12 ms·
> it is a fact that simply letting any casual passer-by copy and distribute any creative work with impunity would That's not how facts work. You can't say "it
by erikpukinskis 10y ago
> it is a fact that simply letting any casual passer-by copy and distribute any creative work with impunity would
That's not how facts work. You can't say "it is a fact that [hypothetical scenario] leads to [expected outcome]" except in the case of very well understood mechanisms narrowly applied. I don't think the sociopolitical effects of copyright law are one of those situations.
- eganist 10y ago"hypothetical" assumes this has never happened. Copyright and patent laws came into existence because this exact scenario happened all the time. Edit: to counter DannyBee's assertion, I'm referring specifically to this statement -- "it is a fact that simply letting any casual passer-by copy and distribute any creative work with impunity would certainly work to rob those who may have spent countless hours developing such works of the commercial value of their efforts." The history of copyright starts with printing restrictions to control the flow of "dangerous" information, but the first modern copyright statute (the statute of anne) deliberately came into existence to protect ideas by granting protections to authors of content for n years. Until this point. Copyright was a grant of a printing monopoly. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright_law > The Statute of Anne had a much broader social focus and remit than the monopoly granted to the Stationers' Company. The statute was concerned with the reading public, the continued production of useful literature, and the advancement and spread of education. The central plank of the statute is a social quid pro quo; to encourage "learned men to compose and write useful books" the statute guaranteed the finite right to print and reprint those works. Comments to DannyBee's link address this mischaracterization of modern copyright history. One example: http://questioncopyright.org/comment/8491#comment-8491 http://questioncopyright.org/comment/8491#comment-8491
- Natanael_L 10y agoThat's not a sufficient answer. The claim assumes that copyright and patents are proven to be beneficial, measurably better than the prior situation. Are they? If so, how? Not to mention, is there any proof there's no better solution?
- wtallis 10y ago> The claim assumes that copyright and patents are proven to be beneficial, measurably better than the prior situation. It looks to me like he's only claiming that copyright protections mitigate a specific harm, not that they're necessarily a net benefit.
- zaroth 10y agoI think you're moving the goalposts quite a bit here! The original assertion does not assume that the current implementation and interpretation of copyright law is, as you say, "proven to be beneficial, measurably better than the prior situation." The complaint was that "that's not how facts work" but the statement in question was in fact verifiable. If you want to provide proof of a better solution, go for it. Proof that there does not exist a better solution is logically impossible, so clearly not a reasonable request. Were creative works shared, copied, and appropriated with impunity when it was perfectly legal to do so? Why, yes they were! Did the creatives lose out on monetary gains in those cases? Certainly. And copyright law evolved to solve that problem. You are perfectly free to believe it wasn't a problem in the first place, or that the medicine is worse than the disease, but I think you have to make the case for why creatives should not be paid for their work, or how else outside of market economies we should pay creatives for their work, if you believe that would be a better system.
- nightski 10y agoOne could argue whether an API is a creative work however. Are you copyrighting the syntax or the semantics? If it is the semantics, then you are essentially copyrighting a mathematical entity (a type declaration). Are we allowed to copyright mathematics at this point? Forever unto me, the tuple (Int, Int) shall be mine.
- Silhouette 10y agoOne could argue whether an API is a creative work however. True, though I suggest a better alternative is that some types of work -- in particular, those necessary for effective communication or for interoperability -- should be explicitly exempt from copyright protection, regardless of any creative element. Copyright itself is an economic trade-off, sacrificing some freedom in the interests of promoting what is considered a greater good. In the same spirit, I would argue that the ability of different parties to communicate and work together effectively is a greater good than anything copyright incentivizes and should therefore take precedence. Curiously, the US legal system already recognises a similar principle in the way it treats typefaces. I submit that analogous treatment is appropriate for APIs, file formats, communications protocols, and the like.
- thyrsus 10y ago[Citation needed]
- DannyBee 10y agoThis is 100% inaccurate Copyright law was created as a way to support a nascent publishing industry by granting it a monopoly. It was not created to help artists or whoever. http://questioncopyright.org/promise http://questioncopyright.org/promise (The history here is accurate and can be verified with other independent sources)