3 ms·
Right theory, wrong cause. Our whole society has moved towards a philosophy that children are not allowed to fail. As a result we give people easy "successes"
by btilly 17y ago
Right theory, wrong cause.
Our whole society has moved towards a philosophy that children are not allowed to fail. As a result we give people easy "successes" at every opportunity, and don't let people experience the fact that they can fail. The result is people whose self-image is like a balloon - really puffed up but likely to deflate suddenly on facing a real challenge.
Obviously the opposite extreme of beating kids down is not good either. But we need a balance. And we need to drive the message home that some things take work.
- tel 17y ago— or pop? Depressing as it is, I wouldn't be surprised if suicide rates climb. Durkheim would probably think so. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89mile_Durkheim http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89mile_Durkheim
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 17y agoThe worst part, in my mind, is that we are taking away one of the cues that the world used to give you in deciding you should try something else. Failure allows a person to find their true talent.
- pvg 17y agoRight theory, wrong cause. Which theory and cause? That the world is ruined and the cause is the Karate Kid? You might have taken it a bit too literally. Our whole society has [...] Our whole society probably hasn't. Is your argument seriously "kids these days"? Because I don't think the author is really attempting to engage in a meaningful debate on whether the Rocky montage is or is not the driving factor in our poor ability to estimate effort required. It's just a bit of hyperbole.
- xiaoma 17y ago>Is your argument seriously "kids these days"?* Maybe btilly's argument is parents these days. It isn't like kids wanted to fail in the past. The difference is that until recently, most kids on the football team didn't win any ribbons or prizes in the past, but now even the chubbiest, least co-ordinated loser is a winner who comes home with a 3rd most improved defensive player ribbon. Similarly, there was a time when an average student got a C. Now, a lackluster effort is often worth a B+. It makes perfect sense that people will have a distorted view of how difficult success is if they are never allowed to fail, never exposed to "dangerous" playground equipment of their grandparents' day, and who are always allowed to beg an excuse to get extensions or extra test-taking time.