6 ms·
Hey, a post about RSS content quirks! It makes me feel young again! On a more serious note - RSS is the Great Web Leveller. It spites your fancy CSS hacks, it'
by toyg 10y ago
Hey, a post about RSS content quirks! It makes me feel young again!
On a more serious note - RSS is the Great Web Leveller. It spites your fancy CSS hacks, it's disgusted by your insane javascript, and it will piss all over your "mobile-optimized" crap. No semantic markup == no party; because markup is for robots, and RSS parsers are very stubborn robots that can see through web-hipster bullshit like Superman through walls.
The only real sin of RSS (beyond the holy wars and format bikeshedding and committee madness and and and...) is that it's too honest a format. It's a format for stuff that matters, for content that deserves to be read; it's too pure to survive in a world of content silos, stalking analytics and inaccessible material-designs. Its innocence doomed it in a very poetic way.
- usaphp 10y ago> "web-hipster bullshit" Why so much negativity lately regarding new trends in the web?
- bordercases 10y agoI can voice my perspective. Essentially: bike-shedding, bedazzlement, and bloat.
- gue5t 10y agoBecause continued development of the Web is an obvious, user-hostile money-grab. If you only care about getting your software to users, you have a million choices for your application runtime. If you want to monetize every user by selling their privacy or headspace, you have only one: i.e., "pirating" Facebook is a logical impossibility. Communicative efficacy on the Web has not improved since the early 1990s--Javascript and its ilk have virtually no positive effect on the usefulness of Wikipedia, for example. We're converting what was intended to be a transport for communication into a framework for writing portable software. The thesis here is that there should be a digital way to share hypertext articles and other statically-described communication without pay the costs (privacy, rendering efficiency, security bugs, transport performance and uncacheability, accessibility) associated with a cross-platform sandboxed multimedia software runtime.
- usaphp 10y agoWeren't computers built at first to do completely different from what we are currently using them for? I don't get the negativity about new ways people try to use things we have. If we were always following guidelines and rules, we would be stuck in the past
- Bromskloss 10y agoIt's not "being new" that is the criticised activity here.
- parennoob 10y agoSimilarly, if we were never negative about things that sucked from our perspective, we would be stuck in a world where Internet Explorer was the only browser and everyone was using "Windows 2016". Negative feedback (preferably with suggestions for improvement) is just as important as imaginative new ways of using the web.
- gue5t 10y agoI don't want to be rude, but I really don't understand your message. Computers have always been, and will always be, tools for automating away work. The specific nature of the work the user needs automated is in a constant state of flux. One particular kind of work that we've wanted computers to do for us since the 20th century is the sharing of written and visual information. Ostensibly, this is what the Web was written for, and though it wasn't perfect, it could have evolved into a simply, highly efficient tool for this purpose. Instead, it can be seen evolving into a sandboxed application runtime, a workload with vastly different properties. Good implementations of software for these two workloads would share little structure outside of that required for inevitable hardware access. Evolving the Web into an application runtime is possible, and well underway, but doing so still leaves the niche of software for an unfettered global commons of knowledge unfilled. By using the Web we're building for the latter purpose, we are met with drawbacks which include (as I mentioned): - lack of privacy - rendering efficiency - security bugs and malware - transport performance - uncacheability - accessibility We can attempt to address each of these piecemeal, and with sustained effort we're likely to make good progress on most of them, in due time. But a lot of these are really hard problems for an application runtime to solve. Conversely, these problems are a lot easier (where they exist at all) on a software platform designed from the ground up for hypertext-based, archivable communication, rather than as an application runtime.
- toyg 10y agoOne reason might be that, for anyone with historical perspective, a situation where our pipes can download hundreds of MB per second and still our browsers crawl like turtles is just shocking. Modern browsers are the most compatible ever and come with all sorts of bells and whistles baked in, and still people are using JS frameworks over JS frameworks over JS frameworks. Another reason might be that most of this website-fat is actively anti-users. It breaks the back button. It breaks bookmarks. It spies on you. It makes it impossible to interoperate/mash stuff, and it makes it incredibly hard to automate things (do you know that in the '90s you used to be able to download entire websites, so you could comfortably read them offline?). Another reason is probably that a lot of "mainstream web plumbers" (like yours truly) are now hitting late middle-age and feeling it hard. We used to be able to view-source and copypaste our way to image-rollover glory; we were breathing markup and feeds... now it's all tooling and frameworks and stacks, even http is going binary, and it feels like the loss of this innocence is not actually gaining anything for anyone except marketing people. Now get off my lawn.
- digi_owl 10y agoI guess its very telling that the terminology these days is not site, but app...
- Klathmon 10y agoI think it's telling that some people don't seem to grasp that the terminology is app because they are applications. The web is no longer just html, they are full-fledged applications running in the browser.
- myrion 10y agoYes, and most of them shouldn't be.
- enraged_camel 10y agoThat's not the problem. The problem is that the frameworks developers use to make their content interactive and manage state are overkill. It's like needing to display today's date on the page and downloading an entire date library to do it when you can just do "Date();"
- fucking_tragedy 10y agoI paid close to $2k for a computer with 16GB of memory and can only have the same amount of tabs open as I did in 2009 with 4GB of RAM. My computer still slows to a crawl when on certain pages. These are the literal costs (for me) to be able to use the web nowadays for minimal usability and functionality 'increases'. For reference, the multiprotocol instant messenger client Meebo was a successful competitor to Trillian in 2005. It was a web application that used less memory and was more responsive than a desktop application. I used it on a computer with 512mb of memory just fine. Also, browsing the web on my phone is unnecessarily difficult and battery consuming.
- protomyth 10y agook.... Because it seems more and more of the trends are designed to target me for advertising and analytics while making the user experience worse. I look at one website and uBlock says it blocked 12 domains the page tried to connect to and allowed 13 domains. What the heck? I go to audible.com and it flashes after 2 seconds and redraws the page. Never mind the banner at the top of the page that says to download the app. All the while, I still have a data cap of 10 gigabytes on my cell. Simple pages are downloading 2 megabyte frameworks, custom fonts, and autoplaying video, and groups of megabyte images. Whole programs in the 90's fit in the space of one of these images (and they said Smalltalk program were too big). We aren't all browsing at wifi spots at some coffee shop. We have to pay for this overpriced bandwidth. I actually hope it gets worse and worse. I'm looking forward to what comes next after it all collapses. Perhaps we will get a medium that matches the app vision people are programming to. // I did up vote you, no sense in down votes for a simple question
- yk 10y agoBecause most of the developments are a net loss for the user.^1 The most important benefit of an ad blocker is not that it blocks ads, the most important benefit is, that the web is a lot faster. I basically stopped surfing on my tablet, because after 2 seconds some ad network comes around to finally deliver an ad, and the entire site jumps around. I lose the place what I just read, and from time to time I actually click some ad by accident ( I wanted to scroll when the site suddenly jumped around, guess what if I want to play stupid reaction games I start Mario, not surf to the NYT.) and I have to click the back button and have a few seconds to curse all web designers while I wait for the same slow ad network to deliver the same ad. It is the same with analytics, JS to have 'nice' scrolling for galleries, and css. Analytics at best does not get into my way, when I notice it, then because it slows my experience to a crawl (another nice opportunity to reflect on the depravity of web designers). JS for galleries or blinking effects or 'improved' nagigation has the same characteristic, either I don't notice or it annoys me. (Nice thing about NoScript, it breaks nag walls by accident. So I get all the advantages of an ad blocker, without having to feel guilty for trying to break the revenue model of websites.) CSS, well the defaults of the browsers are pretty good, and in general browsers are very good at displaying easily readable text. So at best CSS looks slightly better than the original, however I just had to switch off Gnome dark mode because some sites only define the foreground of a text input field not the background, which ends as black text on a dark gray background. ^1 Don't get me wrong, I understand how that happens. I am currently working on my new blog and wanted an entirely static site, without JS. I almost managed to get there, but I do not have a good static replacement for MathJax, so now I am wondering if I should deliver MathJax myself ( and a site jumps from a few kB to more than a MB) or if I should use the hosting by MathJax, with all the downsides above.
- neves 10y agoInstall Firefox Mobile with uBlock in your tablet. I'll discover a whole new Web.
- vintermann 10y agoBecause even once respected outlets seem to be hiring people who have spent their entire childhoods on SA and 4chan, whose only real skill is gaining attention by negative social manipulation. Clickbait is more than sensationalized headlines these days. The entire media, regardless of place on the political spectrum - and much non-news media - seems to have embraced what was once the domain of talk radio hosts.
- lj3 10y ago> Its innocence doomed it in a very poetic way. And yet, virtually every single site on the internet has an RSS or ATOM feed. I think I've come across a whopping 5 that don't and those are mostly tech guys who made their own blog system and didn't bother with the rss feed because, as everybody knows, rss is dead.
- toyg 10y agoMost of those are auto-generated feeds by the usual-suspect CMSs. In most cases, nobody is actually looking at what those feeds look like, with terrible results. Outside the niche of news providers, nobody cares. Besides, does Facebook have RSS feeds? Does Twitter have RSS feeds? That's basically half the web right there, these days.
- lj3 10y ago> In most cases, nobody is actually looking at what those feeds look like, with terrible results. The results look fine to me. It's pretty rare to find one that's completely mangled. For the most part, even embedded videos work. The news providers are the bigger pain in the ass, since they like to truncate content and insert ads. > Besides, does Facebook have RSS feeds? Facebook doesn't, which isn't a huge loss. Nothing of consequence gets posted to Facebook, at least not for me. I could see where that would be a pain point for some people. > Does Twitter have RSS feeds? There are several services that provide twitter feeds. I use twitrss.me.
- gdwatson 10y agoTwitter used to have RSS feeds, and then they took them away as they made their content more siloed.
- daurnimator 10y ago> Besides, does Facebook have RSS feeds? Yes, for notifications: https://www.facebook.com/help/212445198787494/ https://www.facebook.com/help/212445198787494/ Other feeds used to be available too but I can't seem to get them to work. > Does Twitter have RSS feeds? It used to, but is disappeared as they were locking down their apis.
- gcr 10y agoI'm very sad how publishers can find inventive and creative ways to ruin even RSS. Medium, in particular, will only post "Continue reading on medium.com [link]" to its RSS feeds.
- dreamsofdragons 10y agoWe refuse to pay for content, and we refuse to view ads. I keep hearing "Then come up with a different business model, just look at X" where X is simply burning VC, and then we all complain when X goes away or X starts to show ads or charge. Models like Patreon don't scale. If you can figure out a way to monetize without ads or paywalls, I'd love to hear it.
- jkaunisv1 10y agoWhy do you think Patreon-esque models don't scale? I don't have info one way or the other but I'm curious why you're so strongly of the opinion that they don't.
- dreamsofdragons 10y agoWe did an assessment a while back, looking for options, and I can't share that. But this essentially sums it up. https://graphtreon.com/top-patreon-creators https://graphtreon.com/top-patreon-creators Sure, it's a good pay check for one, acceptable for two if you're in the top 10 or 20 patreons, but nobody is coming back to your site if you have 1 or 2 contributors. Now, put together a team to compete with current media, and it simply doesn't add up. This could change, but I was expecting bigger numbers by now. edit: I just want to clarify, we didn't go with a Patreon model. My expectation was that the amount donated for Patreons would be bigger by now.
- riffraff 10y agoit looks like the "quality" of patreons & what kind of "product" you produce matter. The last has 2 entries with similar number of patreons (Aaron Mahnke, podcast, with 1726 and Jessica Nigri, cosplayer, with 1634) and vastly different income (8k vs 23k).
- Etheryte 10y agoThe honesty of your comment made my morning.
- BillinghamJ 10y agoI really wish the web could be more like that. Too many websites these days consider themselves applications where really they're just showing simple documents which should conform to the user's viewing preferences.