5 ms·
So you are really asking a two separate questions: Your second question is "should we implement a social engineering scheme to avoid the regressive nature of t
by 3pt14159 17y ago
So you are really asking a two separate questions:
Your second question is "should we implement a social engineering scheme to avoid the regressive nature of the sales tax"?
I say "no". We do that in Ontario and it has been such a nightmare because it distorts spending, complicates pst filing, and leads to people splitting up coffee orders at Tim Hortons into multiple bills (because a "meal" is tax as a luxury if it is above 4 dollars, and no, this was never adjusted for inflation and yes the tax applies to the whole $4.01 rather than just the cent) and other stupid things (never buy 3 muffins at Tim Hortons, you get bumped into the non-meal bracket, but buying 6 gets you the bulk discount AND exemption from the pst because your presumably buying 6 muffins to take home to your kids, rather than stuffing your face with a 3 muffin "luxury meal"). It is so stupid Ontario is doing away with it and harmonizing with the federal GST.
As for inheritance, this will just hit the lower class. Only people with enough money for lawyers will set up trust funds or "gift" their children $500k to buy their house for them. Also when you say "inheritance transfers at 99%" I assume you mean the government takes virtually all of it. If I were dying and had $100M I'd move to the Turks and Caicos and die there, where I can give my kids what I want.
As for your first question, which is basically "can we implement a simple VAT style tax (ie, tax both goods and services, but let companies deduct the VAT they paid against the VAT they collected) across everything and not greatly disadvantage the poor?" The answer is a resounding "Yes" except for a couple key conditions. First, give every adult a cheque for $7k a year if they have lived in the country for 10 months or more during that year. Don't ask for their income or anything. Then implement a 25% tax on EVERYTHING. "Ohh, but we want to encourage reading" NO! Don't let social engineering make this complicated. As soon as you bring in exemptions you bring in lobbyists, accountants, lawyers, and programming complications. All of which slow down productivity growth which, ultimately, reduces government revenue.
The second thing you need to do is issue a one time cheque to people that are retired, based on their current savings that are not in some form of non-income tax fund. The reason for this is that if someone has paid income tax their whole life and was planning on using their $200k cash they have in their bank account to live, you can't just increase their cost of living by 30% or they will starve.
That's it. Problem solved. No more tax forms, or telling the government how much you earned, or (besides the one time thing) how much you saved. No worrying about offshore bank accounts, or whether a freelancer should incorporate or not. More math brains in science and tech. More business brains in enterprise. The reason it won't ever happen? Politicians need to be busy bees.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoI say "no". We do that in Ontario and it has been such a nightmare because it distorts spending, complicates pst filing, and leads to people splitting up coffee orders at Tim Hortons into multiple bills (because a "meal" is tax as a luxury if it is above 4 dollars, and no, this was never adjusted for inflation and yes the tax applies to the whole $4.01 rather than just the cent) and other stupid things (never buy 3 muffins at Tim Hortons, you get bumped into the non-meal bracket, but buying 6 gets you the bulk discount AND exemption from the pst because your presumably buying 6 muffins to take home to your kids, rather than stuffing your face with a 3 muffin "luxury meal"). It is so stupid Ontario is doing away with it and harmonizing with the federal GST. It sounds like this is a problem with badly-engineered consumption tax, not consumption tax itself. I generally agree with your proposals. However, I don't think all forms of "social engineering" are bad. We need to make the best possible statement about ourselves as a society and what our values are, and that means cracking down on the tumors. If our rich want to behave like uncultured oil sheikhs, they can move to the desert, give up their US citizenship, and act like assholes all they want; but as long as they're in America, they'll behave themselves. The US has a problem with cultural inversion: the people at the very top of society (George W. Bush, Paris Hilton) are uncultured, mouth-breathing trashbag-fuckers, while (on the inverse) it seems like everyone must know at least one brilliant, cultured, educated people who are struggling to pay rent. This is a morale killer. It also ripples through society; the reason we have a "next-quarter" mentality in business and no universal healthcare is that uncultured trash-fuckers have too much money and power. We've got to do something about it, and preferably now while it can still be relatively legal and bloodless. I think a targeted consumption tax is great because it is completely bloodless. [* "everyone knows" clause in last paragraph edited for correctness]
- rick888 17y ago"The US has a problem with cultural inversion: the people at the very top of society (George W. Bush, Paris Hilton) are uncultured, mouth-breathing trashbag-fuckers," It sounds like you are bitter. I also wouldn't put George Bush and Paris Hilton in the same category. "while (on the inverse) everyone knows brilliant, cultured, educated people who are struggling to pay rent." If you are brilliant, cultured, and educated, chances are you aren't struggling to pay rent. If you are, then you aren't brilliant or intelligent. I also would like to hear your definition of "cultured". Some elitist douche that reads a new article on green energy or the middle east is not cultured. "This is a morale killer. It also ripples through society; the reason we have a "next-quarter" mentality in business and no universal healthcare is that uncultured trash-fuckers have too much money and power. We've got to do something about it, and preferably now while it can still be relatively legal and bloodless." You really think this is why we don't have universal healthcare? I really don't want to debate healthcare here, but I have seen it first-hand, and I don't ever want it here in the US. It also has nothing to do with being "uncultured" or "a trash-fucker".