3 ms·
> [..] Google's narrative boiled down to this: because the Java APIs have been open, any use of them was justified and all licensing restrictions should be disr
by weinzierl 10y ago
> [..] Google's narrative boiled down to this: because the Java APIs have been open, any use of them was justified and all licensing restrictions should be disregarded. In other words, if you offer your software on an open and free basis, any use is fair use.
Drawing this conclusion is a bit far fetched, isn't it? I there really a basis for the idea that the very specific "Oracle v. Google fair use" verdict can be applied to open source software in general?
- threatofrain 10y agoI'm not entirely sure, but from my reading: * There were two major questions, one was about copyrights, the other was about patents. * I think that the district court believes that names and short phrases are not copyrightable. So the court excluded API names and class and function headers from the question. So a question that was left was whether the structure / sequence / organization of API's were copyrightable. * The court doesn't hold that the structure / sequence / organization of API's are uncopyrightable, just that in Oracle's case it wasn't. * I think the jury found minor copyright violations (9 lines of copied code and tests that weren't shipped in production), and I believe Oracle and Google settled those matters for $0. As a detail, the court noted that the 9 lines of copied code was written by the same person who was employed by both Sun and Google. * So the remaining question was on patents, and the jury found that Google's implementation of code underneath API calls were original. * The court phrases legal questions for jury consideration very precisely as an itemized checklist for the foreman to tally up unanimous consensus, which is left blank if the jury deadlocks. The first jury deadlocked on the most important question of fair use, and the second jury unanimously felt that Oracle did not make its case on the structure / sequence / organization. I believe one argument about structure related to whether the structure of names (which themselves cannot be copyrighted) were due to external factors of compatibility or industry expectations.