4 ms·
SFO BART is, in my opinion, a shockingly poorly operated line, at least for people who live on the peninsula. Suppose I want to go from Palo Alto to SFO. I ca
by amluto 10y ago
SFO BART is, in my opinion, a shockingly poorly operated line, at least for people who live on the peninsula.
Suppose I want to go from Palo Alto to SFO. I can take the Caltrain and get to Millbrae very quickly. Check. Then I can fantasize that someone would dig a very expensive tunnel from the Millbrae station to SFO and either run a train every 5-10 minutes to SFO or run one train to SFO for each Caltrain that stops at Millbrae.
Amazingly, my fantasy is half realized. That tunnel exists, is electrified, is well-maintained, and it's called the BART. For reasons that probably make sense in the minds of the mess of uncooperative local transit agencies, the train doesn't run before 9 pm on weekdays, and they steadfastly refuse to make the timing work well for Caltrain riders.
On weekdays before 9, I can still use the train, but there's an extra pointless transfer, and they still refuse to make the schedule workable.
So building the thing is only part of the battle. The transit agencies still need to make sure that the schedules and, in particular, time spent sitting around waiting for transfers, doesn't slow it down to the point of unusability.
- admp 10y agoYou probably mean 9am, not 9pm?
- deathanatos 10y agoNo, he actually does mean 9pm. It only runs late at night. Getting to SFO using public transit is a royal PITA. https://www.bart.gov/sites/all/themes/bart_desktop/img/system-map.gif https://www.bart.gov/sites/all/themes/bart_desktop/img/syste...
- djcapelis 10y agoIt's absolutely not a PITA at all if you're coming on BART from the city or the east bay. If you're coming from a Bay Area county without BART services that explicitly chose to pull out of BART and not pay into the system like the other counties? Yeah, absolutely BART doesn't serve you well. Maybe you should talk to your elected officials about why.
- djcapelis 10y agoThe people who live on the peninsula chose to pull out of the BART system. I'm sorry, but you kinda lose the ability to complain about how well it serves you and demand extra service frequency to serve a gap to another transit system from your communities when y'all explicitly chose not to be part of it. For the counties that are part of BART, the SFO connection is great.
- jrockway 10y agoFor someone that isn't from San Francisco, I feel like I have an excessively intimate understanding of the interior details of the San Bruno station. Timed transfers? What are those?
- djcapelis 10y agoTimed transfers are when the trains are timed to arrive at the station at the same time so no additional waiting is required to do a transfer. This allows transferring passengers to simply walk off one train and onto a different one located across the platform. They are common on BART where many transfers are timed transfers, but are relatively uncommon on other systems, since timed transfers comes with a large decrease in timetable flexibility which ultimately results in less system responsiveness to loading, since if a busy line has a timed transfer to a less busy line, you have to run trains at the same frequency down both lines. (BART varies the number of cars in response to passenger loading, but has less flexibility to vary the train timing.) It also requires a high on time arrival rate, since the trains need to arrive within about 1-2 minutes most times so neither train has to wait for the other. BART's OTA rate is actually pretty good and most timed transfers have both trains show up within 30-60 seconds of each other. BART only has five different lines though, which helps make this work, and also increases the need somewhat, since transfers aren't otherwise as common.
- jrockway 10y agoRight, BART is somewhat famous for the timed-transfers on other parts of the network, but they don't do it for the direction-changing transfer at San Bruno, if I understand correctly. You wait 20 minutes at SFO, then wait 20 minutes at San Bruno, and then you're in Millbrae where you get to wait an hour for Caltrain ;)
- mtviewdave 10y agoThe reason the Millbrae<->SFO connection doesn't run all the time is because it's not cost-efficient to do so: http://www.bayrailalliance.org/question/why-is-the-caltrain-connection-to-sfo-via-bart-so-cumbersome http://www.bayrailalliance.org/question/why-is-the-caltrain-... In retrospect, an Airtrain connection to Millbrae would probably have been a better choice, but the person who pushed through the SFO BART station, Sen. Quentin Kopp, was hostile to Caltrain and had no interest in making a Caltrain<->SFO connection efficient.