4 ms·
>The world needs a p2p, anonymity-first, censorship resistant link-sharing and discussion site/app/thing Every single time that's been tried it tanked because
by DanBC 10y ago
>The world needs a p2p, anonymity-first, censorship resistant link-sharing and discussion site/app/thing
Every single time that's been tried it tanked because either pathological arseholes overwhelmed everyone else, or no-one wanted to use it.
But since you ask for an example that you can use: The "free" hierarchy of Usenet. It was set up to have no rules.
- visakanv 10y ago> Every single time that's been tried it tanked because either pathological arseholes overwhelmed everyone else, or no-one wanted to use it. Absolutely. I once ran a community that grew from 5 to 50 to 300+ people, and had this utopian vision that moderation wouldn't be necessary, we were intelligent, enlightened people who would have healthy discussions and hash out our disagreements in civil ways. Alas.
- intended 10y agoAH, the FIRST dream of any mod. That said, moderation and moderation tools - especially on reddit, are evolving. To the point that many issues which I thought were fatal, are now manageable (such as permanent noise to signal ratio attenuation). Unfortunately what keeps me up at night, is that the tools we are developing are straight up censorship bots and their proliferation on various subreddits, and eventually to all social platforms is beyond worrisome. Theres big brother, and then theres the more agile and nimble little brother.
- davidivadavid 10y agoHere's an idea that's probably naive and that's been tried before and failed: what about individual moderation? Let users decide: "I never want to see anything from that guy ever again" (unless, say, 50 people I've upvoted upvote one of his comments). I can see why people would want to avoid such solution, with all the "filter bubble" rhetoric, but I can't see why it wouldn't be a viable option? In fact, I'm pretty sure there's a huge opportunity in that space, for whoever nails the mechanics correctly.
- icebraining 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kill_file https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kill_file
- sgc 10y agoRES etc have this, but there are millions of users; thus I have never used it because the idea of going down that rabbit hole is rather off-putting. I like your basic premise though. There is a lot of space between reddit's "everything the mods let you see" (whether you want it or not) and facebook's "only what your friends (or Zuck) want you to see", and the two extremes cause a lot of friction. Something much better is certainly possible.
- jonathankoren 10y agoSlashdot has that with their friend-foe feature. You could assign anywhere between a +2 and -2 bonus to anyone you friended or foed. Additionally you could assign bonuses to anyone that friended or foed you. Comments only had a score range of +5 to -2 with -2 being completely hidden. So someone you foed at -2 could only show up for you if his comment got a +3. (Default view threshold is 1.)
- function_seven 10y ago> Additionally you could assign bonuses to anyone that friended or foed you. I just some nostalgia for /. from this comment. People who friended or foed you were "fans" and "freaks", respectively.
- stanmancan 10y agoSounds like this would be a solution for a small community with a low growth rate. At any scale the chances of you running into a particular user diminishes. "Ignoring" 20% of a 100 member community isn't too difficult. But if that community is >500 suddenly that becomes quite a burden.
- iza 10y agoThat's how Hubski works and it's pretty great. However I'm not sure it would scale well if it had as many users as reddit.
- aptwebapps 10y agoAt what population level did things start to go noticeably South?
- sunshiney 10y agoFor me, it happened at 325 users of a community group. Pia for sure. I truly wish people were more like cats sometimes -- a quick swipe and then friends again. :-)
- visakanv 10y agoIt would get progressively 'worse' I think from 150, 200, 250, 300. The group eventually 'died' at 300. I should've instituted clearer rules and moderations once we hit about 75, or frankly, from day 1.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- voidmein 10y ago> pathological arseholes overwhelmed everyone else How about a system like this. Something like HN or reddit, but make it read only via online. And the only way to post into it should be by sending a hand written mail, to the admins. These will not be filtered, and will be posted exactly as they are written. People will be able to see the discussions online. The original note can be optionally delivered/forwarded to the recipient (let us snail mail that too)... There will be upvotes and downvotes. But nothing will be sorted or hidden based on that. In other words, take the "instant gratification" out of the discussions, and make them more personal.
- weego 10y agoThat's because the people doing it think that decentralisation, privacy and censorship are primary features that will sell any old bullshit facebook clone site instead of being nice secondary or tertiary features underlying some new idiom that are transparent to users. Even if you managed that and then managed somehow to get funding to grow and scale for a system with no obvious revenue opportunities history shows us you are still likely to fail.