19 ms·
> The article did a great job highlighting three interesting situations and their challenges/opportunities. Yes it did and I agree with all you said. As a Ge
by weinzierl 10y ago
> The article did a great job highlighting three interesting situations and their challenges/opportunities.
Yes it did and I agree with all you said.
As a German I just wanted to point out one thing that might not be clear to many readers not familiar with the situation in Germany:
And as you said the article was "highlighting the interesting situations". These life stories are highly atypical.
Mr. Huber was an Engineer at Siemens. Even if he didn't make quite a career there, he had certainly one of the better paying jobs in Germany. He inherited a house at Tegernsee, which is wealthy area. In contrast to most other Germans he had all the chances he could have, but somehow (the article doesn't say) he lost everything.
The Ehlers' trouble started with the birth of their forth child.
Only 3.5% of all families with children in Germany have four or more kids [1].
Mrs. Kramer is seriously ill. She is a single parent but has (apparently) otherwise no family to support her. She lives in her own apartment and has a good education. Her case is certainly the most typical of all three.
What does typical poverty in Germany really look like?
15.4% of the German population is considered poor[2][3].
- Single Parent 41.9%
- Family with three or more children 24.6%
- Unemployed 57.6%
- Low level of education 30.8%
- Foreign national 32.5%
- Migration background 26.7%
[1] https://www.destatis.de/DE/PresseService/Presse/Pressekonferenzen/2013/Geburten_2012/Begleitheft_Geburten.pdf?__blob=publicationFile https://www.destatis.de/DE/PresseService/Presse/Pressekonfer...
[2] http://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/2016-02/armut-deutschland-2016-paritaetische-verband http://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/2016-02/armut-deutschland-2016...
[3] http://www.der-paritaetische.de/index.php?eID=tx_nawsecuredl&u=0&g=0&t=1465160658&hash=b1f7f86883b269c53d1a67812b32830d631b2e21&file=fileadmin/dokumente/2016_armutsbericht/ab2016_komplett_web.pdf http://www.der-paritaetische.de/index.php?eID=tx_nawsecuredl...
- rattray 10y agoThank you for sharing context, details, and links! Very helpful.
- Mz 10y agoThe article gives a brief sketch of Huber's downfall: But at the beginning of the 1990s, his life came crashing down around him. One of his main customers stopped paying. He fought for years to get the unpaid money and restructured his debt to get seed capital for his new business plan. He fought desperately -- and ultimately in vain. In 1997, he was forced to capitulate. By that point, he had already been unable to work for two years and was on welfare. He lost his family home in a foreclosure and his pension and retirement insurance plan was seized. His landlord evicted him. Manfred Huber was ruined.
- jeremyt 10y agoHe's a college-educated electrical engineer with IT consulting experience. Why can't he find a job somewhere?
- Erikun 10y agoWorth noting that Germany was considered "the sick man of Europe" due to its poor growth and high unemployment from the middle of the nineties to a bit into the 2000s. Not sure that is the entire explanation of his problems, but is probably related.
- netsharc 10y agoThe "recovery" out of that sickness is a bit fake, it's just because 18 other countries agreed to use German currency (a.k.a. the Euro) that Germany now is looking better than the rest of the continent: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jun/22/greece-eurozone-germans-single-currency http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jun/22/greece-... And Hartz IV is a neo-liberal's wet dream.
- allendoerfer 10y agoIt was more like "other countries (aka France) demanded the Germanies to join the Euro in order for them to reunite". No Euro, no reunification. The German people were really scared of joining weak currencies like the Lira and others, having gone through multiple hyperinflations historically and finally having a super solid and strong Mark. That is also why the ECB is a) independent of the member state goverments and b) in Frankfurt and not somewhere in France or Belgium like the other EU buildings are.
- eru 10y ago> [...] having gone through multiple hyperinflations historically [...] In the 20s and at the end of WWII? Any other one I missed?
- mmmBacon 10y agoGermany has the lowest birthrate in the world. It seems like the German government should create policies that encourage men and women to have more children like free/heavily subsidized daycare, tax incentives, and maybe even payments. Here in the US I can see how the Ehler's financial problems would became significant with a 4th child. But given the low birthrate in Germany it seems like Germans could be more generous to those who are willing to have more babies. [source:] http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-32929962 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-32929962
- zo1 10y agoWhy do you have to incentivise an increase in the birth rate? Why does it always seem when there is a discussion of birthrate, it's somehow automatically assumed that low-birthrate == "bad", with the obvious next point being that it has to be fixed. Honestly, from my point of view as a free-minded individual, this is exactly the sort of thing that is quite frankly disturbing about government intervention. Society is seen as some sort of grand-experiment that needs to be tweaked and prodded in order to optimize X or reduce the risk of Y, in endless different contexts.
- wolfgke 10y ago> Why do you have to incentivise an increase in the birth rate? The pension system needs a next generation that will pay when the current generation is in old-age pension. Feel free to call it an obligatory pyramid scheme.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoWhy make more babies when you can just take immigrants?
- cb18 10y agoBecause if you have an interest in Germany continuing to exist in the future, you need German people. A country filled with Arabs, Africans, and Afghans isn't Germany, peoples aren't fungible in that way.