3 ms·
An electric powerplant with effectively one moving part should also have dramatically lower mantenence cost than a traditional, gasoline-powered engine of more
by ams6110 10y ago
An electric powerplant with effectively one moving part should also have dramatically lower mantenence cost than a traditional, gasoline-powered engine of more than 1,000 components
I see this sort of statement made about electric cars also, and I think it's really not true. Modern internal combustion engines are very reliable, and need very little maintenance. Yes they need oil changes every so often, and I guess that's "dramatically" more in a divide-by-zero kind of way, but realistically it's not going to make a huge difference in the operational expense of a GA aircraft. Also not addressed in this piece, how long do the batteries last and what does it cost to replace them?
- coredog64 10y agoGA engines require a teardown inspection on a pretty regular basis. Not only that, but the liability tail for GA emphasizes the use of older designs.
- ams6110 10y agoPresumably electric motors would require the same, then, in an aviation application?
- djrogers 10y agoThe teardown and inspection of an electric motor is trivial compared to that of an internal combustion engine. Generally speaking, you'd undo a few fasteners, pop off a cover, and check/clean the rotor/windings. 15 minutes tops - heck, you could do it before every flight and it'd still be cheaper than paying for the 100-hour maintenance on a GA plane.
- sokoloff 10y agoAbsent a propeller strike, a teardown inspection is almost never indicated between overhauls. Yes, the airframe and engine get inspected annually, but the engine is not "torn down" during those inspections.
- sintaxi 10y agoConventional wisdom around owning a gas powered vehicle is to maintain it until either the engine or the transmission goes. The reason for this is not because engines and transmissions are unreliable its because they are insanely expensive to manufacture and repair which often exceeds the value of the vehicle in the first place. As far as I'm aware with an electric vehicle there is no transmission and the electric motor is basically a spinning coil without any significant point of friction so its orders of magnitude cheaper to manufacture and replacement would be something your average consumer could potentially do themselves. Batteries are definitely the bottleneck but its basically the only area further innovation is needed for the foreseeable future. Basically what this means is that with electric vehicles you can continually drive and repair them until the chassis is no longer serviceable OR more likely your EULA runs out and you are forced to upgrade for licensing (software) reasons because there will be significant services revolving around these vehicles (autonomous driving, parking, recharging, repairs). edit: word