4 ms·
The thing is, cable is more like the railroad than it is like Standard Oil. Petroleum isn't at all like a natural monopoly. It took a lot of corruption and brib
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
The thing is, cable is more like the railroad than it is like Standard Oil. Petroleum isn't at all like a natural monopoly. It took a lot of corruption and bribery for Standard Oil to keep competition at bay.
But nobody is really stepping forward to lay residential fiber. Google is the exception and it's because they're one of the only companies with enough money to survive a war of attrition with the incumbents, and even then it's only in a handful of places.
It's prohibitively expensive to have twelve companies each run a different strand of fiber to every house. And you only need one. The key is to a) get one instead of zero and then b) put competition on the other end of the fiber. Have one company (or municipality) be the regulated monopoly that provides only the physical layer, and then let all willing providers compete to terminate the fiber and provide internet/TV/phone service.
Separating the natural monopoly (the physical layer) from over the top services is the key to preventing monopoly abuse. The entity that does that should do only that.
- colechristensen 10y agoThere _are_ places where small companies are stepping up to place residential fiber. http://fiber.usinternet.com/ http://fiber.usinternet.com/
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoSure, on a few dozen streets in the city center in a place without build out requirements. But what do we do about the suburbs?
- Spooky23 10y agoThose are exceptions that prove the rule.
- tomkinstinch 10y agoIn Rochester, NY we are fortunate to have a local company competing with Time Warner by offering gigabit fiber to the home[1]. The local company is hugely popular, and based on their rate of expansion, very successful. When my house was built in 1890 it did not have electricity, and all rooms were illuminated by gas lights. As of last year, it has gigabit fiber. Infrastructure can change. It helps to have locals take action, and citizens have to be vocal. 1. https://greenlightnetworks.com/ https://greenlightnetworks.com/
- imgabe 10y agoTrue. I recall reading somewhere that Japan has a law requiring the owner of the physical wires to lease them to anyone as long as they pay some set fee - sort of like mechanical royalties that we have for music. This is part of the reason why Japan has some of the fastest and cheapest Internet in the world.
- warfangle 10y agoThat's called last mile unbundling, and is one thing the FCC has refused to consider. aDSL used to be unbundled, too. And while it was unbundled, speeds were increasing. aDSL speeds have been pretty flat since they removed the requirement, even though newer DSL technologies are available.
- bogomipz 10y agoYep, local loop unbundling was a thing in the US, it was basically a provision in the 1996 Telecommunications Act to promote competition. It largely worked too, you used to have your choice of 10 or 12 DSL providers in the US. You could do that with things like copper local loops, I would love to see it with Cable but I suppose theres not a good way to share the local loops in cable plant as they are mostly fiber now. It too bad EEOC(ethernet over copper) never took off.
- lstamour 10y ago> I suppose theres not a good way to share the local loops in cable plant as they are mostly fiber now Well, here in Canada they're mostly fiber also -- but it still works. See, for example, https://www.teksavvy.com/ https://www.teksavvy.com/ and https://www.start.ca/ https://www.start.ca/ ... "TPIA" is what they're called. In looking them up, I stumbled on mailing lists for TPIAs hosted by Torix. Realised at that point that TPIAs have a lot in common with Canadian IXPs -- both put pressure on prices from Canadian ISPs, TIPAs by consumers and IXPs from businesses/services aghast at how much certain folks charge. See https://cira.ca/sites/default/files/cira-ixp-overview-web.pdf https://cira.ca/sites/default/files/cira-ixp-overview-web.pd... for more on IXPs. I wonder if there's a book on this somewhere, or what ISPs think. Rogers Cable peers with Torix, so it's not exclusively smaller players, in fact I'd say it's the everybody-but-telcos club but I'm sure telcos and US players are welcome if they cared to... (let's pretend they simply are unaware of the ahem, savings...)
- dredmorbius 10y agoSee Eben Moglen's "Invisible Barbeque". http://emoglen.law.columbia.edu/publications/barbecue.html http://emoglen.law.columbia.edu/publications/barbecue.html