3 ms·
In the free market if you're a venture capitalist and your job is picking winners and you fail you've got to find another career. It's a self correcting mechan
by rmason 10y ago
In the free market if you're a venture capitalist and your job is picking winners and you fail you've got to find another career. It's a self correcting mechanism.
If you're a Fed whose job is picking winners and you fail there aren't any negative consequences for it.
I think these guys are being selective with history to make their case. There's a role for government in regulation. Government can even encourage certain industries like the $7,500 tax rebates on electric cars but not in deciding who wins and who loses. There's a role for government in financing basic research that leads to breakthroughs.
More often dying dinosaurs use campaign contributions and lobbying to protect their companies and we can agree that is wrong.
If you're an immigrant who lacks money and political connections your startup shouldn't be held back in favor of inferior technology by a Fed trying to pick winners.
- wycx 10y agoPlease elaborate on how they are being selective with their history. It is demonstrable that during the post-war period when the suggested policies were in place was the period when the middle class was ascendant and wealth inequality was lower than today. Contrast with the post-1970s when such policies were progressively abandoned, and the middle class is shrinking, and wealth inequality is rising, and the structure of the economy has changed, notably a decrease in manufacturing and an increase in the financial sector. Learn some more history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_Business_Administration#Small_Business_Investment_Companies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_Business_Administration#...
- Osiris30 10y ago"...you fail you've got to find another career"... I think thats true in a textbook theoretical sense - but not in practice. There is very little 'hard failure' which causes a VC to lose everything. Their incentive structure is not that dis-similar to a government official. The gov't official has far less upside, for probably similar downside (short-term embarrassment). Secondly - there are many cases where governments have picked winners - e.g. EU (or EC at the time) choice of 'GSM' as a mobile standard. Of course, we don't know what the counter-factual here is - what would have happened without GSM having being made a Europe-wide standard...
- flashman 10y agoYou've kind of contradicted yourself. Regulation, tax rebates and research funding are all versions of picking winners when viewed through the lens of the regulations/rebates/research not chosen. Unlike VCs, governments have other instruments besides direct investment. And they don't need to make a financial return.