3 ms·
What the article is pointing out is the problem caused by the fact that we never repeal anything. Some problem happens, some regulation is put in place to deal
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
What the article is pointing out is the problem caused by the fact that we never repeal anything. Some problem happens, some regulation is put in place to deal with it and now that regulation is permanent. Next year some other problem happens and some regulation is put in place to deal with it. Each seems reasonable on its own but after a hundred years when you put them all together it turns a $5 million project into a $5 billion project.
But it doesn't really address why we never repeal anything, and it's in large part because we keep doing too much at too high a level of government. A thousand years ago a population the size of New York City would have been a nation, but now it's a city inside of a county inside of a state inside of a union. And the union is inside of a set of international treaties.
It's too many layers of bureaucracy. People keep advocating laws at the highest level where they can get them passed, which both makes them harder to fix because they're further removed from the affected people and more likely to cause trouble because any flaws are amplified by the larger affected population.
The flaw seems to be that people think federal legislation is less complex than local legislation, under the theory that uniformity reduces complexity. But in practice what happens is that you end up with 10,000 pages of federal regulations instead of each city having their own 20 pages, and then not being able to fix anything because San Francisco and Houston can't agree which rule one should impose on the other when the sensible choice is to let each do what they want.
- ricree 10y agoYour way has its own set of pitfalls, and I'm not sure that they're less than the alternative. If you do business in New York, Chicago, and Boston, then you have to worry about laws in all three places. The more you lean upon local lawmaking, then the more you risk adding a big layer of legal incompatibility once you start crossing borders.
- kristopolous 10y agoMaybe becoming a giant onerous company should have such barriers...
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> If you do business in New York, Chicago, and Boston, then you have to worry about laws in all three places. Which, first of all, you already do, the county/state/federal laws apply on top of those. But you're also assuming that uniform national laws will be less complicated than dealing with different local laws, which doesn't seem to bear out in practice. California is going to care about earthquakes and Massachusetts is going to care about ice storms but not really the other way. If you do business in both California and Massachusetts then you have to care about both earthquakes and ice storms regardless, and if the relevant legislation is at the federal level then it will cover both. Which means local laws aren't more complicated for companies who do business in both places, they're less complicated for companies who don't, because then if you only do business in Massachusetts you don't have to deal with earthquake regulations.
- sharemywin 10y agoBut does insurance, banking(mortgage, payday loans), transportation laws really need 50 different laws? even contract law could be ubiquitous and where lawyers can practice in all fifty states.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> But does insurance, banking(mortgage, payday loans), transportation laws really need 50 different laws? Sure they do. You're insuring against earthquakes in California and ice storms in Massachusetts. North Dakota has a much different banking environment than New York City. Trucks pulling three trailers make sense in big empty western states with wide open spaces but no sense in high traffic urban environments with tight corners.
- umanwizard 10y agoNitpick, but NYC is not inside of a county: five counties are inside of it. Doesn't change your point, though.
- shireboy 10y agoI think this is it, mostly. But there is another reason we don't appeal anything: because the narrative that sells ads in the media and votes for a large sector both left and right is that if you oppose funding X, you hate/are anti-/are -ist. Want to radically redo Medicaid? You must hate old people! Welfare? Racist. Military spending? Terrorist. The hyperbolic media sells ads, so reasoned debate and data-driven politics are the exception rather than the rule.
- MichaelBurge 10y agoI wouldn't mind if legislation automatically sunset after a maximum of 50 years. I don't know if Congress should renew the laws directly, or if it should be delegated to a separate "old laws maintenance committee". Making Congress renew them might bog them down, or might encourage them to repeal as much as they can. A lot of problems could be solved all at once by restricting the interstate commerce clause to only commerce that directly occurs between states. That and the fallout from Roosevelt's "court-packing plan" mean that the federal government is currently far too powerful. These last two wouldn't really solve the problem you mention directly, but it would limit the impact of any particular legislation to just the states demanding it, and reduces the number of representatives needed to change it in the future.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> I wouldn't mind if legislation automatically sunset after a maximum of 50 years. You would end up having The Omnibus Reauthorization Act of [This Year] every year because many of the old laws are sensible or necessary but nobody actually wants to comb through them all and separate the wheat from the chaff. What might be interesting is to set the bar for passing laws higher than the bar for repealing them, the higher you go in government. So cities and counties would keep a simple majority while state governments would need 55% of the legislature to pass a law but only 45% to repeal it and at the federal level it might be 65% and 35%. That wouldn't solve the entire problem but it would help. A lot.
- MichaelBurge 10y agoThat's a really good suggestion, because a politician with his "war paint" on with some specific issue in mind is tactically incentivized to target the smallest region that solves his problem. And hopefully the issue runs out of steam after that. Or, pass a constitutional amendment capping the allowed size of the US Code at 150 megabytes(and allow Congress to cap the aggregate size of all individual federal agencies' implementations of that law at, say, 10 terabytes): So if you want to add a kilobyte, you have to remove another kilobyte somewhere else.
- gruez 10y ago
- panarky 10y agoI see the same disease in many large organizations -- governments, corporations, NGOs. Incredible resources and time routinely wasted. Maybe the assumptions underlying the Theory of the Firm [1] are changing, making internal transaction costs approach or even exceed external transaction costs. If so, we should see large organizations disband into smaller, more efficient, more accountable components. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_the_firm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_the_firm