6 ms·
Lessons from eastern Europe's flat tax
- kaitnieks 17y agoI live in eastern Europe and there is one thing that might be relevant. The flat tax here is actually progressive tax in disguise. We have something that could be called non-taxable minimal amount (sorry, I'm not an economist) which is let's say 80 Latvian gold coins (Lgc); the average salary is 400 Lgc; the income tax + social tax is roughly 32% from the amount that remains after non-taxable minimum is substracted. So effectively it would be 0% for people with 80 Lgc salary; 26% for people with average salary; 29% for people with 1000 Lgc salary.
- patrickgzill 17y agoHow long does it take you to compute and then fill out the forms for your taxes? Also, do you have to declare bank accounts held outside the country?
- kaitnieks 17y agoIf you're employed then you don't have to do any form filling at all. It's responsibility of your employer to pay all the taxes and you only get the amount after taxes in your bank account. Typically accountants do all the computing. There is an exception, self-employed people. They do have to fill in forms and compute everything but their taxes are flat, there is no non-taxable minimum. They have less total tax % but also less perks (no paid vacations or sick days etc) Update: no, we don't have to declare foreign bank accounts afaik. It might change this year because they just started taxing income from capital gains which will cause some headache for me personally.
- chasingsparks 17y agoThe U.S. flat tax proposals contain similar measures. Some even include a negative tax provision for low incomes.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoYou gotta love politicians. The discussion is about Europe's Flat Tax. But katinieks says no, it's really a progressive tax because of all the "tweaking" the politicians have done. Assuming this is correct, what do reasonable people do? Call it a flat tax and add in "but it's not really" every time it's mentioned? Call it a flat tax and have the _real_ flat tax idea be tarnished by what they've done and called flat? Not trying to get in on the discussion. As a guy who watches people talk about problems, politics always amazes me in that the language very seldom matches the underlying reality. This makes every honest political discussion a tricky search for definitions. As a side note, I've found once you get the definitions done, most people are not that far apart.
- mseebach 17y agoAll suggestions for a flat tax I've heard includes a deduction in the beginning. That's hardly tweaking, but certainly not completely flat either. I guess flat is meant to mean flat except for the part that's zero.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI don't know. Honestly, I don't. It's kind of like the "free market" discussion. Perhaps there never can be a free market? Perhaps the term is so abstract that it doesn't in fact exist anywhere and has never existed? I support a flax tax in principle. The problem is that once we start indexing the tax to the size of the purchase, or excluding certain purchases, or giving money back? Well, I might or might not support it, but whatever the case, it's not really a flat tax then, right?
- khafra 17y ago1. This is a flat income tax, not a flat sales tax. 2. Sales taxes are regressive. 3. As a general rule, if a concept is simple enough for you to support on principle, the only real-world plausible implementations will be much, much more complicated.
- 17y ago
- gnosis 17y agoLatvia isn't really in Eastern Europe, is it?
- kaitnieks 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eastern_Europe#The_Baltic_states http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eastern_Europe#The_Baltic_state...
- gnosis 17y ago"The Baltic states , Baltic Nations or Baltic countries are three countries in Northern Europe.." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baltic_states http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baltic_states
- kaitnieks 17y agoSometimes Baltic states are considered Northern Europe, sometimes Eastern Europe. In any case article mentions Estonia as well.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoI'm generally on the left, but let me ask: what's wrong with abolishing income taxes and, instead, charging consumption taxes on purchases and transfers? I may be utterly naive in my understanding, but I'd support this. No income tax at all; heavy consumption taxes. Tax private jets and true luxury goods at 95+%, food staples at 0%, inheritance transfers at 99% after an allowed small amount (handing an inheritance down to kids counts as "consumption") and general consumer goods around 30%. Real estate would be taxed 30% in general but much 75% (marginal) if the owner's real estate holdings (including the house being purchased) exceeded 8 years' median income. The tax would apply to services as well as goods, thus averting the regressive nature of the traditional sales tax. Please tell me why this is too naive to work. It seems like it would be a major improvement.
- spitfire 17y agoAnyone who has done well for themselves will leave. Those businesses that start to go well will leave. Picture the situation: You've started a company that's started to do well. You've worked day and night for years, suffering in the hopes of some payoff. Finally you can afford some nice things, then suddenly you're taxed at 95%. Makes you feel wanted, doesn't it?
- pw0ncakes 17y agoAnyone who has done well for themselves will leave. Those businesses that start to go well will leave. By this logic, why doesn't every successful Bay Area startup just up and move to Dubai? If a few rich assholes want to live in Dubai, fine by me, but the successful companies are always going to be where the skilled people are. Skilled people are where the infrastructure (education, health) is best, and you have to pay for infrastructure; that's why taxes exist. Finally you can afford some nice things, then suddenly you're taxed at 95%. Define "nice things". For me, "nice things" are good books, cool technologies, travel, challenging problems to solve, and interesting company. None of these have to involve luxury goods. My point is that we'd be taxing people based on what they buy, not their income. In other words, the tax is based on what you do with the money, not how much of it you make. If someone gets rich but is using his money reasonably, he pays reasonable taxes. If he wants to belch tons of CO2 into the air by flying around in his custom-built jet with a swimming pool in it, like a lot of the uncultured mouth-breathers in that set, he'll be very highly taxed for it. Besides, those among the rich who are ascending Society and flying around in private jets are too busy schmoozing and colluding to be building anything useful, just as authors who get sucked up into that high-society shitfest stop writing readable work. (Hard to write anything valuable if you're constantly coked up.) At this point, they effectively ought to retire. If we discourage them from being here, great! They're already past peak, and now they're just taking up space at the top. Their exodus makes room for people with talent and energy.
- stcredzero 17y agoLink has mandatory video ad. That's a deal-breaker.
- michael_dorfman 17y agoThe "flat tax" is, in my opinion, a red herring. If people want a simplified tax code, that's one thing-- but there's nothing inherently complicated about a progressively graduated tax rate. It's as simple as looking a single number up in simple table. Tax simplification has nothing to do with the flatness of the scale, and it's being used as an pretext to shift the tax burden from the very wealthy to the not-so-wealthy.
- dsplittgerber 17y agoThat is a common misconception. Flat taxes don't shift the tax burden from the very wealthy to the not-so-wealthy, as they generally include a tax free amount of income. That leads to hidden progression, so to speak. Also, the poorer you are, the less likely you are to be able to hire a tax advisor, so you cannot use all hidden loopholes etc. So a flat tax would actually mostly benefit the not-so-wealthy.
- gjm11 17y agoThe so-called FairTax proposed by some US politicians does in fact shift the tax burden, from the very wealthy and the very not-wealthy to the moderately-well-off. FactCheck, who are generally pretty reliable, have some analysis at http://www.factcheck.org/taxes/unspinning_the_fairtax.html http://www.factcheck.org/taxes/unspinning_the_fairtax.html and their second graph (the first one is from the US Treasury Department and is potentially misleading in a way described on that page) divides up incomes at $15k, $24k, $42k, $75k (I'm sure there's a reason for those divisions; are they where current tax rates change or something?) and seems to show the <$15k and >$75k brackets gaining substantially, the $24k-$75k brackets losing out, and not much difference for the $12k-$24k bracket. Later statements there suggest that the actual range in which people will pay more is something like $24k-$200k. So, it appears that at least one prominent proposal for a "flat tax" shifts the tax burden from the very wealthy and the poor to the middle classes. (I'm guessing that in absolute terms the great majority of the benefit goes to the very wealthy, though quite possibly the poor would feel it more.)
- dsplittgerber 17y ago