4 ms·
Unfortunately, this clause would appear to have legal backing. The Computer Misuse Act 1990 states that a person is guilty of an offence if:- (a) he causes a c
by jdietrich 17y ago
Unfortunately, this clause would appear to have legal backing. The Computer Misuse Act 1990 states that a person is guilty of an offence if:-
(a) he causes a computer to perform any function with intent to secure access to any program or data held in any computer;
(b) the access he intends to secure is unauthorised; and
(c) he knows at the time when he causes the computer to perform the function that that is the case.
The relevant wording is "causes a computer to perform any function". This is deliberately broad in order to cover botnets and the like, but would also amply cover deep linking. There is no requirement for the access to be from a computer you control, nor that you personally initiate the access; only that you caused a computer to perform an action with the intent of accessing data without authorisation.
Although unlikely, it is possible that any British website could be prosecuted for ignoring such a T&Cs clause. Prosecutions have been made under the Computer Misuse Act for very vague 'offences'.
I hope it isn't petty, but I'd just like to point out that our quaint little island does have it's own laws; I find it rather discourteous that some posters in this thread seem to have assumed that the whole of the internet is subject solely to the jurisdiction of the United States.
- njharman 17y agoA link is text, a link does not cause any computer to perform any action, a link does not even "connect" to any computer. It's static data. With proper software "activating" e.g. clicking on a link to uk mail's website may or may not cause one of their computers to perform some function. If anything you'd need a license to click links, not make them. Unless there's even crazier "contributory computer performance" language in that Legislative Misuse Act of 1990
- jdietrich 17y agoOne does not need to "connect" to a computer to commit an offence under the act. One does not even need to use a computer. Consider, for instance, an attacker writing out a paper form with an SQL injection, knowing that the form will be OCRed into a database that does not sanitise it's inputs. Nothing but graphite on paper, but clearly computer misuse under the act. I don't agree with the law as it stands, but the law was clearly designed to cover every possible circumstance of unauthorised access to a computer system. As an analogy, imagine yourself walking down a shopping street. You have tacit permission to walk through any of the open shop doors, but that permission ends at the "no entry" sign on the stockroom door. Walking beyond a "no entry" sign is trespass because you are aware that you do not have permission to enter such a place. Likewise with authorisation to access a computer system. Your right to connect to the system ends at the point where the system tells you to go no further.
- njharman 17y agoYour analogy does not follow from your description. "One does not need to "connect"", "Your right to connect..." A more apt analogy (of a link) would be posting instructions (or a floorplan/map) of how to get to the stockroom. I can believe the statute covers that. The US DRM Copyright law does similar.
- dctoedt 17y agoIf I were representing an accused linker, I'd be inclined to argue (among other things) that in view of longstanding, worldwide custom and usage: 1. Anyone who puts up a Web page is implicitly authorizing, nay inviting, all comers to access the page via normal protocols; 2. As a matter of law, the only way the implicit authorization can be negated is to deny access to the page, for example, by putting the page behind a password wall -- simply putting up a terms-and-conditions notice, that you don't even see before getting to the page, isn't enough (that's pretty much what the courts have held, at least in the US); 3. Therefore, any notice on the Web page that said "thou shalt not link to this page [or site]" would be of no legal significance. A site that said "you can't link to me, even though I'm out here in the public square, so to speak," would be like a company that decided to hold a confidential business meeting at an outdoor restaurant table, put up a sign on the table saying "thou shalt not listen in," and then sued people who eavesdropped from the next table over.