6 ms·
The emails themselves sent from Clinton's server were unencrypted for several months, so unencrypted printing is just more of the same. There's no reasonable q
by zaroth 10y ago
The emails themselves sent from Clinton's server were unencrypted for several months, so unencrypted printing is just more of the same.
There's no reasonable question anymore that laws on handling classified data were broken, the only question is will charges actually be brought?
- cm2012 10y agoThat server was for only unclassified data though. Some stuff was later called "Classified", but many innocuous things are classified.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI was unaware the clintonemail.com email server could differentiate between unclassified and classified content.
- untog 10y agoShe still had a .gov e-mail address. It isn't difficult to imagine there was a "confidential to @gov, all else to @clintonemail.com" rule. I'm not defending the practise, but let's not be glib.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Alupis 10y ago> She still had a .gov e-mail address She did, officially, but she's mentioned several times she never used it, and wanted to have her private email server for "convenience".
- ldness 10y agoI love her values - personal convenience vs national security. This is just the sort of person we need in the White House. It reminds me of a president (I forget which one) who tied up Air Force One on a runway at who knows what cost to the taxpayer just so he could get a haircut.
- zhte415 10y ago2 minutes of runway delays, according to the wikipedia source, the FAA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Clinton_haircut_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Clinton_haircut_controver...
- panglott 10y agoI am constantly surprised at both the vehemence and the triviality of the ire that people direct at the Clintons. There is literally nothing that people will not attack them with.
- zaroth 10y agoI have more of a problem with idling the engines while your hair is cut than of the closed runways. Today the complaint would be ecological not economical. However if idling of the engines is required by security protocols then you can't complain nearly as much. I do expect to put a ridiculous time value of money on the Presidents time and even higher on security. But it should be done to minimize inconvenience to others.
- woodman 10y agoPart of the whole security clearance process is instruction on detecting misclassification, so the :%s/SECRET/SUCRETS/g defense doesn't work. At least 22 emails where later classified as top secret, there is no way to mistake top secret material for uncontrolled information. There were at least 22 chances to take a step back and wonder about the wisdom of the thing.
- jonwachob91 10y agoLets not forget the handful (I don't recall the exact number) of emails that Colin Powell sent from his personal account and had clearance adjustments later on. Or the number of Rice's staff who received emails to their personal accounts that were deemed classified after the fact. Lots of chances for many individuals in the IC to step back and develop better procedures. Lets not put ALL the blame on Hillary.
- woodman 10y agoDo we need to preface every discussion with a list of others' bad behavior? I imagine that would distract for the topic under discussion... and you wouldn't want to do that would you?
- jonwachob91 10y agoWell, we could be superficial and only talk about Hillary. OR, and this is crazy but stay with me, we could talk about how this issue happened way back in the early 2000's and no one at the NSA/House addressed the issue then. A lot of people failed on this issue long before Hillary.
- woodman 10y agoWhy stop in the early 2000's? Surely this is all superficial if we avoid the real issue - the control of privileged information! It should be obvious how unproductive this line of thinking is, eventually we'd find ourselves debating the original sin of man.
- zaroth 10y agoWhat do you mean "that server was for only unclassified data"? There was no other server. Clinton had a .gov account but entirely refused to use it. Meaning 100% of the email Clinton sent was sent through her insecure personal server. Do you believe 100% of her email was entirely unclassified at the time it was sent? As for innocuous, it's reported that her emails (unsurprisingly) included intelligence from "special access programs" which are actually classified beyond top secret.
- cm2012 10y agoThere was another server for truly classified info + hard copies were used for sensitive stuff. Also, the official non-classified state department server was confirmed hacked during her tenure. Excerpt: How did Clinton receive and consume classified information? The Secretary's office was located in a secure area. Classified information was viewed in hard copy by Clinton while in the office. While on travel, the State Department had rigorous protocols for her and traveling staff to receive and transmit information of all types. A separate, closed email system was used by the State Department for the purpose of handling classified communications, which was designed to prevent such information from being transmitted anywhere other than within that system.
- zaroth 10y agoIt appears you are quoting hillaryclinton.com is that correct?
- woodman 10y agoThat is false. Sidney Blumenthal emailed her signals intelligence (which is top-secret at a minimum) on her unsecure server, after stripping classification markings. This has been covered pretty well, and if you want to see for yourself then you can grab a copy of the Guccifer data dump.
- x0x0 10y agoWhat laws regarding handling classified information were broken? http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-0330-mcmanus-clinton-email-prosecution-20160330-column.html http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-0330-mcmanus-clin...
- slantedview 10y agoIt depends your perspective and who you ask. The State Department was directed to draft regulations, as is common, as the result of law. The State Department says that Clinton broke those regulations. By extension, it could be argued that she broke the law.
- at-fates-hands 10y agoHere are the two obvious one, and another one that's well. . . more in the vein of the Clinton's being the Clinton's IMHO. http://www.ijreview.com/2015/03/264655-3-federal-laws-hillary-may-violated-secret-email-accounts/ http://www.ijreview.com/2015/03/264655-3-federal-laws-hillar... - Executive Order 13526 and 18 U.S.C Sec. 793(f) of the federal code make it unlawful to send of store classified information on personal email. - Section 1236.22 of the 2009 National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) requirements states that: “Agencies that allow employees to send and receive official electronic mail messages using a system not operated by the agency must ensure that Federal records sent or received on such systems are preserved in the appropriate agency record keeping system.” - MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell believes that the use of a personal emails server appears to be a preemptive move, specifically designed to circumvent FOIA:
- x0x0 10y agoNothing that links to the daily caller is a serious news source. Plus the article is a pile of stupid innuendo that conflates what Hillary did with Petraeus providing contemporaneously classified documents to his journalist fuckbuddy. Further, clearly nobody in government had a contemporaneous problem with it since they saw the email address every time they communicated with Hillary Clinton. Whenever they sent her an email, they saw Hillary Clinton <hdr22@clintonemail.com> show up in the email composition window, which certainly cannot be mistaken for a state department email...
- pbreit 10y agoAssuming the data was classified (HRC has stated that it was not), what laws were broken?
- spb 10y agoDepartment of State employees are supposed to treat any material that even could be classified as extremely sensitive, and not to leave the building. On top of the flagrant disregard for security procedure detailed in this commentary, Clinton routinely shared material with private citizens like Sid Blumenthal, who had no security clearance whatsoever. For answers to most of your questions about the Clinton email scandal, http://www.thompsontimeline.com/ http://www.thompsontimeline.com/ breaks all the factors in play here down in excruciating detail.
- pbreit 10y agoGot through most of the short version and didn't see anything about broken laws.
- na85 10y agoThere are numerous more egregious cases of senior US political officials breaking the law and/or violating their constitution with no consequences. If charges are pressed in this case it'll be because of her gender.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoBecause of her gender? No way. Because she's unpopular with a large segment of the population, and therefore has less political cover than some of those other people? Maybe. Because we're getting less tolerant of "senior officials" who can ignore the rules? Hopefully that.
- zaroth 10y agoI would say that the "3 Felonies a Day" theory applies equally if not even more-so to someone like the Secretary of State. It's probably very hard if not impossible to actually do your job as a high ranking government official and not end up breaking a few laws. The problem is once said law-breaking becomes widely reported and results in State Department and FBI inquiries, where do you go from there? How can they come back with a recommendation not to prosecute Clinton, but yet they vigorously prosecute people like Aaron Swartz? However, I do disagree strongly with you that if charges are pressed it has anything to do with her gender. If it were John Kerry who had been SoS when Clinton was, operating kerryemail.com, and he was now running for President, I think we would be in exactly the same position.
- panglott 10y agoDoes Poe's law apply here?