6 ms·
German WW2 code machine found on eBay
- mevile 10y agoI get that Museums aren't well funded but I feel like ten quid isn't enough value being returned to the owner. That owner didn't know what they had and was taken advantage of, even if it was for a good cause. I hope their name becomes part of the story of the device at least.
- aw3c2 10y agoYeah, I thought it sounded very ungrateful when reading: "We said 'Thank you very much, how much was it again?' She said '£9.50', so we said 'Here's a £10 note - keep the change!'"
- biot 10y agoIt's like using open source as the foundation of a billion dollar business. "Thank you very much, how much was that fantastically useful library again?" "Free." "Have a nice day."
- mckoss 10y agoThat got to me too with the museum representatives smugly ripping off the owner and telling her to "keep the change".
- london888 10y agoYes the museum could have handled it better so that the owner wasn't made to look stupid.
- pkaye 10y agoLike many collectables, the value will come with how complete and original it is and how functional. Things which are missing parts or modified can lose substantial value.
- ams6110 10y agoYes -- this also looks like it was just the teleprinter part, not the actual encrypting mechanism.
- 13of40 10y agoIt would be awesome if she read the article, then dug around and found the motor...
- lostlogin 10y agoShe's the obvious person to ask about it so I assume they did. How you ask without revealing that you know what's being sold is valuable is beyond me.
- jacquesm 10y agoIf she did I suspect the motor would suddenly become a bit more expensive.
- petecox 10y agoSuckers! :) Who would pay 10 pounds for a 75 year old piece of junk that didn't even work? I mean if you're going to be all steampunk, at least interface with a USB-C connector and use the machine to live tweet the announcement.
- molmalo 10y agoWell, if she did, I think she should take legal counsel...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI understand your emotion but consider it from the owner's point of view. It was junk taking up space, now they have 10 quid and more space. They are quite happy. Sure that junk "might" have been valuable but if you go down that road you end up a hoarder thinking someday velvet paintings of elvis are going to be really really valuable. She could have taken it to the local Antique store and had it evaluated, or asked the museum about it, but instead did what many do, throw it up on Ebay and see if anyone wants it. She's happy, the museum is happy, that really is all that counts here.
- aw3c2 10y agoIf I was the owner and would now see my L20 junk written about as valuable artifacts in the news, I would be pissed and angry. Solely because the buyers did not educate me but used my ignorance for their advantage. Maybe she would have simply donated the item, I sure would have. The issue is not money, it is being exploited.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wwwdonohue 10y agoYou really think they're going to be happy seeing the museum folks bragging about getting it for so cheap in the BBC?
- MrJagil 10y agoI think the problem is the phrasing. "Keep the change" sounds like they exploited her ignorance and ran off with a bargain. It's just not how most people want things to be. Despite the logic of the situation, it doesn't feel right. Attributions are free. Further, though, there are some practical considerations. If they'd shown her appreciation, future dialogue about how it got there, clues to the motor etc should be easier to develop- they obviously asked, but no reason to potentially burn any bridges.
- ChuckMcM 10y ago
- HeyLaughingBoy 10y agoI've never quite understood this. I bought a music box at a garage sale for bout $10. It seemed like a good deal at the time. A few months later I noticed a label on the bottom so I did some research and discovered that the same item was selling for around $1,000 on eBay. Should I now go track the owner down and tell her that she should have asked for more money? Counter that with the time I found a Coach trinket at another garage sale for $1.50 and I pointed out to the homeowner that an old gf had bought the same thing from the Coach store for $35. Her answer was "well, I guess you're getting a good deal then." In the end, once the seller and buyer agrees on a price, it's hard for me to see how that's screwing someone over.
- tormeh 10y ago>I bought a music box at a garage sale for bout $10. It seemed like a good deal at the time. A few months later I noticed a label on the bottom so I did some research and discovered that the same item was selling for around $1,000 on eBay. Should I now go track the owner down and tell her that she should have asked for more money? You didn't know. It was a trade among equals. This was different. That said, there are some situations where it's considered OK to rip people off. Finance works like that. But I would've thought that museums had slightly higher standards of conduct than Goldman Sachs...
- mynewtb 10y agoNo, your transactions were as you did not secretly use rare knowledge to your advantage.
- molmalo 10y agoThere seems to be something strange with that transaction. I don't know there, but where I live, that kind of transaction would clearly be invalidated if taken to court. At least here, for a transaction to be valid, both parties must be in the same kind of conditions, regarding to the knowledge of the thing (if one does not know what the object is, they should explain the other, not just take advantage of the situation). This was clearly not the case. "It may also be sued annulment or amendment of legal acts when one party exploiting the need, lightness or inexperience of the other, obtained through them an obviously disproportionate and unjustified financial advantage." Spending just a few seconds in google, it seems that it is the same in other countries: "When anyone, exploiting the sum ignorance, notorious inexperience or extreme misery of another, obtains an excessive profit that is clearly disproportionate to what he in turn agrees, the injured party is entitled to seek rescission of the contract, and if it impossible equitable reduction obligation." But of course, it all depends of the law of the place. If that that's OK in Essex, well... too bad for the one selling this object. And good for the museum taking advantage of that opportunity (even if it may sound a little bit unfair). At least this machine will be in good hands. In any case, it'd be nice if they stop bragging about that. ----- Edit: And according to wikipedia[1]: In English Law, "unilateral mistake is where only one party to a contract is mistaken as to the terms or subject-matter. The courts will uphold such a contract unless it was determined that the non-mistaken party was aware of the mistake and tried to take advantage of the mistake" IANAL, but in this case, I think there was obviously one party that didn't know what the object was, and another that did know and was taking advantage of the situation ("It was advertised as a telegram machine ", "keep the change" and all that). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mistakes_in_English_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mistakes_in_English_law
- merb 10y agoThat law won't apply to a auction
- molmalo 10y agoWhy not? Because he saw the article on Ebay? I don't know if this changes things, but they paid in person, they had every chance to inform the other party if it seemed so strange for them. And the fact remains, there was a party who didn't know, and another that knew and took advantage. For example, if she knew, she could have started the auction at a much higher price...
- smoyer 10y agoThe description of the "missing motor" sounds more like the motor-transmission assembly. Since the identification plate on the motor looks standard, if they find an identical part number, it may be for the motor only. Is there any chance of getting clear pictures or the motor-transmission from numerous angles (and including all identifying marks)?
- Animats 10y agoThat's a special motor and drive train for the cyphering unit. Here's one with the motor.[1] The cypher unit has two selectors - the two curved mechanisms on the top front. Those are mechanical UARTs, serial to parallel converters, and they're the same design used in Teletype machines from 1924 to 1959. Those need power from a driveshaft. The same motor drives both, which is why there's a special motor with a shaft out each end and two right-angle reduction drive gearsets. That's not a standard teleprinter part. The wheel with the black and white bars is a centrifugal governor. The speed is adjustable, and you use a special tuning fork with a shutter to calibrate the speed. This is a standard Teletype motor feature for when you can't rely on AC power line frequency. It's still not clear if this find included the crypto unit, or just the teleprinter. If they actually found a crypto unit, this is a big deal. Those were very rare. [1] http://cryptomuseum.com/crypto/lorenz/sz40/img/301491/000/full.jpg http://cryptomuseum.com/crypto/lorenz/sz40/img/301491/000/fu...
- userbinator 10y agoBut one key part is still missing and volunteers are still searching for it. "It looks like an electric motor in black casing with two shafts on each side, which drive the gears of the Lorenz machine," explains volunteer John Wetter. Volunteers hope the public will look out for it and if all else fails are hoping someone might want to build them a new one until they find it. If it's just a dual-shaft motor with nothing else special about it, fortunately those are widely available: http://www.surpluscenter.com/New-Arrivals/1600-RPM-115-VAC-DUAL-SHAFT-FAN-MOTOR-1-40-HP-10-2838.axd http://www.surpluscenter.com/New-Arrivals/1600-RPM-115-VAC-D...
- Marazan 10y agoI think they are looking for original parts.
- chiph 10y agoNote the 5 transfer bars to the right of the printing mechanism. It almost certainly used the European variant of the Baudot code.
- n72 10y ago"We said 'Thank you very much, how much was it again?' She said '£9.50', so we said 'Here's a £10 note - keep the change!'" Kind of a dick move.
- anf 10y agoBut how does it work?
- bboreham 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorenz_cipher https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorenz_cipher
- egberts5 10y agoI am wondering if the removal of the motor is some form of temporary disabling of the unit in question.
- Animats 10y agoIf all they found was the teleprinter, and not the crypto machine, this isn't a big deal. That is just the Lorenz version of the Teletype Model 14 tape printer, built under license. These are not that rare. I have three of the Teletype Corp version. (One is in operation right now at the Clockwork Alchemy Steampunk Convention in San Jose. Visit the Telegraph Office there today.) The crypto machine part is separate; it's a big electric-powered rotor machine, like an Enigma with more rotors. This tape printer may be special because the serial numbers match a historic crypto machine, which museum types care about. Here's my overhaul of the Teletype Corp. version.[1] Here's a Lorenz version someone else has.[2] Here's Bletchley Park's set, with the crypto unit and the teleprinter.[3] After I got my first Model 14, I had the paper tape they need made by a company in China. The minimum order was 500 rolls, so I sometimes sell paper tape to museums. (I tried US manufacturers first. Either they didn't want a small order, wanted a very high price, or the edge quality of the paper was so bad the tape would jam.) [1] http://www.aetherltd.com/refurbishing14.html http://www.aetherltd.com/refurbishing14.html [2] http://www.teleprinter.net/english/inhalt/t2.shtml http://www.teleprinter.net/english/inhalt/t2.shtml [3] http://cryptomuseum.com/crypto/lorenz/sz40/img/301491/000/full.jpg http://cryptomuseum.com/crypto/lorenz/sz40/img/301491/000/fu...
- Animats 10y agoFrom [1]: “We saw the swastika and then we noticed one of the keys was devoted to the double lightning bolt symbol of the SS.” Now that's a Baudot/ITA2 character set variation I haven't seen. There's already USTTY, ITA2, weather symbols, fractions (⅛, ¼, ⅜, etc., for stocks), versions with £ instead of #, and versions with a pilcrow. (¶). But I've never heard of a double lightning bolt symbol. Unicode has a single lightning bolt (Stack Overflow cannot handle this) up in the astral planes with the new emoji. But no double lightning bolt. I suppose a request for that now has to go into the Unicode consortium. [1] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/05/29/hitlers-top-secret-coded-messaging-machine-snapped-up-for-950-af/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/05/29/hitlers-top-secre...
- bct 10y agoIt's not a lightning bolt, it's the rune ᛋ.
- ck2 10y agoIf someone is holding a bar of gold but thinking it is just foil wrapped chocolate and offers to sell it to you for $10 but you know it is real gold and say "okay here's $10" is that honest and moral?