2 ms·
I don't see any chance at all that a company could actually get an injunction against iMessage based on a few patents like this. The judge will expect the parti
by zaroth 10y ago
I don't see any chance at all that a company could actually get an injunction against iMessage based on a few patents like this. The judge will expect the parties to negotiate in good faith and come to a settlement. Apple will have to pay "a lot of money".
Could Apple not find prior art and invalidate the patent? Apparently not.
I assume a software patent in particular does not give VirnetX an absolute right to shut down a product for which it is just a small component.
I do think patent awards for component functionality do not get adjusted downward enough based on the relatively small weight of the subject matter on the overall product. When one piece of software can be covered by thousands of parents, violating a single parent should, most of the time, cost less than a small fraction of the overall value of the product.
- neurotech1 10y agoI wonder how patents like this are even valid. IMHO The patent laws should be amended to require entities to both "articulate a solution" and "add value" to make the patent valid. For ARM (described in other posts as a NPE) their patent licenses are bundled with a low-power processor core design that provides a solution to licensees requirements. The core design adds value to the basic technology covered by the patent. The VirnetX patents shouldn't be valid as they merely describe an element of a design, and not a particular means of implementation. This may fall under Sec. 112(f) "Means-plus-function" [0], but getting the patents invalidated is not easy. The EFF have tried to bust "stupid patents" [1] somewhat successfully. Please donate to support this worthy cause. [0] http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/mpep/s2181.html http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/mpep/s2181.html [1] https://www.eff.org/about/staff/daniel-nazer https://www.eff.org/about/staff/daniel-nazer