3 ms·
> Addressed that here. Basically you said "I didn't mention female privilege because I didn't claim white privilege is the only one". No, you didn't, but you a
by smsm42 10y ago
> Addressed that here.
Basically you said "I didn't mention female privilege because I didn't claim white privilege is the only one". No, you didn't, but you also neglected to discuss most privileged category in your own example, which makes one to question your logic in this example.
You also say "women are less privileged in other domains" - true, one can find such domains. But we didn't look into other domains. We looked in specific example you provided, and you specifically discussed privilege, and yet by your own logic you failed to notice the most privileged group. Looks like you didn't really try to find one but tried to arrive at a predefined conclusion, did you?
> Yeah, duh
No, not duh. You can't first claim the mantle of the oppressed and when it is shown to you it is not yours say "duh". People are ridiculing SJWs in part because they use the pretense of being oppressed and sometimes case of real oppression (not done to them) to support their ridiculous and often harmful demands and actions.
> Projection much?
I would recommend looking up what "projection" means. There are groups on the right which do strike "holier than thou" attitude, but they usually have no idea what SJW means and are very far from the context of it. Those that you would see ridiculing the SJWs usually do not have anything like that attitude, they are more of the "leave me alone" kind.
> Striking an "attitude" or feeling better than someone is not even on the top ten of the list of motivations of anyone I know (myself included) who fights for people to be treated with respect.
Their behavior suggests otherwise, unfortunately. And I can't see how some things that are being done - like complete closure of campus thought to any dissent and independent thought, or hate campaigns like one happened to Tim Hunt - can be reasonably described as "fight for people to be treated with respect". If anything, the typical mode of behavior starts with refusing to even admit the possibility of respectful disagreement, and we can see example in this very topic of people being actually proud of it. That's what the W in the name goes for - W means war, and there's no place for respect in war. At least not the contemporary war, older wars were different a bit in that regard.
> It's our ball game, and it's our responsibility make sure that others are invited
It is. But organizing hate campaigns, and fake hate crimes, and imaginary insults, and more and more strict speech codes, and crying for authority to exclude everyone that tries to introduce at least the hint of an independent thought, and taking it all to a ridiculous levels - is not the way to do it. And there's way too much of it going on right now.