7 ms·
In an effort to be entirely objective: disagreeing with a person is not trolling, and Russians do not agree with NATO- which makes sense given that NATO was or
by dijit 10y ago
In an effort to be entirely objective:
disagreeing with a person is not trolling, and Russians do not agree with NATO- which makes sense given that NATO was orchestrated specifically against Russia.
I can't help but pity them, it's like having a pit-bull in the corner that nobody loves because it defended them before in a savage way, so they keep putting up gates and fences and pushing it into solitude. I agree that Crimea was not exactly an ideal scenario but I can see both sides of that too. And neither side is as black as they're painted.
Realistically, with the exclusion of Crimea, Russia has done nothing that any other large country hasn't done with regards to borders, the difference is that when a British fighter jet comes close to France's border nobody cares because we're allied. But we crucify them for it.
As a wise man once said. We make peace with our enemies, not our friends.
(The reason I'm talking about this is because of the recent advances of NATO in putting US military installations in Poland to "combat ISIL", and Russians complaining about it has been tagged as trolling somehow.)
- Udo 10y ago> disagreeing with a person is not trolling The word troll has evolved to encompass any sort of dishonest internet activity that is designed to manipulate the response and attitude of the larger audience, but I agree: the right term would be astroturfing. > it's like having a pit-bull in the corner that nobody loves because it defended them before in a savage way That hilariously fails to describe Russia in any way most people would recognize. > Realistically, with the exclusion of Crimea, Russia has done nothing that any other large country hasn't done with regards to borders That's a pretty big exclusion, but concerns about its borders and the threat of annexation - as elevated as it is compared to any other country - is not the main concern here.
- dijit 10y ago>> it's like having a pit-bull in the corner that nobody loves because it defended them before in a savage way >That hilariously fails to describe Russia in any way most people would recognize. I agree. And that's a shame, Russia has always vied for peace and used force where peace was impossible. That's a trend we see all thoughout history (especially in Britain). We can't exactly crucify them for it. >That's a pretty big exclusion, but concerns about its borders and the threat of annexation - as elevated as it is compared to any other country - is not the main concern here. Sure. It's not but I was preempting someone else bringing it up. And while it's a big exemption you have to at least try to understand Russia's position. Not only is it a military base falling into enemy hands, it's control of a southern region, it's potential troubles for its populace that live there in addition and finally they held a refferendum which is certainly the democratically preferred method of agreeing or disagreeing with political change. Just because we didn't send EU troops (who for all russia knows are the same folk who caused destabilisation in the Ukrainian country) to conduct it doesn't mean it was definitely rigged. It doesn't necessarily mean it was free of corruption either of course but I'm playing devils advocate. Because the devil seems to need one.
- woodandsteel 10y agoI think Russia's problem is it spent its entire history surrounded by powerful enemies, and was frequently invaded. As a consequence Putin honestly believes NATO has the intention of invading it, and so he thinks Russia has to take aggressive actions to prevent that. What he doesn't get is that, thanks to nuclear weapons and modern industrialization, NATO is not interested in doing that for either reasons of security or wealth. That is why, when the Cold War ended, NATO nations drastically cut their arms budgets. NATO would like to basically leave Russia alone, but Russia's agressive actions are forcing it to respond.
- nobullet 10y agoIt is all a lot simpler: power, money and sphere of influence. No one is going to give up power and money in a poor country. That's why Mr. Putin and Company build tons of bullshit about external enemies, preventing folks from blaming the government for existing economical and social problems. Disclaimer: I'm from a country that is in Eastern Europe and borders with Russia. It also has very close relations with it. Russia affects internal politics and mass media. 80% are brain-washed.
- ptaipale 10y ago>I think Russia's problem is it spent its entire history surrounded by powerful enemies That applies not only to Russia, but to pretty much everyone. Particularly, it applies to each of Russia's neighbours...
- cjensen 10y agoCrimea. Georgia. Transnistria. It's become a pattern for Russia to use military force instead of diplomacy to resolve disputes. The notion that "Russia has done nothing that any other large country hasn't done" is entirely wrong.
- unlinker 10y agoNATO would never use military force to fix stuff, right?
- krzyk 10y agoTo annex part of a country? I don't remember.
- pandaman 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kosovo#Declaration_of_independence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kosovo#Declaration_of_independ...
- krzyk 10y agoIt didn't annex it, they created a country out of it. And it still is a country. Can you say the same about Crimea?
- pandaman 10y agoHow could they create a country out of a part of another country without an annexation taking place first? Or, are you going to argue, that Russia did not annex Transistria and South Othetia because a country was created?
- vetinari 10y agoKosovo?
- 10y ago
- TryAgainMaybe 10y ago"with the exclusion of Crimea, Russia has done nothing that any other large country hasn't done with regards to borders" Haha that's an absurd exclusion. You don't get to pick and choose which criteria are valid when judging the behaviour of a government.
- pinaceae 10y agoRussia occupied half of Europe, against the will of the countries occupied, for nearly 50 years. Stop re-writing history.
- aaronchall 10y ago> Russia occupied half of Europe, against the will of the countries occupied, for nearly 50 years. Good point. Seems like we forget this.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoHow would you define "against their will"? I mean, their representatives signed the Warsaw Pact without gun to their heads (however I'm aware about Hungary'56 and Chezhoslovakia'68) This isn't a fair argument. Imagine, tomorrow USA fails, a lot of its former allies get current marginal opposition in power. They'll line up telling how USA occupied them, did this and that against their will. And they'll be partially right. Partially wrong. The boundaries in Europe after WWII were determined by WWII. That's how it went.
- vetinari 10y agoTo expand on your point: It wasn't Russia who invaded Czechoslovakia in 1968. It was entire Warsaw pact. Or, almost entire. There was one country, that didn't take part: Romania. Out of the entire Warsaw pact only Ceaușescu's Romania had the backbone to not invade. Others, like GDR, Poland, Hungary, took their part voluntarily. (That's nothing new: Poland and Hungary attacked the rump Czechoslovakia in 1938 too. That's just expanding your second paragraph). There is yet another twist - even for USSR, it wasn't Russia itself. It was USSR, which was comprised of many more countries at the time. The units that were in Czechoslovakia were Ukrainians. And before there are arguments, that they were commanded from Moscow, the head honcho at the time was Brezhnev, from Ukraine.
- pinaceae 10y agowho gave the orders? who was in charge? was it the kremlin or the marsians?
- wavefunction 10y agoSo you exclude Crimea but what about Eastern Ukraine? I have no love lost for the scheming of Nuland and NATO and the rest of that cadre but Russia has some serious internal and foreign-facing issues. And that man you quoted wasn't really all that wise since you have no need to make peace with your friends.
- DominikR 10y agoThose people living in the Eastern Ukraine for generations identify themselves as Russians so of course they fight against a government that hates everything Russian and threatens them. On the other side of the border many Russians feel sympathy for them and send them all kinds of support, even weapons and volunteers. It's very simple. The country is ethnically split and no side is going to allow the other to conduct an ethnic cleansing without a serious fight.
- wavefunction 10y ago>hates everything Russian and threatens them. I am not sure how Ukraine threatens Russia. Perhaps you can elucidate? I can't speak to the alleged hate though I might find it understandable, given that Russia is actively annexing parts of the country. >Russians feel sympathy[...] send them support, even weapons and volunteers I think you mean the Russian military is sending troops across the border as has been documented many times? Also, there's the issue of the BUK that shot down the Malaysian air-liner. Perhaps those victims might not cheer too loudly for that "sympathy?"
- woodandsteel 10y agoOne reason that people are suspicious of Russia is that Putin and his state-controlled media have made clear his goal is to restore Russia, to the extent possible, to its former superpower geopolitical status, and there is no way that can be accomplished without a very aggressive foreign policy. In addition, people in the West disapprove of Russia because of its highly oppressive human rights policies, including massive internet censorship, and also its fossil-fuels centered, crony-capitalism economics. I feel sorry for the people of Russia. It seems to me that Putin has put them on a path that can't possibly succeed.
- dijit 10y agoBritain is also enacting censorship of its internet. Although pushed by the government on ISPs and only for 'indecent content', who decides what's indecent? The government of course. I don't see Russia being different in this regard, we just don't understand them and we understand the British.
- thrownaway1984 10y agoThe UK's censorship is still nascent compared to Russia's. (The mechanisms are all in place but the actual censorship remains relatively weak.)
- guard-of-terra 10y agoRussian censorship of its internet is much more widespread. And it is an official law, not some kind of recommendations or special cases or limited measures. "We don't like your site, we block it for good" - that's the law.
- woodandsteel 10y agoMy view is that when it comes to internet censorship, and human rights in general, Britain has problems but on the whole is ten times better than Putin's Russia. dijit, what is you position on this?
- dijit 10y ago
- stplsd 10y agoSir, I honestly think you do not know what you are talking about. Disclaimer: I am from Lithuania, which was occupied by SSRS almost by 50 years, my grandmother was deported in Siberia for 10+ years and my mother was born there.
- dijit 10y agoThat's likely, Actually. My polish great-grandfather was likely too old to mention the numerous horrors of the Russians of today. Of course he never actually met them so that may be why.
- KKKKkkkk1 10y agoThis article is not about disagreeing with Russia or about NATO, it's about people working for Russian special services harassing a Finnish journalist.
- sickbeard 10y agoI think you missed the point of the article or maybe some context. There is a theory out there that Russia employs paid internet trolls to push Russian propaganda on message boards and discussion forums like Reddit.