4 ms·
Very cool, though I was hoping it have an option to take into account the terrain, especially in San Francisco... Or perhaps just a heat map showing hilly area
by tlrobinson 17y ago
Very cool, though I was hoping it have an option to take into account the terrain, especially in San Francisco...
Or perhaps just a heat map showing hilly areas would be good enough.
- natfriedman 17y agoOr the Google Maps Terrain view? http://bit.ly/blsELO http://bit.ly/blsELO You can drag the route around to avoid hills manually. It would be nice if it did it automatically, to avoid the worst hills. To do it optimally it'd need to know your weight...
- davidw 17y agoYour weight is just one factor. Others, some of which are more important are: * Your fitness level. * What kind of gearing your bike has. * The weather. * How much you actually feel like riding up a hill.
- rgrig 17y agoThat sounds too complicated. They just need a slider between: * avoid hills like plague, and * bring it on!
- tlrobinson 17y agoTerrain view isn't high enough resolution. I just want a heat map showing "hot spots".
- jonknee 17y agoSounds like it's already there... "They will seek to route around hills, whenever practical." Though in SF that can be tough.
- starkfist 17y agoI mapped a route from the Haight Street entrance of Golden Gate Park to the Castro Safeway. The route ends up being almost correct. The route going to the Safeway bombs down Page street to Laguna and then wraps around. Overshooting like this sort of makes sense, but I would have just cut out at The Wiggle at Scott street and weaved over. On the way back it used The Wiggle, but then goes up Page, which has a bike path, but is very steep. Elevation-wise, it makes more sense to do the full Wiggle over to Fell and then use the Panhandle bike trail.
- tlrobinson 17y agoDoh, you're right. I actually mapped nearly the same route (I live in upper Haight) and I saw it didn't use the Wiggle, but didn't realize it was because the route was downhill. I wonder if it's based on special cases (like the mapped bike routes) or terrain. Anyway, that's great.
- starkfist 17y agoIt tends towards mapped bike routes. I don't think it would send anyone on Page for any reason other than it has a bike lane. I now live in NYC and it has mapped a few convoluted routes along the FDR bike path, when it would be far faster to use 2nd or 3rd avenue.
- mikeryan 17y agoI think in SF they need a special "fixie - non bike messenger" option that keeps you on the flats between point a and b.
- trop 17y agoIn some cities (Austin, Chicago, DC, Louisville, New York City, San Diego, Seattle) it's worth checking out http://ridethecity.com/ http://ridethecity.com/. Not just because it lists "elevation gain" for each route (though I'm not sure if it chooses routes with the least gain), nor because it has "safe/safer/direct" option for routing, or even because once logged in it allows setting per-street routing preferences. At a quick glance at Google vs Ride the City for NYC, Google seems to be lacking in a lot of on-the-street know-how (though of course has a fantastically better UI). Something similar happened with Google's public transit directions vs. http://hopstop.com/ http://hopstop.com/. Google seems to tend to idealize the model (assumes that intersections work, lights are timed, and trains run on time), while Ride the City and HopStop, for all their awkwardness, seem to understand the many things that can go wrong with seemingly clearcut routes.