3 ms·
Why would it be unconstitutional for the government to give money to the poor? There have been thousands of bills created at all local, state, and national lev
by CydeWeys 10y ago
Why would it be unconstitutional for the government to give money to the poor? There have been thousands of bills created at all local, state, and national levels to create these programs. Is your argument that a constitutional amendment is needed for some reason? Government support for the poor is not a new concept, and certainly doesn't originate within the past century. It has been around since before the founding of the United States: http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2015/05/poverty-and-welfare-in-the-american-founding http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2015/05/poverty-and...
- MichaelBurge 10y agoNot "the government", but specifically the federal government of the United States. The federal government here has a specific list of enumerated rights, and anything not listed is given to the states, which split it between themselves, the local governments, and the people. Taxing needs to be explicitly mentioned in the constitution, and income taxes even needed their own amendment. It just seems like the EITC isn't actually a tax, and that the best they could do is offer an optional program that individual states could opt-in to.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- yequalsx 10y agoThe U.S. Constitution consists of lots of statements that grant the federal government powers. These statements have logical implications. Logically valid implications of the enumerated powers ought to be constitutional, right? It would be absurd to say the Department of the Air Force is unconstitutional even though there is no explicit mention of the federal government being granted the power to have said department. Should there be 50 different states with their own departments of the Air Force?