19 ms·
You know, I'm wondering: could part of Dijkstra's reputed arrogance be due to a cultural difference? I'm Dutch, and bluntly calling out flaws in each other's wo
by vanderZwan 10y ago
You know, I'm wondering: could part of Dijkstra's reputed arrogance be due to a cultural difference? I'm Dutch, and bluntly calling out flaws in each other's work is not considered all that rude over here; it's almost the opposite: not calling someone out on their flaws implies we either consider them a lost cause or not worth the hassle of educating.
I almost got fired from a teaching position in Sweden because I told my 3rd year bachelor students that many did not bother to add their names or the assignment number, or using paragraphs and in some cases even basic interpunction on their assignments. And that this was well below the level required to to pass secondary school, and that I expect better from them.
This was apparently too confrontational, and a few upset students later I got chewed out and almost fired. Meanwhile, from my point of view, I was just doing my job and already sugarcoating it by Dutch standards.
Having said that, yes, even by Dutch standards I would say that Dijkstra liked to troll people a bit.
PS: I really like the following insight from Dijkstra's review: But whereas machines must be able to execute programs (without understanding them), people must be able to understand them (without executing them).
- Qantourisc 10y agoBelgium here: it's a bit the same. However HOW you say it matters to. First times you are expected to say it "without" emotion, like not being angry. Consequential times incrementally go nuts :D
- bmer 10y agoFull disclosure: a) Dijkstra is a bit of a personal "hero" of mine (hero in quotation marks, because I don't like to think of myself as a hero worshipper), because it was due to him I learned of textbooks written by guys like Eric Hehner and Roland Backhouse, which ended up changing my life significantly. b) I do not really grasp the technical issues being discussed in the correspondences between Dijkstra and Backus Given this disclosure: Regardless of the cultural issues (which I suspect you are right about), I found Backus' first response to Dijkstra full of ad hominems, and very light on technical rebuttals. If we subtract out the ad hominems, I suspect the technical rebuttals would take less than a page (which is a significant reduction, considering that the full letter is 4 (typewritten!) pages). Calling Dijkstra arrogant seems to have been a popular insult (as Backus himself admits), so I wonder if Backus was simply jumping onto the bandwagon as a defensive reaction to the arguments presented in EWD 692. I think Dijkstra's responses were indeed trollish. I wish he wouldn't have said anything further after he noticed the gratuitous personal attacks against his character in Backus' response, but he couldn't help but say something back. Oh well. Can you comment on this observation?
- Bromskloss 10y ago> textbooks written by guys like Eric Hehner and Roland Backhouse Would you like to say something about those?
- bmer 10y agoE. Hehner has a course called "Formal Methods for Software Design", which he presents completely openly online (including video lectures, a textbook, solutions, and so on): http://www.cs.toronto.edu/~hehner/FMSD/ http://www.cs.toronto.edu/~hehner/FMSD/ I really liked it. I also liked R. Backhouse's approach to it, encapsulated in two books: 1) less playful: http://www.amazon.com/Program-Construction-Calculating-Implementations-Specifications/dp/0470848820 http://www.amazon.com/Program-Construction-Calculating-Imple... 2) more playful: http://www.amazon.com/Algorithmic-Problem-Solving-Roland-Backhouse/dp/0470684534 http://www.amazon.com/Algorithmic-Problem-Solving-Roland-Bac... If you are looking for motivation, you might also like: http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/lamport/pubs/proof.pdf http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/lamport/pubs/p... ----------------- I found Dijkstra's stuff to be easier to read after I had read books by Hehner/Backhouse, even though chronologically, Dijkstra came first.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoHehner's work is on my reading list. The reviews on Backhouse's links aren't promising.
- bmer 10y agoI have learned not to put much weight in Amazon reviews for technical literature. Borrow a copy of the books from a library (my city library actually had access to a digital version of Backhouse's latest book, and you could always Yarr! yourself a copy) and check them out, before shelling out the cash :)
- nickpsecurity 10y ago
- eternalban 10y ago> I'm Dutch, and bluntly calling out flaws in each other's work is not considered all that rude over here; quote: “Object-oriented programming is an exceptionally bad idea which could only have originated in California.” – Edsger Dijkstra Backus, on the other hand, is a genuinely lovely man. If you haven't read/seen his interview with CHM [1], then I urge you to do so. (Pay attention to his closing remarks!) [1]: http://www.computerhistory.org/fellowawards/hall/bios/John,Backus/ http://www.computerhistory.org/fellowawards/hall/bios/John,B...
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y ago> Object-oriented programming is an exceptionally bad idea 'Truths as hard as fists', is one way I've seen it put in another language (sortof). > which could only have originated in California Flattery will get you anywhere. UTexas, in this case ...
- bloaf 10y ago>Reason is always a kind of brute force; those who appeal to the head rather than the heart, however pallid and polite, are necessarily men of violence. We speak of ‘touching’ a man’s heart, but we can do nothing to his head but hit it. G. K. Chesterton
- Retra 10y agoWhile I would agree with that in principle, I think the word "violence" is being stretched a bit. Being unforgiving, stubborn, demanding, hard-hearted, or anything adherence to logic might be claimed to imbue are not acts of violence, even if they are emotionally hurtful to others.
- Jtsummers 10y agoEmotional harm is still violence. it is not a strictly physical phenomenon.
- 10y ago
- internaut 10y agoI've always liked the Dutch for this reason. If it isn't possible to work with somebody while disagreeing with them, then you're the problem. If you spend long enough talking to anybody you'll eventually come across disagreements. Many people take disagreements too personally. I was just yesterday talking to a paramedic. I mentioned to him the article I saw on HN about medical error being the 3rd highest cause of death next to cancer and heart disease. He immediately started to attack me, exclaiming how I was not an authority in this area so how would I know what I was talking about and therefore had no right to talk about something like this. I explained I was not the source of the information, and that large numbers of people inside and outside the medical profession are concerned that a great deal of medical research isn't reproducible and in any case if car accidents don't even touch the number of medical fatalities occurring then it's a problem since car accidents are so problematical it's one of the leading reasons we're trying to automate them. He blew his top. Ad homs everywhere. Later I took to the Net to see if I was correct in my impression. Turns out my 'Master of Paramedics who read lots of journals' can't have been paying much attention because the British Medical Journal and Lancet are in lockstep with everything I had been saying. In fact I was probably far too kind judging from what the leading lights of the medical profession are saying themselves. I expect he would accuse me of being arrogant. I've said it before but tribalism is very powerful. It is far more dangerous to Science than Religion and it definitely gets in the way of technological change.
- sukilot 10y agoI don't know what your friend said, but the "errors are #3 killer" is a twisted fact. It comes from assigning "error" at the cause of death of every injury or illness that might have been non-fatal if every perfect test, advance in practice, technology, and mode of care were applied. It isn't a measure of how many otherwise healthy people were killed by errors that introduced new complications. One of highlighted examples from an abstract of a major study was an "error" where a doctor didn't tell a kid with diagnosed heart disease that strenuous exercise would be dangerous, and the kid died after collapsing during a run.
- internaut 10y ago
- jamesblonde 10y agoI'm a lecturer in Sweden, and i know how you feel :) To quote some students on a list "What's this nonsense with independent thinking? Nobody ever told us we had to do that."
- vanderZwan 10y agoOuch. As if it's a chore instead of a privilege to get to do so! Well, luckily my story had a happy ending: my colleagues (who were checking the assignments with me) stood up for me, and after the course other students defended me by saying "finally, a teacher willing to call out the freeloaders! It's so demotivating to see them get away with not doing anything while I put in so much effort and get nothing in response." The reason my former boss had reacted like an overprotective mother was because the complaining students had made me look like someone who motivated through bullying, intimidation and fear. He takes his responsibilities of creating a safe space for students to learn and overcome their insecurities very seriously, and I respect that. Meanwhile, I have high expectations of my students precisely because I believe they are capable of so much more than they give themselves credit for, and he now understands and respects that, and has given me some pointers in how to get that across in ways that Swedes aren't allergic to. So we resolved our issues too. But yeah, that was a pretty strong culture clash; in the end it was educational for everyone involved I think.
- shiggerino 10y agoI can concur. The Swedes have turned into an absolute disgrace. Constant late-coming, talking and other distracting behaviour. They have become a nation of low moral fibre, pure and simple. I say become, because I refuse to believe this was the modus operandi of the likes of Linnaeus, Arrhenius, Berzelius, Celsius, etc. I'm going through the motions myself, at an institution that shall remain nameless, knowing how kindly they take to criticism here.
- ktRolster 10y agoYou know, I'm wondering: could part of Dijkstra's reputed arrogance be due to a cultural difference? Dijkstra got a lot of attention from his essay, "Goto Considered Harmful." Even though he did not come up with that title, he learned from it that a hyperbolic saying can grab attention, and be used for good. So thereafter, he spent a while when he would say things in the most flame-bait way possible, to gain attention, because it worked.
- tluyben2 10y agoI am Dutch, my father studied under Dijkstra (TUE) and I studied under some of Dijkstra's prodigies. The humor Dijkstra uses is very Dutch to me and to me it's hilarious. His hard stabs were considered good practice in a lot of professional Dutch high end careers in the 70s/80s/90s but I believe it became less common. We have less issues telling like it is even if it hurts people in general, but when I still worked in NL this was definitely dying out. That said; I admire Dijkstra for having such strong opinions and striving to create solid software no matter what. He was used to write software for machines that didn't exist yet[1] and I for one wish I had the time/budget to write software proofs. Especially with the modern tools (not the ones I learnt using from Dijkstra's works, but that was a good theoretical foundation which gave me understanding) we have now it's very possible but only for very expensive systems with very generous deadlines. I could say we will not deliver without that but I would be living under a bridge... [1] https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD13xx/EWD1303.html https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD13xx/E...
- agumonkey 10y agoCulture shock / Calibration. Similar to Russian approach on social politeness. Or the lack there of. They don't smile unless they have a real reason to be happy. For westerners they appears cold hearted. Autistic persons are a bit like that too. They have a very simple optimization scheme, so pointing at suboptimal things directly is seen as a gift when most people will have a broad view on being told, shame, disrespect etc etc.
- tangled_zans 10y ago> I'm Dutch, and bluntly calling out flaws in each other's work is not considered all that rude over here; it's almost the opposite: not calling someone out on their flaws implies we either consider them a lost cause or not worth the hassle of educating. Woah, I do that too! Maybe I should move to Netherlands.
- Ma8ee 10y agoMany, far from all, Swedish students are way to pampered with. I was call Gestapo because I pointed out that it isn't acceptable behavior to be 40 minutes late to the lab session and not having read the instructions beforehand. But it is definitely also a cultural thing. The contrast became very obvious when we had Russians in the seminars. The Swede says things like "I don't think I really understand how you mean, could you maybe elaborate that point a little bit further". The Russians: "You are wrong and it's very obvious to even a high school student what your mistake is. And besides, all this has already been done in the Soviet Union 40 years ago."
- cafard 10y agoI have heard of the cultural difference you refer to--my son worked in the Netherlands for some months. Yet I don't think that is all of it. Is it simple frankness to say that the use of Fortran damages the brain? I do think that a good deal of the internet--the great unwashed both correspondents refer to--remember Dijkstra the insult comic better than Dijkstra the pioneer of computing. It doesn't improve discourse on the internet, I guess, or worsen it much either. I don't think it just to Dijkstra's reputation, though that is no responsibility of mine. In his biography of Alexander the Great, Peter Green quotes the Athenian Demades's reproach to Philip:"King Philip," he said, "Fortune has cast you as Agamemnon; but you seem determined to act the part of Thersites."