4 ms·
The EU telecom market is just as horrible, most countries have only 1-2 "true" ISP's with actual infrastructure to their subscribers and 2-3 cell providers the
by dogma1138 10y ago
The EU telecom market is just as horrible, most countries have only 1-2 "true" ISP's with actual infrastructure to their subscribers and 2-3 cell providers the rest are ISP's that rent fibers/coax access and MVNOs.
Setting up infrastructure is extremely expensive especially in cities where allot of the European population lives.
The US has a different problem where only 4% of the population lives in a major cities so ISP's have to lay allot of infrastructure and historically the more or less remain around their original starting zones and creep out very slowly.
Fiber/Coax infrastructure in the US should be done on a state and municipal levels and then offered to ISP's at a fixed price to recoup the costs via a tender based on the cost to the end consumer
- 0xcde4c3db 10y ago> The US has a different problem where only 4% of the population lives in a major cities That requires a rather narrow definition of "major cities".
- dogma1138 10y agoThe largest 10 cities are home to 16M Americans, the 10 largest cities in the UK are host to 12M Brits. The 100 largest cities in the US are home to 59M Americans, the 100 largest cities in the UK are home to 34M Brits. The US is 5 times as populous but there is only 30% difference between the top 10 cities in the US vs UK and 50% in top 100. Most people in the US live in cities under <100K residents, most people in the UK live in cities with over 250K residents. The rest of Europe isn't that much different. WW2 caused a major shift of population to major cities while in the US it didn't while the US population is still very urban they size of cities/towns is smaller in general. Also i really hate when people compare the US to a specific EU country the US is bigger than Europe go out of major cities in Europe and you'll have shitty internet, there are towns and cities in Germany where the best you can get is a 10mbit DSL and it's not a unique case in Europe.
- 0xcde4c3db 10y agoMany small/medium American "cities" are municipalities that are directly attached to (or even surrounded by) a larger urban area. It's basically a quirk of how local government is structured rather than anything that has to do with population or infrastructure density. For example, it's unlikely that many residents of Beverly Hills (<50K residents) think of themselves as living in a small town outside of Los Angeles.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoSimilarly, the municipalities of Boston and Cambridge remain separated by the natural border of the Charles River, even if by nothing else at all. Cambridge and Somerville don't even have that much justification for existing as separate municipalities: you can accidentally walk across the municipal border and back again without noticing it in some places.
- jsjohnst 10y agoYour numbers are way wrong, even if we discredit another commenter's point about city vs metropolitan areas. The top FIVE cities in the US total over 19 million people. If you instead use the top FIVE metropolitan areas you get just shy of 70 million. That's 20% of the US population living in or directly around the top five cities. Furthermore, there are over 300 cities in the US with populations over 100k. I'm too lazy to do the math to add it up, but I'd venture a guess than 50% of the US population lives in a metropolitan area of over 100k people. (Edit: fixed 25 for 19, accidentally added a city twice)
- jessriedel 10y agoWhere are you guys getting these numbers? The top 5 cities in the US have 19.2 M residents, and the top 10 have 26 M. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_by_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b... This one is more sensitive to noise, but still pretty different than what you quote: The top 5 metro areas have 56.9 M https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_North_American_metropolitan_areas_by_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_North_American_metropo...