3 ms·
Energy may go by radius squared, but the rpms change to match. For visualization: the ice-skater who spins slowly & pulls arms in. By spinning faster, no ener
by Groxx 17y ago
Energy may go by radius squared, but the rpms change to match.
For visualization: the ice-skater who spins slowly & pulls arms in. By spinning faster, no energy is lost, as can be seen by extending the arms. However, a slower-rotating device can more easily be predicted and avoided / hand-stopped if needed.
- rbanffy 17y agoThe energy is the same. A slower moving larger centrifuge can tear your arm off with the same ease a smaller, faster one.
- Groxx 17y agoTotally agree. But a smaller, faster one is less predictable, so you can't bleed of small amounts of energy as easily / safely. Which would you rather try to stop, with your bare hands, assuming identical energy? A 1-inch pipe spinning at 10,000 RPM, or a large tire spinning at 10?
- ars 17y agoIf the energy is identical, why would there be any difference? Remember that with the larger slower RPM one, the radius is higher so the linear velocity is high too, even if the RPMs are slow.
- Groxx 17y agoOne is more predictable than the other. In that video, I can point out when the arm will come around again with relative ease, and can very easily be accurate to below a tenth of a second. Now picture it going several times faster in terms of RPM, and tell me when it'd be safe to stick your arm in its path. Lets scale it up. Picture the earth. Near the equator, the linear velocity is almost 1000mph. Scale it down to the size of the centrifuge in the video, while keeping linear velocity the same. I can easily point out when half of the earth is facing the sun. Could you point out when the centrifuge is pointing north?
- ars 17y agoIf you are planning to play chicken with a centrifuge, sure. But I am more concerned with what happens if you do actually get hit. Or if it comes apart, or falls down. And if you do get hit, or it breaks, a smaller faster one is MUCH (exponentially much) safer. The force goes up by the RPM squared, but it goes down only linearly by radius. You don't need to speed it up very much to counteract the smaller size. On the other hand the energy goes up by radius squared. Meaning the smaller size helps a LOT in terms of destructive power.
- Groxx 17y agoI've been too long out of physics, so I'll take your word on it. I wasn't sure how quickly size effected energy. Though I'll still take my chances with something I can predict if I have to interact with it. One question though: is energy->radius^2 based on angular or linear velocity?
- ars 17y agoAngular. So yes, when you increase the radius the linear velocity goes up even though the angular one doesn't change.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]