5 ms·
A household robot that could - do the washing and ironing - cook meals - clean and tidy the house - take parcel deliveries - watch the house for intruders
by cm2187 10y ago
A household robot that could
- do the washing and ironing
- cook meals
- clean and tidy the house
- take parcel deliveries
- watch the house for intruders
- feed and walk the dog (and tell him off if he does something bad)
- change bulbs, repaint some walls while you are on holidays
Would be like a new revolution similar to washing machines or dish washers, freeing up lots of people (mostly women) time and for instance giving them a better chance to focus on their career. People would be queueing to buy one.
Less sexy but a much bigger market than another Terminator in my opinion.
- nly 10y agoThe problems you list (if they even are problems) are nothing to do with robotics. They're AI problems. And that's AI in the sci-fi novel sense, not the oh so hip "let's build a cluster of 10000 GPUs running a convolution network to recognise cat pictures" sense.
- cm2187 10y agoBut most of robotics is about AI. The electric and hydraulic aspects are old technologies.
- programmer_dude 10y agoI think the battery problem still remains unsolved, other than that yes it's old technology.
- cm2187 10y agoI am not sure batteries would be a problem for a household robot. There are power sockets everywhere. And the robot can take a break from most tasks to charge itself (and like a dog it would spend most of the day sleeping anyway!).
- usrusr 10y agoAn advanced household robot would not even have to take charging breaks because it would be well up to the task of plugging itself in wherever it would work (except for the dog walking part, obviously) In a similar line of thinking, I am actually kind of surprised that there are no wired quadrocopter swarms yet, that would form a bucket line of short cables to trade range for the power and infinite endurance of a grid connection. I am quite sure that there must be applications where this deal would be worthwhile.
- cm2187 10y agoIf you need to connect them with a wire, you might as well sustain them in the air with a long stick and spare the energy.
- usrusr 10y agoMight still be cheaper (storage, transport, setup, investment) than a crane or scaffolding when you don't need to support heavy loads. And scaling would only be limited by how much power you can push through the chain, whereas sticks need to be quite massive just to support themselves once you go beyond a few meters of length.
- _up 10y agoThe idea of Thethered UAVs isn't new. Problem is probably the danger of high voltage tethers that they use.
- usrusr 10y agoThanks, those were the trigger words to conjure up an interesting Google results page.
- Buttons840 10y agoWhy do they need a high voltage tether? They don't need a high voltage battery.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kowdermeister 10y agoTrue, but you also need the interface for AI, which was BD developing. Human facing AI has a serious limitation if it lives 100% in the box.
- lkozma 10y agoI'm genuinely curious: why would someone want to have a dog and have someone else (in your scenario, a robot) interact with it.
- cm2187 10y agoBecause the dog needs to be walked several times a day, whether you need to work late / go on holiday in a non pet friendly place / go out that night / wake up late, or not.
- Chris2048 10y agoIs it cheaper to buy a robot, than just hire a dog walker?
- cmdrfred 10y agoI love my dog, but I work and It would be nice to have someone come to my house in the middle of the day to interact with her. Take her for a walk and make sure she didn't accidentally flip over her water bowl, etc. It would be peace of mind for me and entertainment for her.
- kowdermeister 10y agoThere are lots of situations when you have to leave your home and you can't take your dog with you or it would be very difficult to handle.
- trentlott 10y agoOur society is at a point where it can debate having robot butlers for our cats. What a wasteful time to be alive.
- cornchips 10y agoAdd: - Get hacked - Kill under order
- cm2187 10y agoI am actually surprised that we haven't seen assassinations by drones yet (I mean non USAF drones). Consumer drones can't carry a big payload, but I'd guess they can carry enough explosive to kill someone. And even someone super protected like a US president would be helpless facing 5 drones travelling at 50km/h coming his way. I guess most terrorists are dumb and all recent attacks in the west have shown to be low tech, but I'd rather not count on that to protect us. But in the US it's fine, since the drones have to carry a license number. That will protect us!
- cornchips 10y ago"drones don't kill people, people kill people" - AUVSI, in the future
- cm2187 10y agoI am not arguing that drones should be banned. But I'm just surprised it hasn't happened already.
- Leon 10y agoI think you are right; and what you're saying reminds me of a story from Malcolm Gladwell about the 1981 Traveller Trillion Credit Squadron tournament [1] that Doug Lenat won. He used some type of genetic algorithm (he never released his source) to find that swarming the challenger with many small boats would dominate as a tactic. Miniature swarms, which drones are cheap enough and more than capable for, are not a tactic that people are use to. I fear that a swarm could be terrible in its destruction if used to hurt people, individually targeted or for mass harm. [1] http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2009/05/11/how-david-beats-goliath#/9 http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2009/05/11/how-david-beats...
- melling 10y agoYeah, simply say butler next time. Someone made the joke on HN that it always comes down to people wanting a butler. In short, we're wasting our fucking time on HN AGAIN.