21 ms·
Boston Dynamics employees were frustrated by Google's plan for a household robot
- CodeCube 10y agoWhat a shame ... as a non-psychic prognosticator, I feel like this will turn out to be a strategic error
- colmvp 10y agoI was curious as to why Rubin left Google. I found this via a WSJ article from 2014: > Mr. Rubin is an entrepreneurial spirit who likes to run his own show and was facing constraints on his activities at Google, a person familiar with the executive and Google said. A Google spokesman declined to comment on why Mr. Rubin left. > “It’s surprising and sounds pretty unplanned,” said Scott Strawn, an analyst at research firm IDC. “If it was voluntary on Mr. Rubin’s part, you would think he would see part of the robotics project through to completion to have something to show publicly before leaving.”
- Zigurd 10y agoHe bought Motorola. Even if you've made the most widely used OS ever, that's a fairly serious mistake.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoGoogle got everything it wanted from Motorola. A phone manufacturer wasn't what they were looking for.
- Zigurd 10y agoGoogle got out of owning Motorola at a $9.5 billion loss, modulo some real estate and the patents. The Nortel patent portfolio sold for $4.5 billion, which was higher than Google was willing to pay. Andy Rubin did not like what Samsung was doing with Android and wanted a captive OEM. This doubled Google's headcount, it changed Google's financial numbers materially, it cost a fuckton of money even at Google scale at a time when it was apparent that no phone OEMs were very profitable, and it was strategically incoherent. Andy Rubin was exactly the right guy to make Android a success. But buying Motorola and intending to keep it as a captive OEM was a large mistake.
- nl 10y agoWow. The Motorola patent portfolio pretty much saved Android. One might argue that he should have been more aggressive in purchasing other IP portfolios - maybe Nortel (although that may have been before he was at Google) and Sun of course. But Motorola gave Google exactly what it needed - a mature patent portfolio which other companies would have to cross license.
- ars 10y agoThis article is kinda of empty. Lots of implication, but it never actually says anything. At best as I can tell Boston Dynamics wanted to just try things, and Google wanted a household robot? Yet it also says that Boston Dynamics was worried about generating revenues in a reasonable timeframe. Very unclear.
- cLeEOGPw 10y agoBoston dynamics worked on legged robots, signed contracts with DARPA, made cool videos showing how effective they were, people got spooked by the said videos, google PR decided image might damage company's face, so they decided to not associate Google name with the videos and robots. That and the fact that Google wants robots that work indoors while BD are making pretty much outdoor robots as of now.
- XorNot 10y agoA military bot is a lot simpler to make then a household bot, ironically. Soldiers can be trained to use a tool a specific way its intended (provided it's ultimately useful). And the range of things a military bot needs to do is actually somewhat more limited to mostly the things we've already seen. I'm not really sure what a BD household robot would even do.
- cm2187 10y agoAre you kidding? For every soldier in the field, how many households would pay for having a robot to do their washing, cleaning, cooking, taking parcels, caring for the dog, etc. It's a huge market. And no export restrictions!
- vonklaus 10y agoi think the entire military spending in the U.S. was >650B. It is probably insanely hard to train a robot to walk around an unknown environment, pick clothes up, launder & dry them, and then have the dexterity to fold them. What percentage of people would buy v1 of this in america. A standard shitty top down analysis tries to capture 1% of a market. Here, your absolute max is 1%, likelely 0.01%. So, capturing 1% of the world market of people who could possibly even afford this is 80k people. assume this analysis is terrible, but you get the idea. many countries spend on military/security. This would branch into police dept ect. Obviously, this woud be terrible for humans, but a robonanny is less marketable than a military robot because the tech is there for a military bot but not precise enough to do chores, which aren't super valuable relative to en masse robot manufacturing costs.
- tacos 10y agoOf course they were. And I was frustrated (and creeped out) by their "wacky robot dog prancing through the forest getting kicked by the handler" videos. Evolution seems to tell us certain things about legs. I assume they have reasons for clinging to this approach. But it creates an obvious perception problem because, man, those videos are weird. Google's got rainbows popping out of their logo meanwhile these guys are punting pets. A culture clash surprises whom exactly?
- williesleg 10y agoGoogle purchased BD to shut it down. Like a lot of big companies both Google and Apple buy. Gotta do what ya gotta do.
- burfog 10y agoEmployees are people, with motivations. I know this may be horrifying to some, but there are those of us who would rather make a killing machine. We'll settle for a robot that carries supplies for soldiers or watches the enemy. Defense contractor employees are typically patriotic in a way that would be really alien to the normal tech crowd. Part of the motivation is to do something for the USA. Having Boston Dynamics get diverted to cutesy home stuff is a decades-long setback for the nation. There is also the matter of legs. Legs are cool. Household robots are fiddly. They have to deal with a complicated environment. They can't just look at a toddler obstructing the path and go "Fuck it, I'm blowing that away, EAT FLAMING DEATH!!!". Household robots are cheap plastic, with the shapes and colors totally determined by marketing. When you buy a company that pretty much makes weapons, what kind of employees do you think you will get? Do you really expect that they will be happy that you have "rescued" them from being forced to make killing machines? Ha, ha, ha.... NO. You took away the coolness. You took away the awesomeness.
- gyardley 10y agoI'm not so sure building a robot capable of killing toddlers 'does something for the USA' - at least not anything positive. I'm not particularly horrified by military robots, but I suspect they'd have to deal with complications and subtleties in the environment even more effectively than domestic robots in order to be remotely usable.
- dwc 10y ago> I'm not so sure building a robot capable of killing toddlers 'does something for the USA' - at least not anything positive. I think that's the point. Rather than building a kick ass military bot, they'd be building a lame domestic servant. People who thought they'd be doing the former may not find satisfaction in the latter.
- walshemj 10y agoAnd it may come as a shock those working in those sort of organisations will often look down on "commercial" developers.
- 10y ago
- dgreensp 10y ago"As a startup of our size cannot spend 30-plus percent of our resources on things that take ten years," Rosenberg said, adding that "there’s some time frame that we need to be generating an amount of revenue that covers expenses and (that) needs to be a few years." This professorial tone is baloney. "A startup of our size"? You decide what kind of giant company you want to be, Google. If you don't want to think 10 years out, why did you buy so many research labs? Own your decisions and figure out what you want.
- jonknee 10y ago... That's why they are dumping Boston Dynamics (which is the "startup" in question, not Google).
- all0fMyWhy 10y agoUgh. God. Why the fuck would Google buy, and then immediately kill the first American robot company? I swear to fucking god. Assholes need to put aside differences and make shit work.
- partiallypro 10y agoThey didn't kill it, they sold it. They might have harmed it by causing internal conflict and altering the company vision, but it's still doing fairly well.
- taneq 10y agoGoogle is seeing the writing on the wall about web ad revenue and is thrashing around looking for a replacement cash cow. Reigning in their moonshot attempts is reasonable but I think they're throwing the baby out with the bath water on a few of these.
- Animats 10y agoBefore Google bought Boston Dynamics, BD was strictly a DoD contractor. The military wants big, strong, rugged robots, and BD was headed there. (Even though the USMC rejected the Legged Squad Support System, the militarized version of BigDog.) DARPA was providing much of the funding. It took about $120 million to get to the good version of BigDog. Then Google bought six robotics companies, including BD, which dropped their existing customer base and went quiet. For several years, the robotics community was wondering what great things Google was developing. In the end, it turns out the answer was "not much". The amusing thing is that Google/Alphabet worried about their image from owning a company that makes a big humanoid robot. Google survived paying $500,000,000 to DoJ to avoid felony charges after they were caught knowingly selling AdWords to an FBI undercover operation pretending to be a Mexican drug lord trying to take over the US steroids market.[1] It's not like Google has a cuddly image. If Toyota wants a robotics company, they should probably buy Schaft, which is already in Japan, from Alphabet. There just don't seem to be civilian applications for BD's hydraulic machines. Also, it's about time for Marc Raibert, the BD CEO, to retire; he's about 67 now. [1] http://searchengineland.com/wsj-government-sting-google-pharma-ads-109247 http://searchengineland.com/wsj-government-sting-google-phar...
- notahacker 10y agoUtterly bizarre to think that Google is worried that videos of humanoid robots behaving like big dumb pets present the image of a company developing technology "ready to take humans' jobs" when they've invested so heavily in self driving cars with the stated aim of altogether eliminating a large employment sector.
- Spooky23 10y agoPerhaps they are worried about investing billions and several man-decades into tech that is producing $0 of revenue.
- Fricken 10y agoThat much was obvious when Google (Rubin) bought them. Expecting a commericial product from BD in short order is absurd. Expecting them to abandon 35 years of work on hydraulic legs and go back to the drawing board is worse. I guess we'll never know what Rubin was thinking when he went on a shopping spree with daddy's credit card; or if he was thinking at all. Hopefully Toyota will be more accomodating; and maybe somewhere in the 2030 timeframe it will be time to start thinking seriously about commercializing useful bipedal robots. A company with decades of experience mass producing machines with 1000s of separate components I'm sure will be much better equipped to handle that than Alphabet.
- zaroth 10y agoThe article claims BD didn't like Google's plan for a household robot on wheels because BD makes legs. This seems oddly specialized. The bigger topic (probably not a revelation?) is how loosely integrated the robotic purchases have been, and will this continue? I wonder how much more tightly those teams will ultimately be integrated. Acquisitions should ultimately be integrated and used to form the best teams for internal projects, you don't get the benefit of scale if they operate like an island... Sounds more like, 'Google Takes Hands-Off Approach Before Hand-Off'.
- mac01021 10y agoI get that legs require more sophisticated control software and that those sorts of control policies have get to be perfected. But aside from that is there any reason that wheels are more appropriate than legs for a household servant robot?
- pnathan 10y agoBD is the continuation of 20 years of MIT's research into working legs. I can see how dropping that might stick in their craw.
- xyzzy4 10y agoI think all of their robots have legs, and it was probably their biggest innovation.
- keypusher 10y agoThe entire BD tech portfolio is about making really good legs, including thing like balance and recovery. So I can understand how they might be a bit miffed when Google wanted them to build something with wheels.
- ommunist 10y agoLook, no SkyNet ma! They decided that making careere is way more interesting than making robots.
- ghshephard 10y agoThe entire article is very confusing re: Google/Alphabet - I thought that Boston Dynamics now rolled up through Alphabet, and was totally separate from Google. Or is the author just pretending/ignoring the Google/Alphabet reorg. Or just doesn't know? Regardless, seems like the sort of thing that should get a mention at least.
- gedrap 10y agoI think it's just that even though the company formally is called Alphabet now, people still call it Google and that's fine. Not like Alphabet/Google is working hard on rebranding or something.
- cm2187 10y agoA household robot that could - do the washing and ironing - cook meals - clean and tidy the house - take parcel deliveries - watch the house for intruders - feed and walk the dog (and tell him off if he does something bad) - change bulbs, repaint some walls while you are on holidays Would be like a new revolution similar to washing machines or dish washers, freeing up lots of people (mostly women) time and for instance giving them a better chance to focus on their career. People would be queueing to buy one. Less sexy but a much bigger market than another Terminator in my opinion.
- nly 10y agoThe problems you list (if they even are problems) are nothing to do with robotics. They're AI problems. And that's AI in the sci-fi novel sense, not the oh so hip "let's build a cluster of 10000 GPUs running a convolution network to recognise cat pictures" sense.
- cm2187 10y agoBut most of robotics is about AI. The electric and hydraulic aspects are old technologies.
- programmer_dude 10y agoI think the battery problem still remains unsolved, other than that yes it's old technology.
- cm2187 10y agoI am not sure batteries would be a problem for a household robot. There are power sockets everywhere. And the robot can take a break from most tasks to charge itself (and like a dog it would spend most of the day sleeping anyway!).
- usrusr 10y agoAn advanced household robot would not even have to take charging breaks because it would be well up to the task of plugging itself in wherever it would work (except for the dog walking part, obviously) In a similar line of thinking, I am actually kind of surprised that there are no wired quadrocopter swarms yet, that would form a bucket line of short cables to trade range for the power and infinite endurance of a grid connection. I am quite sure that there must be applications where this deal would be worthwhile.
- optforfon 10y agoahh, good ol' ageism. At least you're straightforward and honest
- ivanca 10y agoWait... if we select a 25 y.o. engineer over a 85 y.o. engineer it means ageism? We must pretend that cognitive functions doesn't decline with age? (Which has been completely proven as any biologist can tell you)
- DanBC 10y agoGP comment was 67, not 85. Can you show any links to reliable research ahowing cognitive decline is inevitable in 70 year olds? Or is that just something you know and think is obvious?
- ivanca 10y agoCognitive decline starts a lot earlier than 70, reflexes start getting worse after 25, other cognitive capabilities decay later on in life When does age-related cognitive decline begins http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0197458009000219 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0197458009... White matter damage on diffusion tensor imaging correlates with age-related cognitive decline http://m.neurology.org/content/66/2/217.short http://m.neurology.org/content/66/2/217.short Evidence for cortical “disconnection” as a mechanism of age-related cognitive decline http://m.neurology.org/content/57/4/632.1.short http://m.neurology.org/content/57/4/632.1.short I can't believe I'm being down voted for this. Is like when someone says males have naturally more upper body strength and then some feminists get mad, even when is written in a biology study about musculature. This obsession for political correctness is corrupting scientific knowledge and research.
- Spooky23 10y agoYou're being downvoted because you're hyperfocusing on one dimension of people. That 25 year old will expend many neurons and lots of that fresh cognitive capability on waste due to inexperience. Have you ever met a practicing 70-year old engineer? That perspective and experience has an outsized impact. The male vs female upper body strength thing is totally different. For one, it's measurable. Second, it's not a job attribute that is offset by expertise -- a firefighter has to be able to carry an average sized person or a roll of hose. 30 years of hose carrying doesn't make it lighter. Usually, fire departments recognize this by allowing fire fighters to retire starting at the 20 year mark.
- WalterBright 10y agoDon't really want them deciding our fate in a microsecond: extermination.
- eating_ice 10y agoSo now Boston Dynamics get to make a household robot for Toyota. Nice.