the parent's position, but expert systems also made money and in fact continu
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
>> The big difference this time is that AI makes money.
This is not in support of the parent's position, but expert systems also made money and in fact continue to do so today, as they're still in wide use in industry for instance in airliner maintenance, fraud detection etc. Obviously those are legacy systems and sometimes they're only de facto expert systems (as in, they're a big database of rules with an inference engine, though nobody calls them an "expert system"). Still- the technologies invented back then did make a lot of money to many people. But, the market for expert systems went bust and people lost their money, and that's what really killed the field.
The number of people working on AI then and now is not very easy to compare. There was no Google, Facebook or even Apple and Microsoft in the first AI boom. IBM was around and it did do a lot of research in GOFAI, particularly logic programming. I've read IBM papers discussing Prolog type systems for instance. And let's not forget that Deep Blue was essentially an expert system: it searched a database of domain knowledge compiled from the opinions of experts. So, mutatis mutandis (if I may), there was inerest in GOFAI from the industry and there was money invested in it. The difference in that respect with what's going on today is not that clear-cut.
>> This time, it's more about making money, and much of the stuff actually works. Machine learning may hit a wall too, but it's useful.
I'm not going to disagree with that- not entirely. That machine learning is useful so far, there's no doubt, but it remains to be seen how useful it is in the long term. Like with expert systems, the obstacles may be more political, than anything else. I'm finishing a Masters in AI (as in, lots of machine learning) that was paid by my former employer, a big financial corporation- and yet, there was no interest in machine learning in the whole company for most of the time I was there. Maybe that says more about my ability to sell stuff (it's approximately 0) but I really did get the feeling that the corporate world doesn't understand the tech and doesn't care to understand the tech, so if machine learning rises or falls will entirely depend on politics and not how well it works, or doesn't.