3 ms·
Startup theory 101: your customer is the person who pays you. What they buy is the story about how you're solving their problem. What the universities are buyi
by marcus_holmes 10y ago
Startup theory 101: your customer is the person who pays you. What they buy is the story about how you're solving their problem.
What the universities are buying is not access to the papers. No-one in this whole system gives a monkey about papers.
The universities are buying a solution to their filtering problem. Allowing anyone to produce "proper science" with no filtering mechanism will kill the universities' business model.
There needs to be a filtering mechanism that stops "crackpot" science from getting in. The journal system works well for this. If all "proper" science is in the peer-reviewed journals then everything else can be ignored as crackpottery.
So the universities sell qualifications that are a prerequisite to being published in journals. People without qualifications do not get published. Papers not published in journals are ignored.
Universities pay Elsevier for journals so that they in turn can sell qualifications to students and farm research grants from governments.
None of this has anything to do with science or access to papers.
If SciHub develops an effective filtering mechanism (like ArXiv has apparently done) then that's the existential threat to both Elsevier and the Universities that support it.