2 ms·
Let's go back to your original statement, that baited me into responding: >You even just hint that you wanna see more studies on their safety you will be torn
by epistasis 10y ago
Let's go back to your original statement, that baited me into responding:
>You even just hint that you wanna see more studies on their safety you will be torn limb from limb
So what more studies do you want to see on their safety that hasn't yet been performed, or would not be required by law for a new GMO?
You started with persecuted hyperbole, but now it seems to have come to this:
>Considering that it is indeed possible to create a harmful GMO, and considering that we barely understand how regular old nonmodified genes operates in relation to the entire organism, it is neither unscientific nor absurd to question whether subtle problems could arise from transgenetic modification
which is essentially "we don't know everything about gene regulation, therefore anything could happen." This is somewhat fallacious.
Well, really, nearly anything could happen. But it's all about chances of bad things happening. Maybe due to random quantum fluctuations, my fingernail turns into a blackhole. The risk of that is extremely small.
We spent many many decades bombarding plants with ionizing radiation in order to mutate them into better species, a roll of the dice every time. Most of these mutations were not desirable, but a very small few were desirable. Now we can be more focussed rather than just rolling the dice billions of times.
We base risk on the amount of experience we have with things, certain behaviors become less and less likely. Introducing non-native species to control some part of the ecosystem has proven to be exceptionally risky, for example. Randomly mutating plants with lots of radiation has not proven to be very risky. So far, genetically modifying them has not proven to be risky either.
If there's some potential risk that you can specifically determine that should be tested for, but is not currently, please publish your findings. But in all these paragraphs you've said nothing that would not be considered in the first five minutes by a thoughtful scientist, so I doubt that you have any deep insight here. I'm officially putting you into the nutter category. Consider this me wanting to tear your metaphorical limbs off ;) You have been vindicated in that sense...
- colordrops 10y ago> I'm officially putting you into the nutter category. Insults and invective make you come off as immature and are explicitly disallowed on HN. You should be able to stand by the strength of your argument. If you feel it is too weak so that you must resort to epithets, then maybe you should keep your comments to yourself. I said nothing that I haven't tried to reason out, and am totally open to discussion, but you don't seem to be interested in having a discussion in good faith. if an expert in programming was discussing with a beginner making wildly wrong assertions, do you think calling that beginner a "nutter" would be in order? You seem to think you have a strong grasp of the subject, and I am clueless, so educate rather than insult. I do have a response to your comment here, but I will only continue if you agree to discuss in good faith. I am not so hard headed as to be closed to new ideas, but I will not just throw everything out the window before thinking critically about the facts and understanding the merits and flaws in both my and your argument.
- epistasis 10y agoI apologize for insulting you. However, I don't think that either of us see any incentive for continuing this off topic discussion.
- dang 10y agoThis comment violates the HN guidelines by calling names and being personally uncivil. Please don't do that in comments here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html