3 ms·
I actually wish a lot of papers in my area (speaking as a grad student) had more novel-like writing and were less hung-up on seeming formal. I've been reading a
by _delirium 17y ago
I actually wish a lot of papers in my area (speaking as a grad student) had more novel-like writing and were less hung-up on seeming formal. I've been reading a bunch of logic papers lately, mainly to mine techniques and ideas for an application-oriented use of logic that my thesis is built on, and the papers parcel out concepts so slowly, and fail to explain any intuition about them, that it's pretty slow going. It's like 90% proofs that I don't care about (put them in an appendix) and 10% actual content I might want to read.
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoI agree with you, but that's what you have to do to get published. My first PhD thesis was rejected, although my viva saved me and I was given permission to re-write. The second version had mostly the same material, mostly the same proofs, but was written in a style that made it seem harder and more inaccessible. It appeared more impressive, so it made a better impression. Clear, accurate and engaging writing is hard and undervalued. My advice is: learn to live with it. After all, you don't really have a choice.
- zbyszek 17y agoYes and no. In my experience it is usually a mistake for scientists to try to write fancy prose like a novelist. I would much rather have a dull but comprehensible paper (all short, plain and simple sentences) than any kind of highly literate ambiguity, or indeed the over-formal pomposity you rightly complain about. A scientific paper should not be a work of entertainment or showing off, but an attempt to communicate an idea. Remember that a paper is written for several audiences, and the annoying crap that you don't care about might be of vital importance to someone else. Having said that, it is nice when a paper is well arranged so that you can find what you want, but too often you just have to develop your cherry-picking skills.